The 17 best cake shops and cake bakeries in Thunder Bay

Good vibes! The ladies who bake are passionate about their craft! They spoke to us with passion and you could tell they poured love into their baking! Establishment was clean. No seating. No washrooms

So the pictures contain 2 Deli Turkey Sandwiches and one CCBLT. All the sandwiches are delicious. I went to sweet north 3 times in a row for their sandwiches and I'll probably keep going there. I love that the sandwiches are prepared as you order so they're fresh. I really loved that. All the ingredients were so fresh and you could taste it. I would highly recommend it. I have only tried their sandwiches but I intend to try their other stuff too.

The iced latte and cookie were really good! Lots of pastry selection to choose from. The butter tarts would be better if they didn't store them in such a cold fridge; they are too hard and the filling inside is hard. The staff are very friendly; i dropped my butter tart and it was replaced immediately. Lots of nice seating inside.

I ordered 12 cookies & 3 small pieces of cake = $55.00, which I found pricey so I will not be returning.

Staff I encountered today were phenomenal. You are all doing a great job and the snacks were delicious.

If I could give this place double the stars I would. If you don't eat here at least once when visiting TB you are nuts. The BEST pretzel I have ever eaten. Get the salted warmed up with the beer cheddar dip. Had a fantastic bowl of loaded baked potato soup after going on a long walk about. The baked goods are delectable. Great selection of comfort foods and drinks. And they serve beer!! Cannot recommend this bakery cafe diner enough. 20/10 can't wait to come back for more!

Excellent service! Their recommendation for a breakfast pastry hit the spot when I was turning hangry. I'll definitely remember The Sweet North whenever I'm in town.

Our daughter’s custom birthday cake looked awesome and it was delicious as well. Super moist cake and tasty filling. Will definitely order again!

Ordered a tray of tea sndwiches for a luncheon. The bread was so fresh and the fillings were a good assortment with generous amount. Delicious! The tray of squares was also delicious and a good assortment.. Definitely recommend.

Ordered a baby shower cake. The cake wasn’t good in terms of taste. The cake was so hard and not even edible.

These gals were incredible. I called at noon looking for 18 donuts for 3 pm.. not only did theu personalize them to my kids liking but they were so fresh and sooo good.. compliments from the entire party. Talk about a hidden gem!!

The young lady at the counter was super friendly and knowledgeable. I think that her name is Susan, great job.

Ordered 24 cake pops for a birthday specifically asking for vanilla and pickup at 1030.... When I arrived the order wasn't ready and the store was empty. I was told it would be 30more minutes (there's a reason I set the pickup time for 1030 not 11).... When the birthday party went to try them they were all chocolate... Half the kids would not eat them, reached out via phone call and messages only to be completely ignored! I paid $90 for something I didn't even want. Extremely disappointed and will not recommend or be back.

Great job on my neice's wedding shower cake. Nicely done as well as very courteous staff. Thank you.

Went here when visiting the area in June. The service wasn't terribly friendly. My first time there so I had questions. No smile, very short with her answers. It seemed as though she wasn't having the best day. So, I got the Persian but the orange color one as she said it was the same flavor as the pink but a percentage went to a special cause I can't remember what. Also tried some other sweets. I may have gotten more if I didn't feel like I was putting her out. Either way, the pastries were good. Also bought some bread. Not sure I'd go back though. She treated the next customer the same way. But they do offer lunch and there is ample seating inside. So, hopefully your experience is better than mine.

For those of you who are wondering what a Persian is after being recommended one, it's a large yeast doughnut without a hole. Kinda like a Long John but wide as well (it's a pretty big pastry actually). What makes it special is the icing which is more like cake icing than your typical doughnut glaze. It's pretty good. Staff were very pleasant. Prices were reasonable. There were a variety of fresh and frozen baked goods available from the attached bakery. Dining area and rest rooms could use a thorough deep clean.

While spending several days in Thunder bay I did a search on local specialties, all the buzz was over the Persian, a cinnamon roll with pink icing. So we went to The Persian Man Bakery and purchased a few to see what all the fuss was about, and unfortunately we're disappointed. A Persian is basically a cinnamon roll style donut, deep fried, ours had very little cinnamon between the layers and had a pink icing that resembled a cream cheese frosting with maybe a hint of raspberry. Our examples, were ok, not bad , but unimpressive, and average at best. This may be unique here , but at home we could go to any bakery and get a similar product, but with multiple icing choices like: vanilla, chocolate,cream cheese, peanut butter, maple .... sorry.

Okay, okay the Persian and all the rave. It’s a kind of cinnabun / donut covered in thick rich butter icing, original is pink and other flavours are available. It’s a little heavy for my taste, but they do have pastries and savory options here like soups and sandwiches. I did liked the decadent cream puffs and tarts. You can dine in or take out. Prices are reasonable for a bakery type establishment. They also sell breads and other convenience store items. A place to visit for sure.

Omg. The donuts and coffee were the best! We shared an Italian sausage in a bun too. Highly recommend!

The Persian Man is an absolute Thunder Bay staple — and for good reason! Their desserts are out of this world — soft, sweet, and perfectly indulgent. The famous Persian is always fresh and delicious, and every visit feels like a little taste of local tradition. The staff are warm, friendly, and always make you feel welcome. Whether you’re grabbing a quick treat or bringing a box home to share, The Persian Man never disappoints. A must-stop for anyone in Thunder Bay!

We arrived at the store around 4:45 PM, excited to finally try this place after hearing so much about it. Unfortunately, we felt a bit rushed as the staff were getting ready to close, which made the experience feel a little hurried. We ordered the donuts with pink frosting. While the donuts were soft, they weren’t warm, and the frosting tasted fairly standard to me. I imagine that seasoned donut lovers may have tried more memorable options elsewhere. Overall, it wasn’t quite the standout experience we were hoping for. While it may still be worth trying for some, I wouldn’t say it’s a must-visit or something to rush for.

Taste good. Not too sweet. But it is not chewy like... I expect extra sweet when I eat macaron but this one is like eating snack. It is good for who doesn't like sugar high

I am not a coffee drinker, but their desserts are to die for! I've never found a bakery where I love every single option until now! It also has a warm atmosphere and service is always pleasant.

One of the best places for dessert in town. Their desserts are all delicious, from their 2$ cupcakes, to their cakes, bars, macarons, cookies, and cheesecakes - all are to die for. The staff is always super friendly and the inside is decorated with lots of local art. Perfect little spot to hang out with friends, have a romantic date, or just to treat yourself.

I held the door some someone on a bike entering the store. No "Thank you" at all. He takes his bike and goes into the kitchen, clearly showing me he works there. How ignorant. Staff here are always short with their service. Even from the older man who lacks a sense of humor. Instead of taking constructive criticism and handling it professionally, they lash out at you. Whether online on FB pages or emails. Their cupcakes are ok. Cake is better then the icing. Icing is bland. Red velvet it good!! Bars are overly sweet. I believe supporting local businesses but be friendlier. Say hello. Say thank you. Say goodbye. Be kind. It doesn't hurt. 3rd time here and my last

I have been here many times over several years. Not once have i had a bad experience. The bake goods are always amazing and the range of teas allows for everyone to find one they will like.

Awesome assortment of sweet treats. Something for everyone. Cupcakes , cakes , cookies , mufffins , loaves , squares , biscotti , macarons and I hope I have not forgotten anything. They have an assortment of teas , coffee ect. And have a nice environment to sit and enjoy yourself. We go there everywerk and download our week to each other .

I ordered for seventh heaven cake for my brother's birthday.The cake was in taste similar to its name, really yummy. As I placed order from India, they accommodated me so cordially.Thanks a lot.

The service was amazing!!! Walked in and immediately welcomed with the amazing smells and a friendly face! It was our first time in Thunder Bay, and I will be making a point to stop at Donato’s every time I come to Thunder Bay! We got butter tarts, cannoli, a peanut butter bar, and cherry cream puffs. They are all amazing!!! The kindness of the staff made this such an amazing experience!! You need to visit here!!!

It's my lucky day. It's thanksgiving Monday and my usual go to place for pumpkin pie was closed today. I was craving pumpkin pie and driving to Shoppers McInyre to get one of those mediocre pumpkin pies, when I happened to see this place open. I went inside and got a piece of cake and it was sooooooo good I ended up buying 5 more pieces and 2 large pizzas. I had the pizza here a long time ago and it is very good. So happy this place was open. Too bad the pumpkin pie was sold out, I will for sure be coming back to try that. The cake is just unbelievably good.

Came all the way from BC for a pizza! 🍕 This is the best pizza you will ever have! Every summer I make sure to pick up some baked goods and pizza :)

Best pizza in town. They have really great baking. Locally owned and operated. Nicest staff. Highly recommend!

My neighbour ordered a loaded pizza and gave me 2 large slices. I took the time to make this review because it’s probably the best pizza I’ve had in the city to date! Real mushrooms done to perfection, pizza sauce was fantastic and crust perfect! They didn’t miss a beat. Donato’s will now be by go to (and before this, I was not aware they even made pizza!

Did a turn and burn to thunder bay yesterday i was hungry and really wanted pizza ! I happen to drive by and remembered how much i liked it at donatos but haven't been there in years. Decided to stop in and grab a pizza. The service was instantly amazing ! The gentleman served me and helped me make a pizza , he was so friendly and his vibe was just winning ! His mama was doing till and she was the cutest and friendliest lady! I got my pizza and got asked to write a review (with a free dessert), and I was like heck yeah ill write one for you guys! Pizza was awesome , almost had the whole thing done by the time I got home .. 3 hrs away. Toppings were fresh, dough was awesome and that sauce 👌🏽 id love to taste their spaghetti lol All around awesome place ! Definitely check them out, they also have fresh bread/ buns , desserts and looked like ingredients to make pizza at home . Also my dessert was awesome, if it's called something else I apologize but positive it was a cinnamon roll! Dough was awesome, that sauce was great as well! Enjoyed a little of that on my ride home !

Food is very delicious, but they need to upgrade their packaging. 9 pieces put in 1 small container.

Gluten Free ALERT ! Ok we all know how awseome Agastino's Deli is . . . If you don't it's AWESOME ! BUT . . . They now have a gluten free Tiramisu that is made from scratch and TOO DIE. I also would highly recommend the g-free meatballs.

Warm friendly staff, best sandwich I've had in a long time. Great place for all types of meats, cheeses and the like. I'll be back

Grazie Agostino Deli for the delicious sandwiches and buns. Helped fuel our journey to the top of the giant. If anyone is new to the Thunder Bay Area or just passing through I highly recommend stopping here. Fresh bread and deli and friendly service. Not too many bakeries/deli like this around anymore, will definitely be going back.

Great store. Have gone there a few times now for getting supplies for making different pastas. Great selection of frozen Arancini ,Ravioli, Tortellini, meatballs, Chicken Parmigiana, fresh baked breads. Pkg soups, risotto.

Being from Toronto I miss a lot of things but this place makes me feel like home great staff that are always friendly with me they got good prices fresh Italian buns

Just went there for the first time today and omg absolutely hands down best sandwiches and service in town!!!

They’re our go-to for a charcuterie board. The selection is always fresh and well worth it!

Best donuts and persians in town. Service is exceptional. Their donuts and persians are sold fast. You better visit the bakery early in the morning and it's worth the effort. The donut is just melted in your mouth.

Great pastries. I especially love the glazed donuts and raspberry turnovers. My favorite stop when visiting TB!

Amazing Staff, very personable & always smiling! The baked goods are out of this world and surprisingly cheap for everything being made in house. Highly recommend this sweet bakery. 😍

Warm, welcoming atmosphere. The ladies working here made me wish we could have dined in. We're new to town, luckily we took home the famous donuts we've been hearing about, sausage rolls, and butter tarts. Can't wait to return! Thanks so much for the great treats and service!

The best honey glazed donuts! The staff are super friendly! Get there early, don't miss out!

Friendly staff. Great bakery items. Bread. Persians. Tarts.

In thunder bay for a conference with a mission to try a Persian. Our hotel concierge ordered them for us and picked them up as well!! Not disappointed. The donut was the perfect combination of sweet and cakey. Not heavy. Like eating a cloud!!

Last weekend I made a last minute cake order for a birthday. They made a beautifully done cake. Ive been ordering cakes from Carols for years and it never disappoints. The staff have always been very polite and professional. I will definitely be ordering very soon as I have a march birthday coming up. I recommend 💯% 👌 love Carol's cakes!

So grateful for Carol's Cakes. They went above and beyond with the theme, the cake was DELICIOUS and the price was more than reasonable! Thank you so much.

I ordered gluten free cake for a very special occasion. The cake was absolutely delicious and no one could believe it was gluten free! The photo we had them add on the top turned out so beautifully. Thank you so much - you will be getting many more new customers from our party.

I ordered the cake at the very last minute from carols cake , and I honestly wasn’t sure what to expect — but wow, it turned out amazing! Not only was it ready on such short notice, but it looked beautiful and tasted even better. The cake was super moist, flavorful, and just the right amount of sweetness. You’d never guess it was a rushed order — the quality was top-notch. Everyone who had a slice absolutely loved it, and I was seriously impressed by how fresh and well-decorated it was. Huge thanks to the team for pulling it off — you made my day! I’ll definitely be coming back for more.

I pre ordered a cake and when I got home I realized it had the wrong icing. I had asked for buttercream but it had whipped icing instead. A quick call to carols and they offered to remake the cake the same day with the correct icing. They were very understanding when I explained the issue. Thanks Carols for going above and beyond.

The birthday cake was delicious and absolutely beautiful. Ordering process was easy. My guests all enjoyed the cake!!! Will certainly order again

As a mother of 3, I’m extremely forgetful. Planned a retirement party for my mom and FORGOT to order the cake. Tried out the online ordering page, but nothing on there is what I was looking for. So I gave her a call (online it says no orders within 48 hours) which it was at the 48 hours. I wanted a basic cake, as I knew it was “last minute.” Tried asking for half chocolate, half vanilla ATLEAST. She was so rude about it with a very stern uh NO. No other explanation. I’m a very understanding person, if she would have elaborated with a “ohh no, I can’t due to the short notice, sorry” instead she gave me unnecessary attitude. At this point I knew she was going to continue giving me a hard time so I was nervous to ask for the colour theme we had planned. As I wanted a basic cake, I was originally okay with it as-is…until we received the cake today. A plain cake, with very little sprinkles. I’m wondering how she would feel bringing that her mother’s retirement party. Honestly would have been okay if she just told me NO altogether instead of the attitude due to short notice. Lol. Anyway, won’t be back

Ordered a salted Christmas ham in November, was told to pick up today, December 23. When I got there they acted all confused and couldn’t find our name on the order. I told them my wife ordered it in November and I even saw our name on the list I told them. She went to the back and had manager come out and tell me they sold our Christmas ham to someone else and nowhere else in town will have any, good luck. Piss poor service and have had a problem of some kind here every year. Will not be back or recommend to my enemy

I absolutely love love love the Beef Jerky here, it’s the most delicious, moist, perfectly spicy, not too spicy just the right kind of heat! They have an amazing selection of deli meats and fare, fresh bread and pepperettes! I really love the fact that they sell beef soup bones here too! The staff is always friendly and helpful, sometimes it feels like I’m visiting family when I come through the door and I am treated with love and kindness here!

This is the only place that I purchase my deli meat from. I grew up with meat from here as my dad and the owner were great friends. They’ve both passed on now but his son still continues the tradition of excellence and even though I’ve moved 4 hrs away, I bring my cooler bag and still pick up all my favourites every time I’m in Thunder Bay. The very best!!

Friendly, fast service. Very helpful and their smoked foods are incredible! I always buy their ribs and chicken every visit for our family. My daughter's favourite is the the smoked chicken and my hubby's favourite are the smoked chops.

I was immediately elated when I entered the store. They have an amazing selection of meats and goodies. The smell of wood smoke draws you in and makes the experience memorable. The staff is so friendly and helpful.

Omg I took pics. They did our pork belly and we always use thick slices. Wow smells, tastes awesome and the ham and hocks look absolutely fabulous. I'll do other pics as we use them. Thank you so much.......yummy

Number one in meats and sasages and real good jerky . All the time best place for meats

This place was recommended to be the best. looks delicious. Prices seemed reasonable. Friendly staff, kept talking. Don’t take credit cards. Wasn’t until after I left, I realized, was over charged by $10.00. I think she charged for a dozen instead of 6 Persian pastries.

Great place for Finnish baked goods. Can pre-order custom items. If for example you don't like too much sugar you can request not to add any extra on items.

Refused to let my 4 year old use the rest room in an emergency. Their treats are great but they lost a sale and future purchases from this family. You don't refuse a child the use of a bathroom, and then give the parent attitude when we have to leave. Use discretion next time

The most delish pumpkin pie I’ve eaten. Most are so sweet they lose the flavour, not this one. A real treat!

Purchased rolls, bread and coffee breads. Excellent quality and very enjoyable. Staff was pleasant and helpful. Try cinnamon coffee bread!

Wonderful cake with fresh strawberries and whipped cream. Best country rye bread and perfect pull a!

Local business, good quality baked goods, friendly staff

All of the reviews are true. This place is not kidding around with their croissants. Absolutely the most perfect croissants I've ever had. Absolutely gorgeous aesthetically, and so insanely delicious. Get in line early and get them before they sell out. The other pastries are also top notch. A blessing in downtown.

Visiting Thunder Bay for the weekend. Great pastries!!!! Have great specials. Get there soon after opening if you want full selection as things sell out

One of the best croissants I have ever had. The bakery changes menu every month, they have it posted on instagram. You have to get there early in the morning because everything is sold out pretty quick.

this charming local bakery will blow you away with their selection of incredible pastries! The flaky, buttery goodness simply melts in your mouth with each bite. The welcoming atmosphere only adds to the experience. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area! Best little bakery in the heart of DT Port Arthur

Delicious croissants and pastries! The baked goods here are fresh, flakey and oh so delicious. You have to arrive early to get the most variety of flavors before they sell out, but honestly anything you buy here is going to be fantastic.

Best pastry shop in Thunder Bay, possibly the world. Each delicacy is an artisanal gem. Limited supply. They are only open Thu-Sat and sell out a few hours after opening. Line up at least 15min before 9am for complete selection.

Was recommended this place by and friend and it did not disappoint!! Not a single dessert has been anything but mouthwatering. Top favourite so far…VANILLA BEAN COOKIE :))) A hidden gem in Thunder Bay for sure, take a visit to swell you will not regret it!

I ordered iced hazelnut mocha and it tasted so good! Beautiful clean ambiance and the nicest barista! Loved it

Best thing to happened to Marina park!Great view to Lake Superior and you can enjoy the coffee at the same time!Coffee is fantastic as well there great delicious cookies!Great service and looking forward to be back again and would highly recommend them!10 out of 10!

Friendly service and great coffee. Beautiful spot to sit out front and enjoy the seaside views. What more could you want?!

I’m a regular at Windy Shores, it’s my favourite cafe in town! Sadie and Kyle are amazing - welcoming and professional. I’m always greeted like a friend. (And to the woman who said Sadie greeted her with a frown, and the oat milk latte was sour - nothing could be further from the truth! Sadie is sweet and kind, and the oat milk latte is my regular drink - I had just had an excellent one that very afternoon!) Anne O’Brien

Ordered a latte with oat milk, which I felt was over priced and was very disappointed when I couldn’t even enjoy it because it tasted so sour! Could only bring myself to drink a third and now have a belly ache. The girl working had a frown on her face and did not seem particularly friendly. Only thing this place has going for it as far as my experience is the location. Will return tomorrow and see if they can make it up to me and may change my mind.

Great location! We sit on the patio or take our items out into the marina. Great variety of different hot and cold drinks, and amazing baking! The orange glazed cookies are delightful. Staff are always friendly and inviting and happy to explain the more upscale drinks on their menu! I've become a regular.

When I first moved to Thunder Bay, and I had no friends, I decided that I was going to try all the cafes in the area to amuse myself. I even made a whole ranking system for my cafe visits. Windy Shores Cafe ranked the highest out of all the cafes in the area, and my experiences with the FRIENDLY staff just keeps getting better and better. They have a great selection of drinks, fresh baked goods, and a comfy/aesthetic sitting area. They're also one of the few cafes open on sunday. You'd be hard pressed to find a better location tbh. I can't say enough good things about this place.

Everything I've ever had at Uncommon Baked Goods has become my new favourite treat - which is why I ordered a custom cake from them for my wedding. It was probably a shorter turnaround than most custom orders, but it turned out absolutely fantastic. I seriously could not have asked for a better cake or a better experience.

Uncommon baked goods has become a Sunday tradition for my family! Grabbing a delicious cup of coffee every time we come here and being greeted in such a friendly way! Place is always clean and tidy and has delicious desserts. Would recommend to anyone looking for a tasty and warm cup of coffee. Hope to see them in a store some day 😊

This is the best baking in town. The creativity of the owner and pastry chef is unparalleled in Thunder Bay. I've been told by more than one person that the croissants are the best they've had. I cannot wait for the Christmas goodies and stocking stuffers! The lumps of coal and caramels are incredible.

Uncommon Baked Goods was a great find, everything we tried was top notch. We stopped in after grabbing coffee at St. Paul Roastery, and it more than made up for their neighbor bakery "Swell" being sold out. Plus, the market it’s in has a great vibe overall.

I’ve had wonderful experiences with the most delicious treats here! The highlight was definitely the London Fog – it was the absolute best! Reasonably priced and I can’t wait to go back :)

Ordered ham and cheese roll it was good. Price is genuine.

From someone who lived in Montreal for 10 years, I have to say this is one of the best croissants you can find in Canada

Amazing find... The staff were friendly, prices reasonable, food was tasty. And the sizes were good too.. a great place for those with Gluten issues.

Gluten free baked goods that have a good texture and don't have the cardboard gluten free taste!

Great gluten-free bakery. Food is delicious!

Wonderful owner, great custom made birthday cake and speedy delivery.

Great pizza and unique tasting. We're from the USA. Our relatives served us Eat Local at a family reunion.

Thanks, it's great to order pizza that does not taste like a "generic" pizza. Keep it up!

I love this place great pizza and very friendly

Eat local is an healthy pazza plece in town!!!!

Their number is no longer in service

Just tried to eat a Pep&Cheese pizza severed from the satellite location inside the Eaton's Building (Goods&Co.) The only thing Hand's about this is it was Hands down the Worst pizza I've ever had. No where on their boards do they mention its not a regular crust, nvm that is whole wheat or something drier and as thin as the cardboard box it came in. After I got it I thought I'd give it a chance anyways. The blend of mozza and gouda was ok at best, but they could of used pizza grade instead of bulk store quality cheese. The little bit of pepperoni barely gave it a taste of it to know it was there and lastly, the sauce tastes like nothing more that tomato soup out of a no name can before you add the extra water. Nvr will I go back.

We were really looking forward to trying your pizza, but unfortunately a few things fell short. Some of the ingredients we wanted weren’t available when ordering, so we went with bacon, mushroom, and pesto. When we got home, we realized the pesto was missing from the pizza, which was disappointing—especially considering the price point. We also found the pizzas to be quite oily. That said, we did enjoy the base and overall flavours, and the restaurant has a great vibe.

Oh...WOW!! This pizza was fantastic! First time visiting the area and so thrilled to have found this little pizzeria. One of the top pizzas I have ever had. Staff were very friendly and our pizza came out pretty quick. I wish I had been able to try their bread too. Located in an old house, the dining area has tons of character; it's small though so no large groups. If you are visiting Thunder Bay and you want pizza, you HAVE to come here. Watch their hours - open Wed-Sat only.

Excellent pizzeria, probably one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Due to a change in ownership, alcoholic drinks are currently not available. Service was very attentive and polite. Two of us shared a 16" pizza and it was more than enough.

"The 'Fungus Among Us' pizza is an absolute delight. The blend of mushrooms, onions, and green olives creates a perfect balance of savory and tangy flavors. The thin sourdough crust made from local Brule Creek Farms Flour is a crispy masterpiece. The mozzarella and Thunder Oak Gouda cheese blend adds a creamy richness that's truly exceptional. Customize it with three toppings or try it as is – either way, it's a must-try for pizza lovers. This one has become my favorite, and I keep coming back for more!"

I just dropped by this afternoon to pick up a loaf of bread as I had a free coupon. The warmth and friendly atmosphere in this establishment is second to none. I have had the pizza before and it is very good as is the staff. I would recommend both hands to everyone.

We stopped by Wood Fired one evening, and the pizza was absolutely amazing! The dough tasted super fresh, and the cheese just melted perfectly. It took about 20-30 minutes, but you could tell it was made fresh. Mostly thin crust options, and honestly, I’d love to come back!