Siesta KeyBest lobster roll
Pin
The 25 best spots for lobster rolls in Siesta Key
When is your trip?
Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
Wanderlog staff
Updated • updatedSep 11, 2025
Updated • updatedSep 11, 2025
Are you looking for the best lobster roll in Siesta Key? You’re not alone! Many of us love traveling on the Wanderlog team, so naturally we’re always on the hunt to find the most popular spots anytime we travel somewhere new. We’ve looked through different sources to find the best options, including favorites like Siesta Key Oyster Bar, Lobster Pot Restaurant, and Captain Curt's Crab & Oyster Bar.
Visiting Siesta Key? See our Siesta Key Trip Planner.Why trust us
We scoured through the internet and read through 11 reputable sites and blogs like Sarasota Magazine and Siesta Key Island Rentals. We gathered all the results in one place and ranked them by how many times they were mentioned so you know you're getting the best of the best. Just look for the "mentioned by" tags on each place.
Curious about the sites we referenced?
Your itinerary and your map in one view
No more switching between different apps, tabs, and tools to keep track of your travel plans.
What users say about the app
Other best of categories in Siesta Key
Restaurants
Attractions
Cafes
Cheap eats
Breakfast and brunch
Bakeries
Romantic places
Family restaurants
Shopping
affordable
Oyster bar restaurant
Bar
Restaurant
Siesta Key Oyster Bar, affectionately known as S.K.O.B., is a laid-back beach spot with a covered patio where you can savor delicious seafood and bar favorites while enjoying draft beer and live music. The restaurant lives up to its name by offering an array of fresh oysters and other local seafood dishes. From raw and baked oysters to grouper bites with signature remoulade, there's something for every seafood lover.
Fresh, flavorful seafood, worth the wait!
The food here is absolutely delicious and everything we tried was fresh and full of flavor. It can get a little hectic during peak times, and things might move a bit slow since the place gets packed and the staff is juggling a lot. That said, the waitresses were top-notch: friendly, professional, and doing their best to keep up with the crowd. If you're not in a rush, it's definitely worth it!
Annie ( — Google review
Delicious grouper tacos. The best way to get grouper without overlaying for sides. Excellent service. I sat at the bar and Megan took top notch service for me.
Ambience is fantastic too. You can sit either inside or outside. I sat outside at first to soak up some sun, and then moved inside to soak up some AC and live music. I’ll be back for HH oysters.
I always love coming back to this place, it's really nice, and every time I go, even if I'm not hungry, I order the calamari. I don't know if I do it out of habit, but I love them. I also tried the oysters, and even some cooked oysters (I don't remember the name because I didn't order them myself, I think they had cheese on them) and, man, those were good too! They often have live music, which makes everything more magical.
Such a fun spot. Right off main stretch with live music. Didnt have drinks as we came in after a beach day but food was delicious. Blue cheese and bacon oysters... best oysters I've had yet. You can tell its been around for decades as the inside is covered in dollar bills and memorabilia. We will come back when we are in the areas for sure.
Lunch was good, nothing to write home about or suggest to others. The cocktails ($12-$15) were good, no cheap sugary mixes. The oysters Rockefeller were meh, just spinache, barely any crispy bread crumps, almost no cheese and very little sauce. The grouper bites were really good. The tuna and avocado BLT was also very good. Cajun Shrimp po'boy had no Cajun seasoning. Service started out good but then she would forget what we asked for and just stood up at the host stand. Wouldn't complain of we went back but would try a different restaurant next time I'm on the area.
Great local bar. Good food, a little pricey though. Great staff. Gets crowded because it's small. Always has a great band playing! Drink selection was limited on seltzers though which I prefer
For an oyster bar, we found it disappointing. The service was great, the food was ok. Grouper bites were good, the oysters not so much. The crab cakes were so so. Quesada’s were good. They were filled with cheese and veggies and didn’t dry out.
Great selection of cold water oysters, truly some of the best oysters we’ve had, period! Ordered dozen oysters (mignonette delicious), calamari and lobster roll from the specials menu. Perfect vibes and service ✨
5238 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Seafood restaurant
Family restaurant
New England restaurant
The Lobster Pot Restaurant is a charming, family-run eatery located in Siesta Village on Siesta Key, Florida. With a cozy and inviting atmosphere, this restaurant offers a seafood-heavy menu along with some Portuguese staples. Established by the son of the original owners of the Lobster Pot in Cape Cod, this establishment brings New England culinary tradition to the sunny shores of Sarasota.
We had a great dinner experience. Arrived early enough on a Friday to beat the crowd, but it filled up fairly quickly. The Village is a nice area to visit near the awesome Siesta Key beach. The food was good. My wife raved about her Salmon and pasta dish. My only constructive feedback would be that the beans were a bit boring. Otherwise, all good! Carlos was our waiter and was very professional and attentive. We'd definitely return when in the area.
Eric F — Google review
Lobster bisque is dah bomb! Had steamed clams, mussels - the garlic butter sauce is wonderful! Corn bread is outstanding. Not a full bar, but wine and beer selection fine. Micheal was our server - very attentive and personable. We’d eat here again.
We love this beach culture sea shanty of a restaurant. It has tons of atmosphere without a hint of tackiness. The beach food, particularly the hot or cold lobster roll, is a delight. The sides are also delicious.
Parking can be a bit of a challenge.
Had the Fiery Pasta Dish with Shrimp. The shrimp was large and perfectly cooked. The sauce had a sweet spice to it. I’ve never had a sauce like it but would gladly pick it again.
We had a very small intimate wedding on the beach in siesta key and have eaten at The Lobster Pot three different times already! One of them was right after our wedding and they were able to accommodate 11 of us. The owners Tony and Fran went above and beyond to make sure we had an amazing experience! On that day,our server was Allison and she did such a great job attending to our group and making sure everyone was taken care of! Great job Allison!!
The other two servers we had during our other two visits were Bryce and Dominick. Both outstanding and attentive servers with great personalities. Thank you gentleman!
This little restaurant is packed with big flavor and great servers. If you haven’t been there, I strongly recommend!!
It won’t disappoint!
We enjoyed an incredible dinner here! The Lobster Bisque is WOW good and authentic. Our server, family, was super nice and helpful. We will definitely go back before our visit to the key ends. Congratulations on your upcoming anniversary! We could see why you have been around so long.
I always like to come here to have lobster along the beach. Prices are fair for lobster and the atmosphere is pleasant. I typical sit in the open window area
I’ve grown up going here since my grandparents lived on the key. It always has the coziest atmosphere that’s inviting and the food is incredible. Service is always top tier too. The lobster bisque (with extra chunks!!) is to die for. The sangria was incredible and I had to have a second glass. I even enjoyed the cornbread at the beginning which was the perfect texture and sweetness. I’ll always be a regular here and would encourage you to make it one of your regular spots too!!
5157 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
Need a place to stay?
Where
When
Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
When
Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
When
Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
Travelers
2
Travelers
2
affordable
Seafood restaurant
Bar
Family restaurant
Captain Curt's Crab & Oyster Bar is a popular seafood spot located at the south entrance of Siesta Key, Florida. It offers a relaxed island atmosphere, delicious seafood dishes, and live music. The restaurant is known for its award-winning clam chowder and diverse menu featuring the freshest seafood selections. The nautical-themed interior and friendly staff create a warm and inviting environment for all types of gatherings.
After a recommendation from a relatives friend, we stopped by while on a vacation night in Sarasota. The service was stellar, food and drinks came out quickly and was hot and fresh. All the food was good but I could have eaten a vat of the clam chowder!
So tasty, full of clams, and a rich mouth feel that is rare with restaurant chowder.
The fried pickles were amazing too!
Karinna was our server, and she helped us find just what we wanted both food and drink wise. Give that girl a raise !
S S — Google review
Captain Curt’s was a gem hidden in plain sight. Food was awesome, games playing on the big screen and the breeze off the ocean made it perfect. Really had a great lunch. Seafood extravaganza was a giant fried seafood plate, everything was delicious however the star of the show was the clam chowder. I tend to be skeptical when dishes are labeled best in the world however I agree one hundred percent, that clam chowder was so good!! Drinks were strong too, strawberry banana daiquiri was recommended and didn’t disappoint. This will be my first stop on our trip back to Siesta.
I dined in for lunch. Food was excellent, especially the chowder clam soup. It is a must try. Apart from that , oysters and crabs were fresh and tasted great. Highly recommend this place. ❤️
Mike, the gentleman who seated us, was incredibly friendly and gave us great insight into the menu and the most popular dishes—he did not disappoint! René, our server, was fantastic—he took our order and brought everything out quickly and efficiently. This spot is definitely a must-visit! My family is more than willing to drive 1.5 hours for a beach day just to come back and enjoy a meal here again.
The food was absolutely delicious — everything we ordered was spot on. We sat outside, and even in the midday heat, the outdoor seating felt fresh and comfortable. The frozen drinks were a highlight: tasty, refreshing, and not strong, perfect for a casual lunch.
*Clam chowder is a must try*
The only downside was the service toward the end. My daughter and I were having a nice conversation and considering ordering another drink, but after we declined dessert, it felt like we were being subtly rushed off our table. It changed the vibe and our plans a bit, which was disappointing.
Overall, we’d still come back for the food and atmosphere.
They claim that they have the best New England Clam Chowder and as someone who grew up in New England I agree!! It's amazing!! The other food was really good too, and the service was awesome!!
First time visiting Captain Curt’s and the food was great! We did a quick lunch break during work and they made sure we were not waiting too long. The staff was super friendly and the food was good. We had the crab cakes, peal and eat shrimp and the fried clams. Highly recommend the clams!
Highly recommend potential diners to this establishment. The service from the start is attentive and quick. We orders clam strips and fried shrimp basket. My son finished the meal in 10 minutes. Another dish include sea scallops and shrimp and the broiled sea scallops were melt in your mouth experience. Another dish includes Alaskan snow crab and there was a ton of meat. We will dine here again next visit at Siesta Key.
1200 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Restaurant
American restaurant
Japanese restaurant
Latin American restaurant
The Cottage is a fusion restaurant located in the heart of Siesta Key Village, offering an eclectic dining experience with an elevated tropical vibe. The menu features dishes with American and Japanese influences, crafted using ingredients from local farms and sustainable seafood. The restaurant provides a warm and welcoming atmosphere, ideal for both upscale dining and casual occasions. With indoor and outdoor seating, it caters to all-American tastes while embracing flavors from around the world.
This place is amazing! Food, atmosphere and service were all top notch!
We had a very large party and service was still fantastic. Scallops, tempura shrimp, poke bowl , grouper sandwich and scampi were all excellent. But the best thing we had hands down was the lobster bisque and the lobster sushi roll. May be the best of both that I’ve ever eaten and I have eaten a lot of bisque! Prices aren’t cheap but this is a “you get what you pay for” kind of situation. Highly recommended!!
Scott K — Google review
We were greeted and seated immediately. We ordered the Plantains off the Tapas menu. They were served with crispy cancha (corn nuts), chimichurri, and huancaina sauces. I had the Black Mussels for my entrée and my husband had the Diver Sea Scallops. I also ordered a side of Truffle Fries because why not?! Every single dish was delicious!! Our waitress, Monica, was attentive, knowledgeable, warm, and friendly! We will definitely request her again if we ever come back this way. 10/10 recommend!!
This place is amazing!!! They’ve got an awesome selection! Also love the indoor and outdoor seating. The food is flavorful, and I loved every dish we picked. The servers were kind, patient and attentive. I’d come back here! Definitely recommend! Love!
I recently visited The Cottage and had a pleasant experience overall. The staff was friendly and attentive. As for the food, it was good. The plating was nice, but the garnishes on several plates looked a bit tired and not as fresh as I would have hoped. That slightly took away from the visual appeal of the meal. It was an okay dining experience. Worth a try if you’re nearby and want a casual bite in a nice setting.
We had eaten here during g our last visit to Siesta Key and really enjoyed it so it was an easy decision to go back again for lunch today.
It’s normally too hot to eat outside in Florida restaurants in August but due to the large canopy we were able to do so without getting g too hot - the many fans helped!
The staff were so friendly and helpful and we were soon sitting down with drinks trying to decide what to eat from the large menu. It was lunch time so we’re looking at sandwiches, burgers etc - we decided on the grouper sandwich and the seared tuna club sandwich with both of us upgrading to the truffle and Parmesan fries. The food was absolutely great - so tasty and the fries were a revelation!
Just about the right quantity for lunch so didn’t have a dessert.
Happy to come back
We had an amazing time, food was delicious. Amosphere was super cool and great location, very close to the beach. Will definitely come back. Strongly recommend it!
Wonderful tiki bar with friendly service and great bites. Excellent service from the Bartender Rudy and the Manager Tiffany, along with the awesome live music truly made for the perfect atmosphere and fun night out with my Husband.
My friend and I visited The Cottage multiple times during our week in Siesta Key, and every single time it felt a bit like walking into Cheers. Everyone was genuinely excited to see us. The entire staff was, without a doubt, the friendliest and most personable team we encountered on the Key. A massive shout-out needs to go to Kyle, who was a true standout for "adopting" us and taking such good care of us throughout our visits.
The curated menu is fantastic. I highly recommend the tuna tacoshimi, the mussels, and the rich, delicious lobster bisque. They were all instant favorites. And for drinks, their mai tai is a must-try. The quality of the food combined with the welcoming atmosphere created by the staff makes this place unforgettable. If you’re looking for great dining and even better hospitality in Siesta Key, you have to stop by The Cottage. We can’t wait to return!
153 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Seafood restaurant
Fish & chips restaurant
Fish and chips takeaway
Restaurant
Spearfish Grille is a warm and inviting restaurant located in Siesta Key Marina, offering a delightful dining experience for both locals and visitors. Since its opening in March 2018, this eatery has been dedicated to serving the freshest locally caught seafood with creative twists on classic dishes. The menu features a variety of grilled and fried seafood plates paired with flavorful veggies and street corn.
Spear Fish Siesta Grill serves up very good, incredibly fresh food with just the right amount of seasoning. The fish tacos stand out—they’re a bit different, served over a flavorful base of beans and Mexican corn, but the twist works beautifully. Everything tastes clean and well-prepared, with fresh vegetables that add a crisp, healthy touch to every plate. Definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for a fresh take on coastal favorites! Small little fun place :)
Jana G — Google review
My mom and I just arrived in town from Orlando and I found this restaurant on Yelp. It was a great experience! Our waiters were so funny and polite! Thank you for taking care of us!! Jeremy is the best!
As a business owner, I know how important great service is — and Jess and Gio absolutely delivered. Their attention to detail, friendliness, and genuine care made our visit to Spearfish Grille outstanding. It’s rare to find people who make you feel both valued and welcome, and they went above and beyond. The food was excellent, but their service truly set the experience apart. Highly recommend!
The food is beyond delicious and Jeremy provided us with excellent service and jokes! We waited less than 10 minutes for our order. Loved their grouper sandwich, the sushi nachos and the salted caramel cheesecake, which is to die for! Will definitely come back.
Beer wise, they give little paper cups to try it (like as a sample). They give out free water as a starter drink, live music, live games on TVs, and fresh fish caught by the restaurant owners and employees (not market bought). Not a whole lot of decorations but nice and outdoor atmosphere. Outdoor air conditioning so it’s good to eat outside even in 85 degrees Fahrenheit. Silverware, a napkin dispenser, salt and pepper, and bottle of ketchup at each table. It’s not exactly an amazing place to have a quick snack but if you are willing to wait, you will be rewarded with an amazingly cooked meal. Have something specific you want? You can customize your meal entirely, as long as they have the ingredients. Recommend
The Spearfish Grille is easy to get to and sits on the water by a boat marina access. Parking is all over and can be free or paid for. It was over the top busy when we visited. They do not take reservations. We got there around 630 PM and waited for 10 minutes to be acknowledged to actually get a seat. They took our name and seated our group of 6 quickly. There was a singer playing a guitar with 80s/yacht rock and not too loud. Then we waited. And waited. And waited. So, if you go, be prepared to wait. No fault of the staff as they were hopping, and the place was busy. Menu pics show the options, with fresh fish available daily with different options. The Hogfish tacos were very good, clean, and refreshing. The only thing was that the sweet potato fries came out cold and rubbery. Overall, the location was nice, the parking was ok, the service was slow, the taste and flavor ok, and the price was around $330 for 6 people. For an average of $50 a person, I was expecting more, and ended at 4/5 stars.
Our first visit to this incredible restaurant was nothing short of phenomenal. A gentleman who took us parasailing highly recommended it. We were warmly welcomed by the radiant Jasmine, whose infectious smile and warm personality set the tone for an unforgettable experience. With her vast knowledge, she graciously answered our numerous questions about the fresh catches and menu, offering expert suggestions that proved to be pure perfection. We're forever grateful, Jasmine, for your exceptional service, uplifting smile, and genuine hospitality. We can't wait to return next year and request the pleasure of your service again.
On our recent trip to Siesta Key, we ended our trip with dinner at Spearfish Grille. In hindsight, we should have started AND ended at SG. It was a great experience and, for our family, a great environment to eat great food and enjoy good music.
The four of us disagreed on what to order so we ended up ordering 6-7 things to cover everyone. That was a good move as everything was really good. Started with the Tripletail Ceviche, Ahi Nachos and Coconut Shrimp. The ceviche was as fresh as you get, the sauce on the ahi nachos was sweet but not overpowering and the coconut shrimp were perfectly fried. For entrees we went with multiple Fresh Catch plates (Grilled Hogfish & Blackened Grouper) with Potato of the Day (mashed on our visit), Roasted Root Vegetables (Beets) and Fish and Chips (Snapper). The fresh fish plates were amazing and the portions were large. The F&C were great and only lightly breaded so the snapper stood out, not a pound of beer batter.
The outdoor dining was perfect with the breeze coming in to cool things down. The live music was fun and complementary. The service was great and attentive. Even though they were busy (the entire outdoor area was full at 6:00), our server was on it and delivered a great dining experience. You could tell the team was focused on CX and were passionate about the food.
I’m not a big fan of 5-star reviews as it skews reality and waters down the effectiveness of Google. In this case though, Spearfish Grille nailed it and deserves 5 stars. Thanks for a wonderful time. We will be back for sure - first AND last meal of the trip.
1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
Create your ultimate travel itinerary
Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.
affordable
Restaurant
Bar
Seafood restaurant
Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village is the ultimate late-night destination for those seeking a laid-back vibe infused with fun. This lively bar and restaurant is renowned for its creative frozen daiquiris, including the infamous Deck Diesel—a tantalizing mix of orange, vodka, and grain alcohol that packs a punch.
With so many little restaurants to choose from in the village on Siesta Key you would be wise to give this place a try on your next visit. From the outstanding service to beach atmosphere without being on the beach, it is worth it.
For starters, the service was exceptional, and our server was consistent in ensuring we were doing okay. My wife ordered fish and chips and let me tell you, their chips are truly delicious.
The burger I ordered had a definite seasoning to it that has made it one of my favorite burgers on the Key, and in Sarasota.
The only real downside to this location, and pretty much every other restaurant in the village, is parking.
K M — Google review
We arrived right at 3:00 to begin the happy hour. They didn't seem to have very many servers so it took a while to get served. Our server was very knowledgeable of the drinks that were available and the flavors. Our drinks were delivered cold and ready to drink. Although you might want to mix it a little bit.
This bar & restaurant is SO CLEAN. The staff are friendly, the service is quick and the food is what you’d expect from a beach bar. So many choices. It’s not often you find such a clean and well run beach establishment. The bartender is always cleaning and helping bus tables for wait staff. Can’t recommend enough !
Always go here. Food was great and our waitress Brook was wonderful. Always smiling and was super friendly she checked in on us frequently making sure we were having a good time and everything was to par. Very attentive. I had the coconut shrimp was delicious and the nachos. Best I’ve had on the Island. Be back soon.
Ray is an amazing bartender. Love the atmosphere, grouper fingers were on point, we'll be back for sure!! 😁
I had Shawn as a my waiter and he is the best waiter I have ever experienced on top of are orders with the best customer service and positive you guys are truly blessed to have such an amazing employee I will be coming back frequently for his wonderful service hopefully I get him as my waiter every time
This is a very typical, beachy, touristy place. It's right in the heart of the restaurant / bar / shopping district. Open air, a lot of different types of seatings, large menu (but very typical fried bar food). Loved their daiquiris and when I go again I'll try different ones. I do believe you can combine different flavors together. Come as you are. It is a very loud busy place so if you want something more low key this probably isn't the place for you.
Really like this place, my go to every time I'm visiting the area... The Gator bites were delicious as always
5250 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
Seafood market
Seafood restaurant
The Big Water Fish Market is a wonderful spot for fresh seafood on Siesta Key. They have a full-scale fish market where you can buy fresh fish to prepare yourself, and they also have a restaurant where you can enjoy prepared dishes with seafood. If they don't have what you're looking for, they won't sell it!
Absolutely a great place!!! It’s a little hole in the wall that only has 6 tables and a little bar, but the food was incredible. We had the crab cake appetizer and seared Tuna tacos with hush puppies, the Tuna was soooo good, the fish tacos are really good and they have a great option for sides, we had cucumber and tomato in a balsamic reduction. The fish and chips are fresh and hand battered. We had to try the key lime pie it’s their mom’s recipe and it did not disappoint. Our server was friendly and helpful with the menu options. I would definitely recommend finding this place and trying it out!!!
Bill G — Google review
We stopped here per a friends recommendation and we had planned to only stop here once during our 4-day visit and try the other restaurants in the area, but that quickly turned into 3 visits in 4 days. no other resturant in the area compared!! the food was exceptionally cooked and seasoned. Our server was a rockstar as she was the only server had had for each of our 3 visits and she killed it!
Big Water will be a staple for every visit to siesta key from here on out!
Absolute FAVORITE place during our vacation. We ate 3 meals there in a week's time. Had oysters on the half shell, seared tuna tacos, key lime pie, hot pot I think it was called (it's like a crab boil), shrimp tacos, fish tacos, crab legs, hush puppies, caeser salad with fresh anchovies, seared tuna appetizer + siesta key light beer & a local IPA that was on tap. EVERYTHING was mouth watering. I was a walking ad all week letting people know about it. Thank you for the fresh fish, cool atmosphere, and great customer service! Cheers!
If you are looking for a DDD place, this is it! Not much to look at but outstanding food. Great portions also. Crabs legs, fresh fish, shrimp, and salads are all top notch. They have some outside seating. We came for lunch. I highly recommend this place.
Great spot for fresh, delicious seafood! Sit down and enjoy a lobster roll, fried shrimp and fresh fish tacos and or grab some fillets from the market to take home. Cold local beers on tap! Awesome place inside. Will return.
Found this gem of a place. Where have I been?? 😂 Had the Siesta Key Club, absolutely amazing!! Service was awesome as well, thank you "Bubbles"!! I will definitely be returning to try more on your menu!!
Tiny place, but just look at these portions in my photos. My fish doesn’t even fit on the plate. And my wife couldn’t finish hers. My son got the grilled cheese. Very good!
My goodness, the food was good! This is a little out of the way shop that is definitely worth the stop! But what I really want to rave about are the people who work there. In my not so smart move, I hung my purse on my chair, thereby forgetting it when we left. Of course, I did not have any contact information inside. And to make matters worse, I didn’t realize I left it until several days later as I packed in early morning hours to return home on an early flight. When we landed in Michigan, we called the restaurant and Jenn, the manager, said that, yes, my purse was there. I asked if she’d be willing to ship it to my home, using the credit card I had in the purse to pay. Within a few days, it arrived! When you think of all the people who had access to my credit cards (our waiter, other workers, and management), each person was honest and full of integrity and I am incredibly grateful. Additionally, I offered to Venmo Jenn some money to compensate her time at the post office and she rejected my offer.
Thank you for making the world a little better Big Water Fish Market employees!
6639 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
Seafood restaurant
Fine dining restaurant
Steak house
Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood is a stylish and elegant eatery that offers sustainable steaks, seafood, cocktails, wine, and beer. Located at 149 Avenida Messina, this restaurant provides a refined dining experience with hand-cut steak and seafood selections in a coastal-chic setting. The establishment boasts a remarkable 1,000-gallon on-site fish tank that spans 14 feet.
Summer House in Siesta Key is a must-visit! The ambiance is lively and energetic, perfect for a fun night out. The food was phenomenal—the ceviche special was fresh, unique, and bursting with flavor, and our steaks were cooked to perfection. What truly elevated the experience was the exceptional service. Our server, Derek, was outstanding, tailoring recommendations to our preferences and even letting us sample different steak sauces. His attention to detail made us feel truly valued. Highly recommend!
Ashraf H — Google review
Overall, I had a very good experience. The hostesses and my server, Julie were friendly and attentive. A gentleman, I assume a manager, checked on me once my entree was served.
The bread, lobster bisque and grouper were outstanding.
The only miss was the bone marrow. It was oily and lacked flavor.
I would highly recommend SH to anyone looking for a higher end dining experience in Siesta Key. Cheers!.
Three of us enjoyed our dinner in here , we ordered the seafood platter and 40 ounces steak, seafood is fresh, steak we asked for medium well , prefect! Smile service around our table, Valet parking also helps us save a lot of time in this area. Appreciated!
Outstanding place!!! First timer, actually went two nights!!! The staff are amazing, the food is amazing!! I had fillet mignon one night cooked to perfection. The Top sirloin wagyu was unbelievably good on our second visit. Not big on sirloin, this is a must. The management worked with our party of six to get us in on a last minute decision on a Friday. I have eaten steaks at some of the top rated in the country, hands down one of the best!!!
Amazing! Perfect for an upscale dinner or celebration. The atomsphere is elegant but casual. Very comfortable
Everything we had was incredible. Our server Derek was great- efficient, personable and made excellent recommendations. Pictured : the seafoam margarita (I don’t know how to describe this other than the name being perfect for the drink.. )topped with lime/ eggwhite foam and siesta key harvested sea salt 10/10
Wagyu tartare with bone marrow grenota
40 oz Porterhouse with Gorgonzola crust - INCREDIBLE!
And of course, when in Rome… key lime pie. So yummy
Will return on my next trip to siesta key :)
To start with, Derek was our server who delivered with flair and the utmost professionalism I haven’t witnessed in a long time. Derek asked for our names and engaged in conversation that was pleasant and legitimate. A thorough explanation of menu items and the background to the Chefs vision.
We started with colossal shrimp and crab cake as appetizers to which both were fantastic. We then entered into our main course of wet aged NY strip steaks that were both tender and delicious.
A complimentary dessert was provided as Derek admitted me dropped a small, bite size morsel of steak.
The ambience, food and service was IMHO, stellar.
The manager, Thai, even came by our table and engaged with us which sealed the deal.
We will definitely by coming back for more food adventures.
Absolutely fantastic experience! The waiter was awesome & the manager stopped by our table to say happy birthday. We would definitely recommend this place for your special occasion date night!
Top notch service every time my husband and I come here. The bleu cheese crust is unlike any other, and the cocktails are delicious! We make sure to reserve a table weeks in advance before our annual trip and it’s always worth it.
149 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Bar & grill
Restaurant
The Hub Baja Grill is a lively and vibrant restaurant located in the heart of Siesta Key Village. It offers a tropical-themed atmosphere with indoor and covered patio seating, perfect for people-watching along Ocean Boulevard. The menu features Mexican-inspired dishes and an array of margaritas, including the popular Cadillac Margarita made with Patron Anejo tequila.
I had low expectations for a busy spot right on the main street, but we were very pleasantly surprised about the food, drinks, and the number of gluten free options. First of all, get their yummy margaritas. Different but in a good way. Try their signature one and the coconut one. We had the chicken bowl and the taco plate, and both were very tasty. The live music was great too.
Thomas G — Google review
This was my first time trying this. We saw this place walking around the village and wanted to give it a try after viewing the menu. They have a great variety of tacos. We got mahi, shrimp, and tuna tacos. We also had an order of the smashed burger and fries… both were great! The tacos were enjoyed with the complementary rice and beans but I have had better at other Mexican places. The place is well located and the service was fine. Prices were good. Overall, it’s a nice place to go if you’re looking for a tasty spot in the village!
Our server was Kameron and he was fantastic! I am a vegetarian and he got the kitchen to make a special meat-free version of the nachos. Apparently the restaurant has two different types of tortilla chips. I didn't even know that, but Kameron brought them both out for me to try before he put in the order. The nachos were really good, the service was phenomenal, and they had a good selection of beers too (I got a hazy IPA). On top of that, the live band was great. We had a wonderful night.
Decent food for a busy strip restaurant but not authentic. The drinks were great though. We were surprised to see they charge for chips & salsa. They live music was a good touch.
Great casual spot for tacos and local eats right on the main strip and not too far from the beach. Started with the house margarita and got a half Tajin and half salt rim. tasty for sure but too much orange juice for my liking so it was almost like a different drink entirely. All three tacos we got were tasty but the tone poke was the standout. Rice and beans were ample and super tasty. Blackened grouper sandwich was delicious but didn’t care for the sweet potato fries as they were tossed in some sort of sugar. Way too sweet as a side. Server very attentive and friendly. Fun spot for sure.
Short walk from Siesta Key Beach.
Indoor/outdoor with live music.
Good food.
Came here after looking over the menu and reviews.
Service may have been a 1 off, but we were seated and left there for a good 10 min watching others get seated and eventually served. It seemed like they either had the bus boy take care of us, or he was from the other side of the restaurant. Drinks weren't refilled, slow all around, drink orders weren't put in.
Will not return.
Came here after checking out a few options in the area.
This is a popular spot that provides fun music while you dine.
We ordered drinks that included a margarita, which I was told was "great!"
We also ordered nachos, which were not as hot as I preferred and they were okay.
However, when our main courses came out to the table we were very happy.
My partner got the Chicken Bowl and she loved it. When I took a bite of it - I thought the flavors were good and I recommend it too.
The biggest thing is that my main meal hit my side of the table. FYI - I have a habit of seeking out things on menu6 that I have never tried before and on this night it was a great success.
The Birria Burger is positively AMAZING! The first bite I took was just as the burger was presented on the plate; respectfully, I was not entirely sure what to think of it at first but that's not to suggest that it was bad or disappointing. Then I dipped it in the accompanying sauce where it felt like the heavens opened up and the angels revealed a culinary party in my mouth!
Try to imagine a next level chilli cheese burger and that somewhat comes close to this fantastic sandwich. Honestly, my only complaint about this burger was that I was too full and couldn't make way to order a second one.
Finally, my partner finished the meal with a strawberry and jalapeno margarita, which she also loved the combination of sweet, sour, and spicy all at once.
I definitely recommend giving this place a try.
Nice out door seating and with a band playing island music. Service was quick and was not typical cheap beach food. Not the best food ever but certainly better beach food that I have had. Mostly Mexican and sandwiches here. Reasonable price for food and drinks for a tourist area. Margarita was tasty except they put OJ on all of their margs so ask without it.
5148 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Seafood restaurant
Bar
Walt's Fish Market Restaurant is a historic seafood spot that has been in business for over 100 years. Originally established as a fish market in 1941, it has evolved into a full-service restaurant and fish market. The restaurant offers fresh seafood meals, including gator bites and hush puppies, while the market provides patrons with the opportunity to purchase fresh fish for cooking at home.
We were pointed toward Walt’s by some friendly locals while out playing pool, and I’m so glad we took their advice. From start to finish, this place delivered big-time.
We kicked things off with the Oyster Rockefeller, which set the tone, fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. For the main course, our group went all out and shared a variety of dishes: the Alaskan Fish & Chips, Captain’s Platter, Charred Grill Plate, and the Raspberry Chipotle Scallops. Every single dish was fresh, well-seasoned, and cooked just right. You could taste the quality of the seafood and the care in the kitchen.
We wrapped up the meal with their Key Lime Pie and Bread Pudding, both were a perfect sweet finish to an incredible meal.
If you’re in the area and want true local flavor with great vibes and even better seafood, Walt’s is a must. Trust the locals on this one!
Joel C — Google review
Nice local vibe. The food with good (not anything to write home about… but good enough). We had a great time over all and the waitress was very nice. This is a place we would go to again if we lived locally, it was worth the trip for sure.
Had such a wonderful lunch here today - we got the clam chowder, peel OBG shrimp app, grouper bowl, steamed snow crab & blueberry cobbler cheesecake and everything was cooked so well and was delicious! We had great service and everything was very clean as well. Fun beach vibes inside make it a really great lunch spot, highly recommend!
Absolutely a must eat restaurant in Sarasota. We stopped here on the way to Siesta Key beach and we enjoyed our lunch so much. Everything was delish. Lobster bites is to die for. The cocktail was strong and nice. Very friendly staff. Strongly recommend.
This is a great local place to enjoy seafood!
The service is good.
The atmosphere completely fits the food.
The meal is exactly what many want when we visit the beach.
The one downside is that there was a guy smoking around the outside seating area, which did take away from the dining experience.
If you love seafood, then make time for Walt's Fish Market!!!
Loved it, the fish spread was delicious. We had a party of 5 & enjoyed the Bob Pot for 2, Captains Platter, Alfredo for or non seafood eater and chicken tenders for the 6 year old. We all loved what we chose, we will definitely come back next trip
Had a great lunch. I had grouper tacos and husband had grouper sandwich. Recommended although I had a little bit of sticker shock. One soda only and it was 65 bucks with the tips. Great food though.
The food delivered great value for the price and brought back memories of the seafood joints I grew up with. The lobster bisque was hands-down the best I’ve had in Florida—rich, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. My brother was equally impressed with his Paella, calling it spot-on.
If I had one suggestion, it would be to season the fish a bit more before cooking or breading—it could use a touch more salt to really bring out the flavor. As for drinks, my wife ordered a Piña Colada, but it tasted more like a blend of alcohol and ice than a proper cocktail. We swapped it out for a margarita, and that was a total win—smooth, refreshing, and exactly what we were hoping for.
4144 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL 34231, USA•
Create your ultimate travel itinerary
Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.
affordable
Restaurant
American restaurant
Fine dining restaurant
Clayton's Siesta Grille is a charming eatery located just minutes from Christopher Wheeler Park on Old Stickney Point Rd. The restaurant offers a cozy and art-filled space with a spacious patio overlooking the water, making it an ideal spot for families looking for casual or fine dining experiences. Known for its creative American cuisine with Mediterranean influences, the menu features wood-fired pizzas, fresh seafood, and rotating specials that have made it a local favorite.
This is our 33rd anniversary weekend. While on the beach my wife made reservations online at Clayton’s. Unbeknownst to me, she let Clayton’s know this was our anniversary dinner. When we got to the restaurant Marin, the hostess congratulated us for our special day. We then decided to have a drink before dinner when our bartender Luca, again congratulated us for our anniversary. As we were finishing up our cocktails, Mavis, the owner/manager came over to talk with us and once again told us how much she appreciated us having this very special dinner at her restaurant. After being seated, our server Luca echoed the same message as everyone else we came in touch with, sincere appreciation for celebrating our special evening.
The cherry on the milkshake was when Mavis personally brought out a special treat for us just before desert. Another great big shoutout to Marin for the picture as we were leaving.
Thank you Clayton team for making this one of the best evenings ever! We appreciate each and every one of you!
BTW, our meals were A+++!
David V — Google review
Ate dinner here on a Monday night and had a good experience. The free bread appetizer is SO good; the bread (and butter) are flavored with herbs, so it’s better than the typical bread. The mac n cheese appetizer was also great; I just wish it was bigger, as it was gone in a matter of seconds with only 2 people sharing it. The pappardelle was decent, but did lack flavor; it tasted similarly to the plain noodles covered in butter that I ate as a kid. My husband’s red snapper on shrimp risotto, the fresh catch of the day, was delicious. The waiter was nice/personable and, with my reservation, we were immediately seated, even though parking was really limited. The restaurant atmosphere was nice, though nothing special, and lacked a waterside view. Overall, I’d definitely recommend this place and come back, but I’d order something else besides the pasta.
Great spot with a fun atmosphere. My wife and I had dinner at Clayton’s on the 4th and it was an excellent meal. The Grouper and Calamari were delicious. We would definitely come back!
Absolutely the best and freshest food! Everything tastes so homemade and yummy and the place is adorable and quaint! We love to visit this restaurant often, we like to ask for Jacob! Excellent server always! Barbara is fantastic too! They all are good, but we feel special when we get them! They have a well oiled machine at this restaurant and that’s what we like about it, so organized and perfect every time we eat there! We will be back again and again!
Food and service were both amazing! Jacob took great care of our family of 5. The chefs special was excellent. Our family ordered 5 different meals, and all were amazing.
Went to a high rated local spot last night which greatly disappointed. Spoke to some locals at the beach and they recommended this place so glad we came. It was fabulous. Five stars all the way around.
Luca was a great waiter!
We had the macadamia crusted grouper and the Moho roasted chicken and they were both amazing!
The crème brûlée was a great dessert!
Amazing food and value. Coconut shrimp was amazing. Filet cooked perfectly. Chocolate martini on point! We will be back
1256 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Cafe
Breakfast restaurant
Brunch restaurant
Lunch restaurant
Sun Garden Cafe is a cheerful restaurant with a breezy ambiance that offers American cuisine made from locally sourced ingredients. It has been consistently recognized on various 'Best Of' lists in Sarasota for its delightful dishes, including the popular breakfast options. The cafe prides itself on using locally grown produce and fresh catch, as well as farm-fresh eggs and artisan foods to create original and flavorful dishes.
Great spot for breakfast or brunch! Bronx Bagel was amazing—fresh and flavorful. The SG Potatoes are an absolute must, perfectly seasoned and cook3d just right. The Sweet Potato Pancakes were exceptional, and the Liege Waffles were fantastic—sweet, warm, and indulgent. Friendly service and a cozy atmosphere round out a great experience. Highly recommend!
Just expect a little wait to be seated.
Joe G — Google review
Hospitality goes such a long way here!!! Food was also delicious, not even 10 minutes after ordering, the food was already on our table. What I love best about this place is the patio outside. Sitting between the plants and flowers provides such a tranquil scene. Lots of options on the menus and the sourdough is especially good here.
Cute spot, solid food! It was a good spot to catch up with friends - lively but not too loud for conversation. The food was good and portions perfect.
We came on a Sunday at brunch so it seemed very busy but we only had to wait about 15 minutes for a table for 4 luckily.
We decided to stop by for breakfast on a weekday morning.
The food is fantastic!
We went for Eggs Benedict and an Omelette - we would definitely consider them again.
The service was great!
We loved sitting outside and taking in the fresh air while savoring the meal.
We would certainly consider coming here again.
Came here two days in a row it was so good! Everything was super fresh and delicious - had a Benedict one day and omelette the next and would definitely recommend. Had great service and fun beach vibes :)
Found the place by walking and have to say that the reviews are all accurate, food is fantastic same as the service.
We came for breakfast yesterday and decided to come back again today to try other dishes from the menu.
The French toasts are a must! And the Mediterranean Revival eggs so good!
Defiantly recommend this place!
I rarely give an "all out" review but I can see why this place is top of the list for breakfast here in Siesta Key. The menu isn't too big, and the food comes out quickly. The ingredients in/on my "Bikini Bagel" were fresh and well-balanced. Which I greatly appreciated. The avocado on my dish was cut fresh —for my dish. The fig was for sure my favorite —thickly sliced and placed atop the avocado. I was all for it. We're on a quick pass through on our way to Fort Myers, so we needed something quick. What a treat! Totally unexpected to find such good eats. The price is fair for the portions and the vibe outside is a must.
Such a hidden gem! Do not miss this spot in the village! Amazing food, great coffee, & super quick service! Indoor seating (with AC) or outdoor seating. The staff were all so friendly. We went multiple times during our trip & loved it each time. From breakfast sandwiches, chicken & waffles, oatmeal, biscuits & gravy, shrimp po’ boy wrap. Breakfast or lunch — it’s all amazing!
210 Avenida Madera, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Fish & chips restaurant
Family restaurant
Restaurant
Seafood restaurant
If you're looking for a delightful dining experience on Siesta Key, The Old Salty Dog is the place to be. This charming British pub not only serves up mouthwatering beer-battered hot dogs but also offers a variety of bar bites that are perfect for satisfying your cravings. With its inviting atmosphere and proximity to the beach, it's an ideal spot for families and furry friends alike. Dogs are welcomed with special meals and treats, making it a truly pet-friendly destination.
Another little local gem just North of Siesta Key village by about a block. It turned out to be one those (If you know then you know) places. Food was really delicious and portions size was tremendous. Staff where all very friendly. The place appears to be way bigger on the inside then it looks on the outside. It also sports one of the longest bars that I've seen in the whole village. We were very impressed with the atmosphere and the personaliized decore. It gives the restaurant a special and unique identity. Anthony was our server and he was friendly and efficient had our drinks to us very quickly and the food followed soon after. Very fast service. I tried the Loaded Salty Dog (one of their signature dishes) I have to tell you that was the biggest and I dare say probably the best hot dog I have ever had. Meat was jucy and delicious not something you find everywhere. This dog was loaded down with 3 types of cheese and Sautéed onions and mushrooms as well as crisp sourkrut. The hot dog nearly won. I.almost couldn't finish it. They claimed it was a quarter pound dog, the whole sandwich likely weighted in at 1 and 1/4 pounds.. Be really hungry if you order this monster...but if you can't finish it (Henry thier mascot maybe standing by literally to help you clean up.) Heather sampled the Grilled Shrimp Tacos and they where also pretty large and she found them wonderfully flavorful. The Beer I ordered was a locally brewed Draft and it was cold crisp and really hit the spot. Heather sampled one of their special house made Margaritas and it was delicious but stout...they didn't skimp on the tequila that's for sure. So if you haven't tried this place I strongly recommend it. We will be trying more of their fine cuisine on our next visit. Very glad we stopped in today.
Scott F — Google review
Firecracker wrap with shrimp is incredible. Tortilla wasn't dried out. The sauce has a kick. Good taste. The batter chicken sandwich is huge. Real chicken that isn't batter on top of batter on top of batter. The original salty dog though isn't something I'd get again. Rum cake was moist and so yummy!!!! Key lime slice is fine. Glad desserts are local.
The Old Salty Dog Siesta Key: A Mixed Bag, But Worth a Visit!
Our recent trip to The Old Salty Dog on Siesta Key offered a bit of a mixed experience, but overall, it's a place we'd consider visiting again, especially if you have a furry friend!
First and foremost, it's a wonderfully dog-friendly place, which is a huge plus for pet owners. They were very welcoming to our dog, making it easy and enjoyable to dine out with our companion. The relaxed, casual atmosphere is perfect for a laid-back meal by the water.
Now, for the food. I decided to be adventurous and ordered their signature dish, the "Salty Dog." Unfortunately, I really did not like it. It just wasn't to my personal taste, and I found it quite overwhelming. However, this is where the "mixed bag" comes in: my family ordered other dishes that were great! They enjoyed their meals thoroughly, with everything from seafood to other pub-style fare receiving high marks. This suggests that while my particular choice wasn't a hit, the kitchen is certainly capable of producing delicious food.
So, while I might steer clear of the "Salty Dog" next time, the positive experience of dining with our dog and the enjoyment my family had with their meals means we'd still recommend The Old Salty Dog Siesta Key. Just be sure to explore their menu beyond the namesake dish!
Wow!!!!!! WHAT HAPPENED????. We came here a couple times last time we were in siesta key. We were all excited to eat here. NOT the same. The waitress struggled to offer to take our order after we ordered drinks and an appetizer. We were never once offered any refills on our pop, there were only about 5 or 6 other tables with customers so it was not very busy. We ordered two burgers and an original salty dog and a loaded salty dog. The hot dogs had absolutely no taste. Last time we came we had left a 5 star review. The original was fried so hard that the batter was absolutly rock hard. The loaded had the tiniest amount of grilled onion and saurkrut hidden under the dog which is stange because the whole thing tasted like nothing but burnt greasy onions. There are so many amazing places to eat here. Would not suggest spending $90 on a couple dogs and burgers that were not very good.
I LOVE that we could bring our dog with us (patio dining and it was perfect!) Service was great. Mixed thoughts on the food. The wonton tacos were AWESOME, but very small portion for the price. Grilled mahi had no flavor and was a bit dry. The chili (not pictured) had too much chili power added which made it overly salty.
Visited mid August. Was a hot day but there was plenty of air movement on the covered patio. The beer was cold. Great locally brewed hazy IPA. The hush puppies and shrimp were freshly fried, hot and crispy. What more could you want?
Service was friendly, the atmosphere was good for the time of the day (lunch) and the food was ok. Had a great craft beer (think it was mango flavoured light ale type). We had the mussels, firecracker wrap and the hotdog. The endamme and chickpea salad as a side was great. Think this place comes alive late evenings.
While our server was nice, the food was cold and bland which is such a let down. The place was empty on a Sunday afternoon and still took a while to get our food.
5023 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Italian restaurant
Bar
Fine dining restaurant
Cafe Gabbiano is a rustic-elegant eatery located in Siesta Key, offering upscale Italian favorites and an extensive wine list. The restaurant provides a fine dining experience with friendly service and an inspired setting for indulging in a variety of Italian dishes. The menu features sauteed veal, poached pear, truffle pasta, and braised ravioli among other delectable options.
10/10 for places to have a wedding reception! We had our wedding reception here and it was perfect! It’s been a year since our wedding and our friends and family members are still talking about how amazing the food and drinks were. We had to get a tent because we had about 120 people, but they handled all the details for us. All staff members were so kind and were great to work with (Robbie is the best bartender around and he was a must have at our reception!). Robbie also constantly made sure I had everything I needed which helped out greatly throughout the night. Marc and Kris made sure we had all the details ironed out and ensured everything was beautiful and ran smoothly. We chose this place because the food is incredible (wine and cocktails, too!) and it was nothing short of top notch that night. They stayed opened 2 hours or so after the reception was supposed to be over because everyone was having such a great time! The only thing I regret was having too much fun dancing and missing out on the dessert which I was greatly looking forward to. Some day soon we’ll be back for it 😋
Katie S — Google review
This is a solid 4-star Italian/American restaurant. The food is good, but lacks greatness. It’s well prepared, the menu is well thought out, presentation is on point t for what it is, and the food really isn’t bad… it just lacks certain details to really be considered great. Many of the sauces are a bit on the bland side. The veal parm was a bit dry. The pastas lacked that taste and flavor all great pastas have. Service was average to good, ambiance is good, and the location is great. Although they could use a remodel, especially with the prices they are charging… the entire restaurant is still the same hurriedly constructed shed on top of a wooden deck I remember from 20+ years ago… the best thing about this place other than location is the wine menu, they have an exceptional wine menu.
The food here is lovely!
We enjoyed several courses during the meal.
The salads are good.
The bread is hot and delicious.
The ravioli is amazing.
The service is good and constantly focused on the guests.
Be sure to save room for the tiramisu.
The space is fun.
If you are a fan of wine, then get ready to have a wonderful dining experience 😃
We enjoyed an amazing meal and truly spectacular service from Ricco. Our group of 10 shared several dishes and each of them was done perfectly. So delicious! It was our favorite restaurant from the many we visited on our vacation on Siesta Key.
Food was absolutely amazing. We had apps of mozzarella, brushetta and olives. The Mains being tortellini and the chicken special of the day. Highly recommend this place for outstanding food.
Service was a little slow and we were there right when they opened. But everything was correct so I would definitely go back.
Cafe Gabbiano is an outstanding dining experience! The food was exceptional, with freshly made pasta, rich authentic flavors, and a menu that offers a wide variety of delicious options. The atmosphere is cozy and calm, creating the perfect setting for a relaxing meal. The waitstaff was attentive, friendly, and truly made the evening enjoyable. Hands down the best Italian food on Siesta Key and a must-visit when in the area.
Very personal and knowledgeable friendly staff answered all our questions with authority and without hesitation. The food was fresh and above our expectations. Authentic and will not disappoint. More wine selection than most wine stores !!
The food was very good however the server we had was not personable at all. He did not say his name and he was very stand offish. We came for a bachelorette trip and was very excited to eat here. The bride asked for ranch and he said “no this an Italian restaurant” when we were leaving and after we paid all he said was “bye” as he was walking into the kitchen. The food was amazing but the service from our waiter really rubbed us the wrong way and ruined the time.
5104 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242, USA•
cheap
Restaurant
Bar
Gastropub
Island House Tap and Grill is a laid-back restaurant and bar that serves Latin street eats like tacos, ceviche, and stir-fries. Located at 5110 Ocean Blvd in Sarasota, Florida, it offers a cozy atmosphere for enjoying a variety of dishes such as Ahi Poke and Guac N Chips.
Island House Tap and Grill is a cozy place to get a meal in the village of Siesta Key. There's not much seating available which makes it nice in my book. The atmosphere is what I've come to expect for Siesta Key restaurants which is very fitting and went along with the whole vibe of island theme. Our server was polite and attentive. Now to the food. It was excellent. High quality ingredients and everything is made from scratch. It's a legit scratch kitchen. Everyone in our party enjoyed his or her food. If you like beer and wine on top of good food, the beer and wine selection is hard to beat as well.
Jackson C — Google review
This little cute place is definitely worth your visit when in Siesta Key Village.
It’s a tiny indoor place with a few tables outside, when I walked in I was not sure about the place, I don’t know what I expected but my expectations were exceeded to the max. Thank you to Steve and Amber for serving us, guiding us through the food choices and extra kudos to Steve, he made me separate non-mayo dips so I didn’t have to miss out, it was amazing!
We had a few different things, the fried pickles as a starter is a must, so delicious, the America Burger, the filet mignon rice bowl. Everything 10/10. Lots of beer and wine choices as well!
You’re missing out if you don’t visit this cute little place.
Thank you guys!
I've been here multiple times. The first time was great. The second time wasn't so good as the service was really lacking and food wasn't on par.
The last time I came a few days ago it was great! The service was really good and fast. Food came out super hot and everything was good. The first shrimp app was phenomenal and I highly recommend that dish. The steak tacos were good - could have used a little more crema but some hot sauce did the trick. The bowls they have are also very very good!
Overall if you're in the key I highly suggest stopping by here for lunch. They have a lot of great options.
So glad we stumbled on this place! Best Brussels I’ve ever had (no pic because they were eaten so fast). Mahi tacos and grouper sliders were also amazing. Stephen was an excellent server, great knowledge of fish/tastes and gave us some great local recs!
I ordered online, so no opinion on atmosphere and service. The food was not very good. I really wanted to like this place too. I ordered the chicken sandwich with duck fries. The chicken sandwich was missing the prosciutto and special lettuce. Horrible chicken sandwich. Also, no duck fries. Regular not very good fries. I won't finish the sandwich and I'm giving the fries to my dog. Truly a 2
1.5/10. Especially considering how expensive this place is.
A Must-Visit in Siesta Key!
We had an incredible experience at The Island House Tap & Grill! From the moment we sat down, we felt welcomed and relaxed. The atmosphere is laid back and perfect for Siesta Key vibes.
The food? Outstanding. The fish tacos were absolutely delicious fresh, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned. We also tried the chicken tacos, and they were just as amazing. You can tell they take real pride in their ingredients and preparation.
What really made the visit special was our server, Amber. She was friendly, attentive, and made us feel right at home. Her energy and great recommendations elevated our whole experience.
If you’re in Siesta Key, do yourself a favor and stop by The Island House Tap & Grill. We’ll definitely be back!
Myself and my family (5 of us) dined here on Friday night 7/25/25. We were initially surprised by how tiny the restaurant was, but we were seated outside by the hostess Amber who was extremely friendly! We ordered drinks, amber house ale, a classic Moscow mule, and more. All were great. As for food, we ordered 2 steakhouse burgers, a shrimp bowl, steak bowl, and tuna bowl. Safe to say we all CLEANED our plates. Everything was delicious and tasted fresh. We will definitely be returning a second time during our stay here in Siesta Key.
Been coming to siesta key for years and somehow we have never found this place until today. Genuinely the best food we have had. Fresh, cooked to order and simply amazing.
Service was perfect, the team took the time to chat and make us feel massively welcome throughout.
Please just try this food… you won’t regret it!
5110 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242, USA•
Create your ultimate travel itinerary
Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.
affordable
Seafood restaurant
Restaurant
Dry Dock Waterfront Grill is a casual waterfront restaurant located at the Boathouse marina on Longboat Key, offering panoramic views of Sarasota Bay. It has been recognized as one of the 100 Most Scenic Restaurants in America for its picturesque setting. The menu features seafood specialties such as grouper sandwiches, lobster rolls, and Boathouse Burgers.
Great food! Great service. When my husband said he was taking me to lunch, I was thinking we were going to another restaurant. I was quite glad when he pulled up to Dry Dock Waterfront Grill as I knew I didn't have to worry about what I would order. Of course, I ordered the best thing on the menu: the seafood pasta with garlic and wine sauce (I forgot to order it with extra garlic though!! 🤦🏿♀️). My husband ordered the Tuscan cream sauce pasta with blackened grouper. He said it was delicious. I wouldn't know since I was gobbling down my own deliciousness so quickly! 🤷🏿 We gave the virgin strawberry daiquiris. They were ok, a little icy and lacked the sweetness of some others. The outdoor patio was breezy and nice. They really try to make it comfortable for the guests and it shows. DDWG is a bit pricey, and it doesn't look like they have a lunch menu (unless I missed it??), so if you are budget conscious, you'll have to choose your menu items carefully. Whatever you choose, especially if it's one of their pastas, you'll be glad you did! Happy eating! 😊
L R — Google review
Im not much of a seafood person but this place was phenomenal. I had a few locals tell me how good this place is and it did not disappoint. Their coconut shrimp and their category 5 shrimp were phenomenal. And the lobster rolls had you craving for some more. Highly recommend!
The food at Dry Dock Waterfront Grill was absolutely delicious—fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The views overlooking Sarasota Bay were stunning and made the whole experience worth the visit. Carly, our waitress, was top-notch. She had fantastic people skills, made us feel genuinely welcome, and took great care of us throughout the meal. You can tell she loves what she does. Great atmosphere, great service, and great food. Highly recommend!
On vacation we rarely eat at the same place twice but we did here! Went early for dinner around 4 to 5pm. Did have to wait a few minutes but we'll worth it. They have deck seating and 2 and 3 floor seating, all with great views of the bay. Our first visit, our waitress was exceptional! Our meal superb! Had grouper, veggies and real mashed potatoes. This was the best meal of the week!!! My second was sea bass, red potatoes and asparagus. Other plates were delighful chicken. Veggies so tender. Highly recommend 👌 FYI watch out for Barney Fife with the Longboat Police dept. They work Gulf Blvd with their radar guns!
🤤 o m g. Delish! Amazing vibe, delicious food, and phenomenal service. The entrees are very generous portions with a delicious salad. I got the blackened grouper and my partner got the bacon wrapped scallops and coconut shrimp. I did not have a bad bite of food all night. We had an amazing sunset to complement dinner time too! They had a ton of fans running outside to keep the air moving to prevent overheating. Our server was even kind enough to take a cute picture of me and my boo at sunset :) worth the splurge!
Exceptional food and service! AND the view of the water was amazing! Our server Sylvia was amazing and so knowledgeable and patient as it was our 1st time there but definitely not our last! Red snapper was so delish as we're the crab cakes and crab claws! Upscale restaurant but doesn't make you feel out of place!! Loved it
Lovely! We wanted a special place for our anniversary. My husband found Dry Dock Waterfront Grill. We were offered the option to sit inside or out (we had a reservation and went at lunchtime) and chose to sit inside which was on the second floor overlooking the water.
We had a hard time picking what we wanted to eat since everything sounded so good. My husband ordered the Lobster rolls with fries while I ordered the Grouper tacos (fried) with coleslaw. SO GOOD! One of those meals you don’t want to stop eating even when you are full. Everything was prepared perfectly. The coleslaw was some of the best I’ve ever had! We were very happy.
Can’t wait to go back! (Already decided what I want).
Went for my bday dinner with my bf and we really enjoyed it. Lobster bisque wasn’t my fave I’ve ever had had a really fishy aftertaste but everything else was really good. We got the bacon wrapped scallops, soup, and we each got a pasta - one snapper & one seafood and they were great. Worth waiting to sit by the waterfront if you can get a reservation, gorgeous view of the water. They also had bug spray which came in so handy and was very thoughtful. Recommend the salted caramel cheesecake to finish it off. Some cons were we mentioned it was my bday when making the reservation and nothing special was done or mentioned about it so kind of wish we picked somewhere else for the special occasion in that regard. We had a late reservation (8:45) and it seemed like the workers really wanted to go home because they were packing up fans etc early which takes away from the experience overall. We deserve the same experience diners got at 5/6 and staff should close up once patrons leave it’s just kind of rude overall and makes customers feel rushed to leave and we shouldn’t feel that way or they should not be taking late reservations if they want people to hurry up and go. Overall still enjoyed it but could’ve been better based on the cons of the overall dining experience
412 Gulf of Mexico Dr, Longboat Key, FL 34228, USA•
affordable
Seafood restaurant
American restaurant
Family restaurant
Fish & chips restaurant
The Old Salty Dog is a British-style pub located in various prime spots, including Sarasota's City Island and Lido Key. It offers a picturesque view of the bay and provides a relaxed atmosphere for visitors to enjoy live music while indulging in beer-battered hot dogs, fish n chips, grouper sandwiches, and their famous plump and juicy chicken wings tossed in Old Bay Hot Sauce.
The restaurant is right on the water. You cannot beat the view! It had a local vibe, which we love since we're true Floridians. The food was fresh and delish! We had the grouper, blackened, sandwich and the Captain seafood platter. We also enjoyed some nice cold beverages: ice tea and a local beer. Enjoy!
Kristin M — Google review
This was one of the best restaurants we ate at. Everything was great. The food was above average!! The Service was fantastic!! Several of the workers stopped and talked to us. We set on the deck overlooking the water. This is a must if you are near the area. The sunset on the water is a must see.
What an incredible meal! The Old Salty Dog is always a must-visit whenever we're in Florida, and this trip was no exception. We finally tried the loaded Old Salty Dog, and I deeply regret not ordering it sooner. It absolutely lives up to the hype and is a game-changer.
The atmosphere was perfect. We sat right by the water, which made for a beautiful and relaxing experience. The kids had a blast too, enjoying their meals along with a delicious strawberry smoothie. They also loved the freebie that came with their food and were so excited to take it home.
On top of that, the peel and eat shrimp were out of this world—fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The staff was also incredibly friendly and attentive, which made the experience even better. We'll be back again and again!
We had a stunning lunch here. Everything was super fresh and crisp. Neat lobster roll I’ve had in a long time and their sweet potato fries were delicious. Service was friendly and super attentive. Robbie was so sweet and great at serving us. We saw a manatee swimming right by us and lots of fish, jelly fish and dolphins in the distance. Amazing location for the perfect relaxing lunch on the water.
We absolutely love this Old Salty Dog location near St. Armands Circle in Sarasota.
The restaurant is waterfront and right next to a marina/boat yard and marine center. There are always boats being launched, refueling, or just cruising by. On a sunny day, it is a perfect waterfront spot in Sarasota to boat watch.
The Pelicans are always swooping for fish and putting on a show for restaurant guests. You can also occasionally see jelly fish, we just saw a couple hundred swimming by on our last visit.
Rain or shine, Old Salty Dog is always worth a visit. The patio gets the perfect amount of sun on a sunny day with light sun shades, a gulf breeze, and the perfect sunset back drop. On rainy days, you might have to wait a minute for an inside table or seat at the bar because they stay busy, but it is worth the wait.
As the name implies, they are known for their deep fried hot dogs and dog bites which are always a favorite. The burgers also hit the spot for a change up and the seafood doesn’t disappoint. If you’re looking for a frozen drink on a hot day, a delicious rum runner, or just a beer they have something for everyone.
The parking lot gets full pretty quick with limited spaces while they are working on the building next door, but additional lots are across the street and a short 2 minute walk.
We’d highly recommend Old Salty Dog for a casual waterfront restaurant in Sarasota with good food, good drinks, and the ability to come in your swim suit by boat or car.
You cannot beat food right by the water. We both enjoyed a grouper sandwich, mine was blackened. My wife's was fried in a tempura like beer batter. Both were absolutely delicious, shared some regular fries and some sweet potato fries. The service was quick, there were a couple of local beers on tap. And whatever you do, do not skip the key lime pie!
If you want the beach vibe while eating dinner this is the place for it. If you imagine having a drink with the weather breeze blowing on you then look no further. Sitting there while a boat floats by, a pelican lands 10 ft from you, and seeing a rainbow was amazing. The food wasn't amazing, but the atmosphere makes up for it. I got a hamburger and an order of the Salty dog nuggets. I had a wonderful time eating here.
After a day of apartment hunting we were hungry and The Old Salty Dog was right on our route and super convenient. We got some mozzarella sticks, burger with fries and the hotdog bites. Not super excited about the hog dog bites Sadly but we were so hungry it served a purpose. The staff was super friendly and the atmosphere was perfect to end the day. I would love to stop back when I come back to the area.
1601 Ken Thompson Pkwy, Sarasota, FL 34236, USA•
affordable
Restaurant
Oyster bar restaurant
Seafood restaurant
Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar, affectionately known as "the Creek" by locals, is a beloved waterfront restaurant located just a short distance from downtown Sarasota. This long-standing eatery offers a casual atmosphere and stunning views of Phillippi Creek. Known for its excellent oysters on the half shell, seafood paella, and stone crab (in season from October through April), it's a go-to spot for Southern-style seafood dishes like gumbo and fried gator chunks.
A location we have been to many times that never disappoints. If you are visiting Sarasota then Phillippi Creek should be on your to-do list.
The food is always delicious, the service always attentive, and the atmosphere is quaint.
I recommend the tilapia and red potatoes.
K M — Google review
When I got my Asian poke bowl, it looked like a masterpiece!!! I’m in love with the setting and restaurant. It’s right on the water as tourists go by on boat tours. The service is par excellence, the food is fresh and made to order, the restaurant is throughly cleaned and full or vibrancy! The menu is extensive and during the summer time they have a special menu. I can’t wait to be back for their seafood boil! My server was perfect! Thank you Brad.
It was a beautiful day and we chose to eat outside on the deck. Waiter was totally unfamiliar with the menu and when the Tiki tuna wrap came in it was served on lettuce rather than a wrap and no wasabi. My grouper wrap was a little fishy and it was wet. The beers were nice and cold and the fries were hot and tastey. Nice view of the creek but would not hurry back.
Oh wow, they have such delicious food! Everything we ordered was delicious. We went at night, the vibe was a bit dark but once inside, it's really nice. I had the combination seafood boil, which can feed 2, it is a must! The crab cakes was also good. My hubby got fish tacos, he really liked that.
Beautiful atmosphere, love the seafood stuff, oysters, and oysters Rockefeller our waiter was Jose he was the sweetest and gave awesome recommendations. The stuffed oysters and oyster Rockefeller along with pina colada cheesecake 10/10 . Nice view on the deck
Oct 1st 2024 Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar saved the day for my family. My daughter was scheduled to be married on Lido beach at Limetree Beach Resort but Hurricane Helene crushed those dreams and plans. We stopped to eat at Phillippi Creek after picking up wedding decorations from Limetree and I had a thought that maybe we could have the wedding on their dock. I asked the managers Ricky and Jorge if it would be possible and they said YES!!! With only a few days to change coarse Lisa and her team with Tied The Knot weddings made it happen. It turned out to be the best day ever for all of us!!!
I can't thank the staff at Phillippi Creek for saving the day and the the excellent service they provided the wedding party and all of the delicious food as always!!!
My favorite place to eat 🥰
The restaurant has beautiful views and the staff was super friendly. We had Valentina and she was amazing!!! The food was delicious. We had the stuffed grouper and the steamed dungeness crab dinner. So good!
Kind of disappointed. Very small portions. Ordered fried clams extra crispy. They came out luke warm and not fresh cooked crispy. Flavor was fair and ahain small portion. Fried clams were served hot but small order for the price and only a few were large enough to dip. Needed a spoon to finish most of the order. Hush puppies were hot but not very flavorfull.
Waiter was amazing and very friendly. All the staff i interacted with were professional and pleasant. Dont know if I'll be back.
5353 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL 34231, USA•
expensive
Seafood restaurant
American restaurant
Banquet hall
Chart House is a high-end chain restaurant that offers a classy setting with views and serves seafood and steakhouse fare. Located in Longboat Key, Florida, this waterfront restaurant provides a relaxing spot with dining room or terrace options overlooking the beautiful Gulf waters of Sarasota Bay. Known for its popular happy hour, creative drinks, tasty food, and great views, Chart House is praised by locals and visitors alike.
Excellent dinner. The savory shrimp pasta was hands down the best Scampi I have ever had. The prime rib was cooked to perfection. The grouper was also tasty. Mom said the lamb was ok. The chocolate lava cake was yummy even though it was over baked just a bit. No lava. Our server was wonderful even though she had several tables. We had a window table, and the view was gorgeous.
Melissa W — Google review
We arrived at 7pm on a Friday night with reservations and were immediately seated at a beautiful table overlooking the bay and bridge.
It was our first visit and came to try out the restaurant during Savor Sarasota. We ordered the Caesar Salad, Salmon with Shrimp and Key lime pie. All were exceptional and very generous portions. Sadie our server was attentive during the entire evening and most importantly we never felt rushed leaving our beautiful view. We will definitely be back.
Excellent service from moment of arrival. Even though the restaurant was busy, the hostesses were so warm and accommodating. Our server, Craig was so nice and attentive and helped us with our selections. I really enjoyed the crab cake appetizer and the salmon for main course, also recommend the mango tuna avocado appetizer. Besides the top notch service, the restaurant itself, with warm tones and beautiful views of the Gulf, made the dining experience exceptional. Will be back.
We had dinner here. We were seated by the windows and that allowed us to enjoy the water view. Our server was nice.
We had crab cakes, clam chowder soup, and Kim Chee Calamari for appetizers. For main dish we had, sea bass with mashed potatoes and asparagus. For dessert, we had a dish that brought 3 different flavor crème brûlée. Sangria and water.
The crab cakes was tasteful. The clam chowder was okay, nothing to write home about and the same for the sea bass. The creme brûlée dessert was good, different flavors to suit different paletes.
Overall, it's a nice restaurant with nice views. The food was okay.
Always a great time here with friends and family . Never have a bad meal or service A great place to celebrate your birthday . You get a copy of that days menu with recognition and they give you a delicious dessert with a candle
Noah was our server . He was wonderful.,We wanted to pace out our dinner with the wine and salad bar before putting in the main entrees and he gave us plenty of time . We never felt rushed . We just need to remember to get there before our dinner reservation to enjoy Happy Hour prices . because quite a difference in pricing of drinks only available in bar area
Had our usual , Salmon and Chicken Balsamica and the Farmers bar . ( The adding on of the salad bar with Entree has definitely gone up over the years ) But it's well worth it .
The early bird menu is great and includes dessert . Which you might as well bring home after your 2-3 trips to the salad bar
Everyone told us Chart House was the upscale spot to go to on Longboat Key so we were expecting something more elevated when we walked in, but it felt very dated.
That said, we did get a great seat at the bar with beautiful views of the water.
We came for Happy Hour and that was definitely the highlight.
Pomegranate Mojito: Super tasty, just delayed
Firecracker Shrimp: Good and flavorful
Crispy Spicy Tuna: Worth it to order, but not my favorite
Prime Rib Sliders: Solid choice, would definitely order again
Sunset Beets (regular menu): The pesto make it work, but otherwise it was a no for me.
Cedar Plank Salmon (early dining menu): Came with a salad and lemon sorbet, both refreshing and tasty but the green beans and rice were a no for us.
Service-wise, the bartender greeted us and was really polite, but it felt like we didn't get much attention after that - maybe because we ordered in waves, or maybe because the bar was just busy.
Overall, Happy Hour was worth it for the price, the view, and a few standout bites but I don't think we'd come back.
Excellent dinner and drinks with family. Everyone enjoyed their meal. The seafood was fresh and delicious. The salad bar was also plentiful. Dessert was excellent as well.
We went to chart house after we got engaged. My fiancé had made a reservation prior and let them know ahead of time. They were SO sweet to us. Our server, Jason was polite, attentive , and so sweet! The staff even signed a card for us! Our menu even had a personalized message just for us. Thank you staff!! We will be returning!
201 Gulf of Mexico Dr, Longboat Key, FL 34228, USA•
affordable
French restaurant
Miguel's Restaurant, located at 6631 Midnight Pass Road on Siesta Key in Sarasota, Florida, is a renowned dining establishment that has been serving exquisite French and continental cuisine since 1983. Founded by Miguel Garcia and now managed by his sons Gabriel and Daniel, the restaurant offers a diverse culinary experience. From an early bird menu for budget-conscious diners to elegant tableside presentations, Miguel's caters to various preferences.
This gem of a restaurant is hidden in the corner of an L shaped strip mall just south of Stickney point. This was our first time getting takeout from the place. It was jam packs shortly after it opened. It was a Saturday night and I am sure reservations are highly recommended.
The food was good. Actually the food was great. Everything we had was well prepared and tasty. That is something of your feet on a busy Saturday night. But they maintain the quality.
It’s one of those restaurants where, when you finish dinner, you can’t wait to go back another time and try something else.
As an added bonus, the early bird special came with dessert and an appetizer. One of us had the seafood wrapped in a puff pastry that was delightful. I had lamb chops which was seasoned and cooked well. The online ordering did give you the ability to specify how you would like them cooked, and they did them perfectly.
The parking lot gets very busy and I could see where one could have trouble finding a spot. There is parking in the rear. That’s a little bit difficult to negotiate.
The pictures show the crème brûlée dessert, the beef tips and shrimp appetizer, and the two entrées I mentioned above. There is also a short video of the interior of the restaurant.
I recommend trying the place. Even if you’re not strictly a French food lover, there is something for everyone, just take a look at the menu.
Bon appétit
L. L — Google review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
If I could give Miguel’s Restaurant 10 stars, I absolutely would! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warmth and hospitality that makes you feel truly special. Dan, the owner, is a delight to converse with behind the bar, always ensuring guests are comfortable and well-attended. Chef Gabe’s culinary expertise shines through in every dish, offering a delectable French continental menu that’s both authentic and innovative. The wine list is exceptional, featuring selections that perfectly complement the cuisine. This establishment is a rare gem in Siesta Key—a must-visit for anyone seeking an unforgettable dining experience. Highly recommended! 
This was the best food and experience. Meal was just fabulous! Cocktails were so awesome and unique! Inside, the restaurant the decor gives you a cozy outdoor European feel, even though you are indoors. I liked that they thought about keeping the sound level down with sound dampening ceiling tiles and carpeted floors. You could have a nice quiet level conversation and enjoy a great meal. Went for the Savor Sarasota week 2025.
Fantastic! Hidden gem on Siesta Key.
Tucked away in the corner this unsuspecting restaurant has some of the best service and food anywhere, let alone on the key.
Amazing table side service, we had the ceasar for the table and it was made from scratch right next to us, same with the dover sole and the flambe both tableside prepared.
Everyone enjoyed their food. Perfectly cooked fish and steaks. Delicious sauces.
Great wine and cocktail selection too. Dirty grey goose martini was on point.
Complimentary veggies with delicious pâté, really good nicely seasoned pâté, and garlic bread.
Will definitely be a regular stop for me from now on. Can't recommend highly enough.
Such a wonderful meal accompanied by perfect service! You're immediately provided with ice water and delicious garlic roles with accoutrements. Our server was knowledgeable on wine options and graciously provided her favorite menu selections. We leaned into the full dining experience and ordered the Cesar salad and bananas foster, both made table side - a must! Don't sleep on this hidden gem. In business for more than 40 years, they know how to serve with quality and flavor. We'll definitely be back!
We have visited Miguel‘s multiple times over the years visiting Siesta Key & have always enjoyed our experience. They have great parking and we can usually get a reservation last minute the day of. Cocktails are always good. We love the table-side Caesar salad service as well. The dressing is made in front of you from scratch & is delicious. If salad isn’t for you, you have to get the French onion soup. It is absolutely amazing. From there my favorite entree is Le Boeuf Diane. Beef & puff pastry = a beautiful masterpiece! The prices are great for the flavor packed entrees.
Our favorite dessert option is the dessert sampler where you can pick 3 desserts to try. They also have amazing table-side flambé dessert options.
We’re from Spain and have been living in the US for a while now, and this is hands down the best meal we’ve had here. Incredible quality, family-owned warmth, and unbeatable prices. Highly recommended!
Great service from the start. Parking was easy and very convenient. We had made reservations for four and we were greeted and seated immediately upon arrival. The place was beautifully decorated in traditional Euro- French decor. We noted the place was booming with happy locals and tourist guests. We were taken care of by Brendan who walked us through the menu options. My girls opted for the Savor Sarasota, Prix Fixe Menu, including delicious escargot, French onion soup and savory beef bourguignon short ribs. They serve delicious, freshly made, bread which is prefect to dip in the escargot cassoulet. My wife had the coquilles st Jacques and the filet de boeuf, I had their 8 ounce filet mignon in peppercorn sauce. Both delicious and perfectly executed at medium rare. We accompanied our meal with their house Chardonnay and Riesling. For dessert we had the event of the night, our very own server Brendan executing table side delicious flambé Crepes Suzette with grand mariner and vanilla ice cream. We had an excellent evening and will definitely come back.
6631 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA•
Create your ultimate travel itinerary
Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.
expensive
Seafood restaurant
Restaurant
Jack Dusty is a seafood-focused eatery and lounge located within The Ritz-Carlton Sarasota. The restaurant offers a high-quality dining experience with options ranging from juicy steaks to braised pork shank. Guests can also enjoy hand-crafted cocktails and craft beers in the nautical-themed space. With an extensive seasonal menu, Jack Dusty's experts are known for pushing the envelope with new creations, including favorites like The Sirena cocktail.
We had a great experience. Dinner on the patio watching the sun set over the bay. Well crafted cocktails. The food was good. Our server was awesome. Will be back next time in Sarasota.
Jodi M — Google review
Amazing food. Great views. Wonderful service. Drinks were great as well. We were blown away at the portion of lobster they gave us. They were very accommodating and created a special plate even though it wasn’t specifically on the menu. Perfect place for sunset dinner.
Here for the first time to celebrate my wife’s birthday. I found this place by googling Best Seafood Restaurant in Sarasota. It is located in the Ritz Carleton Hotel which is situated right on the harbor with great views. Complimentary Valet parking was handy since there is no parking nearby. We were seated immediately outside with a nice view of the harbor. Our server Brooke made our experience we wonderful. The menu is limited but that is not necessarily a negative. We were waited on by a team of servers. I ordered a Negroni and my wife had a gin and tonic. We had the shrimp cocktail which I felt was not as fresh as it could be. I was expecting jumbo shrimp but they were average size. A highlight was the brown maple bread which came backed in a tin cake. Brooke served us explaining the origin of the bread and the name Jack Dusty. My wife had the mahi mahi which she said was delicious. I had the Red Snapper. It was a huge serving. I had filled up on the shrimp and bread. The bar looks like a good happy hour spot. Some people came just for drinks. Dress is casual. This will be a good place to bring company. Oh, my wife got her pick of desserts and the recipe for the bread. I’m
Sooo, Jack Dusty was surprisingly good! I’m usually skeptical about hotel restaurant, there’s often a high chance of high prices and bland food, but this one delivered.
We had dinner, dessert, and breakfast here and enjoyed all of it. Tried a few different things on the menu, no clear favorite, but everything was solid. The staff was friendly and helpful throughout.
Definitely worth trying if you’re in the area or staying at the hotel!
Great brunch/ lunch as always! Oysters are always really good too! One of my favorite and most frequented restaurants in SRQ. Jack fries are SOO GOOD, if you’re on a diet I recommend staying away because they are dangerously addictive (in a good way).
Jack dusty food was great! We came here for a birthday dinner and were in a private dining room. Drinks were great, views were nice as well. Only complaint was service. We were a large party, but still took 30-45 mins to get checked on knowing we were having drinks and needed water topped off etc. I would give it an 8/10.
Jack Dusty, is located inside the Ritz Carlton downtown Sarasota.
Nice lunch specials 😋, very helpful and courteous staff 👍 good views out the back 👍 Both indoor and outdoor seating 💺 😀. And for those of you that follow me, you know that cleanliness is very important 😉 Jack Dusty easily meets my expectations 👍😉 The restaurant and restrooms 🚻 are very neat and clean 😀. I recommend giving them a try 😀
We stayed at the Ritz for our vacation in sarasota. And ate at the restaurant for lunch one day. They have an exceptional seafood menu. My husband got the fish tacos and very much enjoyed them. I'm vegetarian and the options were limited but the bartender was kind enough to discuss with the chef options to help accommodate my dietary restrictions and they made vegetarian tacos. Which was such a nice gesture. The tacos were filled to the top and the flavors actually worked well. They bar tender was great!
1111 Ritz Carlton Dr, Sarasota, FL 34236, USA•
affordable
Steak house
American restaurant
Seafood restaurant
Wine bar
Connors Steak & Seafood is a beloved neighborhood restaurant and bar known for its warm atmosphere and exceptional culinary offerings. With locations in Knoxville, Huntsville, Fort Myers, and Sarasota, it has become a go-to destination for those seeking aged steaks and fresh seafood prepared over mesquite wood grills. The restaurant's intimate feel makes it perfect for small gatherings or couples looking for an unforgettable dining experience.
My finance and I took a trip down here before our wedding to destress and we decided to go to Connor’s because it looked like great quality food that wouldn’t break the bank. We walked in and were immediately greeted and seated. It was gorgeous inside!!! Our server Mandy was so nice and knowledgeable about the menu! She made great conversation! She was so sweet! The food was amazing! So happy we decided to come here!
Madison G — Google review
This is a great place to celebrate special events or have a nice date night. The booths and tables are nicely spaced out for privacy and the lighting is low, but still bright. Service was quick and friendly. Our server came back to check on us often to make sure we had everything we needed.
I got the grouper which was delicious and very filling. The creamed spinach was wonderful as well. The fried calamari was cooked perfectly, still tender, but with crisp breading.
We dined at Connor’s Steakhouse in Sarasota tonight with our two children to celebrate our anniversary, and the experience was nothing short of extraordinary. Our server, Kelly, was exceptional, providing service marked by unparalleled attentiveness, warmth, and precision. Her ability to anticipate our needs and create a welcoming atmosphere elevated our special evening to new heights.
The manager further enhanced our experience by personally stopping by our table to ensure we were enjoying ourselves, a thoughtful and gracious gesture that underscored the restaurant’s commitment to guest satisfaction. This personal touch made us feel truly valued.
The food at Connor’s was absolutely phenomenal. The steak, without question the finest in Sarasota, was prepared with masterful skill, delivering unmatched flavor and tenderness. Every dish we enjoyed showcased the restaurant’s dedication to culinary excellence, making this the most memorable meal we’ve ever had.
Connor’s Steakhouse delivered an unforgettable evening that perfectly honored our anniversary. We are deeply grateful for the impeccable service and exquisite cuisine, and we eagerly look forward to our next visit to this remarkable establishment.
Very nice and relaxing setup. Great for Anniversary and Birthday celebrations. Food came out nice and hot could tell it wasn’t just sitting waiting for the server pick up. The drinks were perfect!
My experience at Connor’s was a disappointment. The food was just okay, nothing to rave about compared to the many other steakhouses I have experienced. Although, I will say, the Korean style bbq ribs was probably the highlight of the night. I thought the service was below par as well. Our waiter seemed to forget about us for most parts of our dinner. We went on a Sunday night and it was not busy at all.
It was my husband’s birthday and they made sure he felt special! The food was amazing, atmosphere and service were great!
Thank you so much for wonderful experience, we will definitely come back!
Dante and Katarina
P.s. all these “bad” reviews are made from very petty people!
I ordered the shrimp cocktail and was very disappointed. The shrimp didn’t look or taste fresh, and the presentation was sloppy for a restaurant of this level. I politely asked for a replacement, but the second plate was just as bad. Honestly, I’ve had better shrimp from Costco. For the price and reputation, I expected much higher quality and care for customers.
Great affordable option for a birthday or anniversary. The service was a bit slow but our server was nice. Only think I wasn’t much of a fan of was the brussels sprouts. I think the flavor could’ve been a little more developed, but everything else was great!
3501 S Tamiami Trl #1165, Sarasota, FL 34239, USA•
Permanently Closed
affordable
Seafood restaurant
Bar
Nestled along the picturesque waterfront, The Boatyard Waterfront Bar and Grill is a delightful destination for seafood lovers seeking a casual yet refined dining experience. With stunning marina views as your backdrop, this eatery offers an array of fresh local seafood options, including perfectly cooked tilapia and salmon, alongside tempting pasta dishes like shrimp and mussels fra diavolo. The ambiance strikes a harmonious balance between upscale elegance and laid-back charm, making it ideal for family gatherings or outings with friends.
We came here to celebrate my birthday, and it was an excellent decision. The view was beautiful, as we sat outside. The drinks were delicious, and the food was hot and tasty. Service was quick, but we did not feel rushed. A great place with an all around great atmosphere.
AmberLiz S — Google review
Great spot on the water. Their website said every seat has a water view and they weren’t kidding! (I was chilly, so if it’s cold outside bring a sweatshirt). I had the jambalaya and it was delicious. A big bowl filled with shrimp, chicken and sausage! It was spicy but I didn’t mind. I brought a good bit of it home for another meal. My friend had the shrimp tacos and while they were good there were only two and she didn’t feel they were dressed out adequately for a meal. A little something in the taco besides 3 shrimp and a little bit of lettuce left her hungry. Our server was polite, friendly and attentive.
What a great dining experience. The restaurant has several layers to sit, right on the water, inside, or in between. We were able to watch the sun set while we ate dinner. We started with the nacho, which was plenty in it self for the three of us, as our appetizer. After seeing the wide selection of food, my party all decided to get a variant of the tacos and they did not disappoint. After sampling eachothers none of us could decide which was the best. The waiting staff was super friendly and constantly refilling our drinks. The best part was the food was very reasonably priced. All in all I would drive a ways just to come back.
A nice restaurant with a great view. The tables are right at the water, intercoastal waterway. Its a fun place to watch boats, birds, and dolphins. It's a treat to see the draw bridge go up for a passing tall boat. Prices are fair, service good. We didn't eat here but lots of fresh fish on the menu.
The food was decent. The first server clearly didn't want to be at work, but the second server was wonderful. But in the end, we chose to eat here on this particular day because we wanted to be by the water. And the scenery definitely did not disappoint. Would I dine there again? Why not. It won't be at the top of my to-do list, though.
Nice outside seating area (uncovered) overlooking the canal. The food was delicious and the staff was friendly. The menu wasn’t very diverse for me - they lack salmon in their main plate menu, for example, amongst other “staple” dishes you’d expect at a waterfront restaurant. Nonetheless, you come back here because of the outside seating and vibes.
It’s a great place to bring friends and have a nice time while watching the sunset. I’d give this place a solid 4.5.
Once again, tortillas need to be cooked before you call it a taco. Blackened means color on the fish. Nice flavors, but the cook needs to be versed on some basics. Staff was very pleasant but our waitress seemed to be scared to approach our table.
When they say every seat has a view they aren’t lying! Wish I found this place sooner! We will be back for sure! The views were amazing, the food was DELICIOUS, and if you visit you MUST ask for Rocky the bartender, she makes THE BEST Bahama Mama I’ve had! She was so sweet and attentive, and she makes some mean drinks! Love this place!
1500 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, USA•
affordable
Cafe
American restaurant
Breakfast restaurant
Restaurant
Nestled in Siesta Village, the Village Cafe is a laid-back American eatery that specializes in breakfast and lunch. This family-owned establishment has been serving up beloved breakfast classics with exceptional service for decades, earning a dedicated following. Guests can choose to dine al fresco on the spacious patio or inside the welcoming dining room adorned with vibrant beach-themed decor. Located conveniently near souvenir shops, it's an ideal spot to fuel up before indulging in some retail therapy.
Is one of the best our breakfast in this year). The service timing is perfect, the morning atmosphere is nice, 10 am, not a lot of people but not empty, the restrooms are clean AND the Food is fresh, looks very appetizing, even better than we expected!!! Thanks!
Artem G — Google review
The food was great! Warning the cinnamon roll is the size of a soft ball and delicious and get the biscuit grilled with honey! Wonderful service too!
Absolutely perfect, the food is outstanding the service is great places clean and this is a can't miss plays for breakfast!!
Great service, extensive menu & plenty of healthy options. Clean. Breakfast was delicious & filling !
Dona was a great and friendly waitress. The owner came out to greet us as well!! The service was fast and the servings were huge.
Everything was fresh!! Thank you for such a friendly and embracing service!
We’ll definitely will come back!! ❤️🙏❤️
Breakfast sandwich was amazing! Older woman server had a bit of an attitude on our second visit but the gentleman that helped us our first time here was so nice!
Went here two days in row to have their amazing Mexican omelet and so much more! Dog friendly and great service 👍
Our server, Dona, is one of the SWEETEST servers we have ever had! The place is adorable, no wait, and the seating outside is adorable — love the Siesta vibe 🌴 I could stare at the palm tree all day! Highly recommend Village Cafe 🫶🏼
5133 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242, USA•
affordable
Seafood restaurant
American restaurant
Bar
Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key is a vibrant hangout spot known for its creative daiquiris, seafood dishes, and live music. The restaurant's bright green building with colorful shutters stands out on Ocean Boulevard, offering outdoor seating on both the ground floor and upper deck. Guests can indulge in legendary frozen daiquiris while savoring classic options like seafood alfredo or buffalo wings, as well as more adventurous choices such as gator bites and grouper fingers.
My family of six gone out daiquiri deck at south siesta key on my September 21 birthday the staff they were very nice and friendly. amazing customer service they were happy to answer any questions I had and happy to find the answer for me they made my 21 Birthday very special. I loved the food and drinks were amazing.would definitely recommend daiquiri Deck to my friends and family.
Victor C — Google review
Great stop on our last day at the beach. Happy hour frozen daquiris are a must and a great buy. Try the deck diesel. We just had a few sides this trip, but their onion rings and fries are really good.
View was nice. Drinks were small. Food ok. Hush puppies were under cooked. Our waitress was very good.
We were pleasantly surprised by the food and delicious frozen drinks at this location. You get a view of the sunset if you’re on the upper deck. I got the fish sandwich. It was delicious. He got A chicken sandwich both were very good. But the fries are the star of the show. They’re excellent! Like perfect french fries… Hot crispy and perfectly seasoned yet tender inside. The frozen daiquiris were really yummy. We especially liked the banana. and coffee mixed and the banana and strawberry mixed. Casey was a sweetheart. Good music from the 90s playing.
Decent food, friendly servers, nice to eat out on the deck...famous for a big variety of daiquiris!
I didn't try any food during my visit, however I decided to come here after my visit to Crescent Beach and kill time before my dolphin sunset cruise.
I went to the location in Siesta Key Village and wanted to see how different this location is.
I loved how there's a upstairs deck and you have a wonderful view of the area, since there were kids upstairs I decided to stay downstairs.
Where I met a wonderful staff member (I forgot her name but it was her first day and she was very welcoming).
This spot was actually a lot more fun, they have a huge back area, a spinning wheel (I won a free drink) yay!, a nice huge selection of daiquiris.
I absolutely loved the giant chair to sit on, it's so much fun for a photo.
They also have this cool feature of a machine to make you own magnets and I loved it!
I hope to come back, this is one of my favorite spots!
I had the best experience at Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key, thanks to Gwen! She was so friendly, attentive, and made the whole visit so much fun. You can tell she truly cares about her guests, always smiling, checking in, and making great recommendations. The drinks were amazing and the vibe was perfect. If you stop by, definitely ask for Gwen — she’ll make your visit 10x better!
I came in last week and was so astonished with the service I was given. My server Pricilla was such a ray of sunshine. She was so attentive and super helpful with helping me figure out the happy hour menu. I recommend asking to have her serve you next time you come in!!!
1250 Stickney Point Rd, Siesta Key, FL 34242, USA•
Other best-of categories in Siesta Key
Top searches in Siesta Key
Popular road trips from Siesta Key
What's the weather like in Siesta Key?
It depends on when you visit! We've compiled data from NASA on what the weather is like in Siesta Key for each month of the year: see the links below for more information.
- Weather in Siesta Key in January
- Weather in Siesta Key in February
- Weather in Siesta Key in March
- Weather in Siesta Key in April
- Weather in Siesta Key in May
- Weather in Siesta Key in June
- Weather in Siesta Key in July
- Weather in Siesta Key in August
- Weather in Siesta Key in September
- Weather in Siesta Key in October
- Weather in Siesta Key in November
- Weather in Siesta Key in December
All road trips from Siesta Key
- Siesta Key to Orlando drive
- Siesta Key to New York City drive
- Siesta Key to Tampa drive
- Siesta Key to Miami Beach drive
- Siesta Key to St. Augustine drive
- Siesta Key to Washington DC drive
- Siesta Key to New Orleans drive
- Siesta Key to Naples drive
- Siesta Key to Chicago drive
- Siesta Key to Savannah drive
- Siesta Key to Atlanta drive
- Siesta Key to Sanibel Island drive
- Siesta Key to Nashville drive
- Siesta Key to Titusville drive
- Siesta Key to Charleston drive
- Siesta Key to Toronto drive
- Siesta Key to Boston drive
- Siesta Key to Gatlinburg drive
- Siesta Key to Miami drive
- Siesta Key to San Antonio drive
- Siesta Key to Daytona Beach drive
- Siesta Key to Philadelphia drive
- Siesta Key to Memphis drive
- Siesta Key to Myrtle Beach drive
- Siesta Key to Niagara Falls drive
- Siesta Key to West Palm Beach drive
- Siesta Key to Montreal drive
- Siesta Key to Winter Haven drive
- Siesta Key to Baltimore drive
- Siesta Key to Branson drive
Explore nearby places
- Siesta Key
- Sarasota
- Osprey
- Longboat Key
- Nokomis
- Venice
- Bradenton Beach
- Bradenton
- Ellenton
- Holmes Beach
- Anna Maria
- North Port
- Englewood
- Tierra Verde
- Port Charlotte
- St. Pete Beach
- St. Petersburg
- Apollo Beach
- Treasure Island
- Punta Gorda
- Madeira Beach
- Boca Grande
- Indian Shores
- Tampa
- Largo
- Clearwater
- Safety Harbor
- Dunedin
- Thonotosassa
- Palm Harbor
- Cape Coral
All related maps of Siesta Key
- Map of Siesta Key
- Map of Sarasota
- Map of Osprey
- Map of Longboat Key
- Map of Nokomis
- Map of Venice
- Map of Bradenton Beach
- Map of Bradenton
- Map of Ellenton
- Map of Holmes Beach
- Map of Anna Maria
- Map of North Port
- Map of Englewood
- Map of Tierra Verde
- Map of Port Charlotte
- Map of St. Pete Beach
- Map of St. Petersburg
- Map of Apollo Beach
- Map of Treasure Island
- Map of Punta Gorda
- Map of Madeira Beach
- Map of Boca Grande
- Map of Indian Shores
- Map of Tampa
- Map of Largo
- Map of Clearwater
- Map of Safety Harbor
- Map of Dunedin
- Map of Thonotosassa
- Map of Palm Harbor
- Map of Cape Coral
Siesta Key throughout the year
Looking for day-by-day itineraries in Siesta Key?
Get inspired for your trip to Siesta Key with our curated itineraries that are jam-packed with popular attractions everyday! Check them out here:
Best attractions in nearby cities
- Top things to do and attractions in Orlando
- Top things to do and attractions in Miami
- Top things to do and attractions in Tampa
- Top things to do and attractions in Fort Lauderdale
- Top things to do and attractions in Miami Beach
- Top things to do and attractions in St. Augustine
- Top things to do and attractions in Sarasota
- Top things to do and attractions in Naples
- Top things to do and attractions in St. Petersburg
- Top things to do and attractions in Fort Myers
- Top things to do and attractions in Clearwater
- Top things to do and attractions in Kissimmee
- Top things to do and attractions in Bradenton
- Top things to do and attractions in Fort Myers Beach
- Top things to do and attractions in Venice
- Top things to do and attractions in St. Pete Beach
- Top things to do and attractions in Punta Gorda
- Top things to do and attractions in Englewood
- Top things to do and attractions in Madeira Beach
- Top things to do and attractions in Holmes Beach
- Top things to do and attractions in Titusville
- Top things to do and attractions in Nokomis
- Top things to do and attractions in Anna Maria
- Top things to do and attractions in Apollo Beach
- Top things to do and attractions in Longboat Key
Best restaurants in nearby cities
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Orlando
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Miami
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Tampa
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Fort Lauderdale
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Miami Beach
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in St. Augustine
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Sarasota
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Naples
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in St. Petersburg
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Fort Myers
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Clearwater
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Kissimmee
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Bradenton
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Fort Myers Beach
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Venice
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in St. Pete Beach
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Punta Gorda
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Englewood
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Madeira Beach
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Holmes Beach
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Titusville
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Bradenton Beach
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Nokomis
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Anna Maria
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Apollo Beach
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Longboat Key
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Osprey
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Tierra Verde
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Sanibel Island
- Where to eat: the best restaurants in Ellenton
Planning a trip to Siesta Key?
Save all the best places to visit with WanderlogDownload the travel planning app everyone's been raving about
- Itinerary + map in one view
- Live collaboration
- Auto-import hotels and reservations
- Optimize your route
- Offline access on mobile
- Optimize your route
- See time and distance between all your places
