Lucy's New York Style Pizza

4.4
(1122)
•
4.2
(69)
4.4
(1122)
•
4.2
(69)
•#14 on "Where to eat: the 50 best restaurants in Idaho Falls"
cheap
Pizza restaurant
Placeholder

About

Lucy's New York Style Pizzeria is a humble local chain restaurant that offers thin-crust pizza, calzones, subs, and salads. It has been voted by the locals as Idaho Falls' best pizza place. Specializing in New York-style pizza, Lucy's uses hand-tossed dough with a thin crust. The popularity of this pizza joint is evident with three locations in Idaho and one in Utah.
Why you should go
    1
  1. Experience authentic New York Style Pizza baked in a high-temperature Italian oven
    2. 2
  2. Enjoy specialty pies like Zestpian or CCB with unique toppings such as sauerkraut and salami
    3. 3
  3. Situated near the Japanese Friendship Garden on Broadway Street offering beautiful views during summer months
Your itinerary and your map in one view

No more switching between different apps, tabs, and tools to keep track of your travel plans.

Learn more
What users say about the app
Love love love! ❤️ Planning travel has actually been fun instead of tedious because of this app.
J
Julie G.
Exactly what I needed to plan a trip. I can’t imagine anyone not loving this app!
J
Jen S.
Wanderlog makes planning a trip so effortless. Seriously, this app does it all!
B
Brad C.
This site and app let me do all the planning for our 15 day trip in a little over 6 hours! I can’t recommend it enough!
A
Amanda W.
Amazing!! The organization this app provides has taken a huge weight off my shoulders.
G
Garrett V.
This is the crème de la crème of planning apps! Don’t think about it - just click download right this minute.
C
Chris C.

Your itinerary and your map in one view

No more switching between different apps, tabs, and tools to keep track of your travel plans.

Menu and popular items

Map
Address
560 W Broadway St, Idaho Falls, ID 83402, USA
Website
https://www.lucysnypizza.com/
Phone
(208) 524-2800
Hours
Su
Sunday: Closed
MoMonday: 10:30AM–9PM
TuTuesday: 10:30AM–9PM
WeWednesday: 10:30AM–9PM
ThThursday: 10:30AM–9PM
FrFriday: 10:30AM–10PM
SaSaturday: 10:30AM–10PM
560 W Broadway St, Idaho Falls, ID 83402, USA
Wednesday: 10:30AM–9PM
Su
MoTuWeThFrSa
Su
Sunday: Closed
MoMonday: 10:30AM–9PM
TuTuesday: 10:30AM–9PM
WeWednesday: 10:30AM–9PM
ThThursday: 10:30AM–9PM
FrFriday: 10:30AM–10PM
SaSaturday: 10:30AM–10PM
People typically spend 1 hr here
(208) 524-2800
https://www.lucysnypizza.com/

Highlighted reviews

Slide 1 of 3
The first bite? It's like a party in your mouth and everyone's invited... especially your tastebuds, they're the VIPs. It's a whole mood. You'll forget your troubles, your bills, maybe even your own name for a few minutes. It's so good, it's almost suspicious. Through the eating experience, you'll probably make involuntary happy noises. You might start inventing new words to describe the flavor. Don't be surprised if you find yourself trying to hug the pizza. It's a natural reaction to something this good. So, if you're tired of pizza that's just food, then get yourself to this place. It's a guaranteed riot for your tastebuds. Just be prepared to have your pizza standards raised so high, every other pizza place will seem like a sad imitation. You've been warned... and you're welcome! 😉🍕 Go grab these pies now!
So I had the meatball sub...and the bun was a bit charred and the cheese was barely melted...sauce was skimpy as well as the cheese...and no way the sliced meatballs were 10 ounces! And sadly the meatballs were either bad...they tasted ok...but they literally had me on the toilet for 2 days! I should have had the pizza!
We have been long time customers and always happy with service and the food. However the past few times they have messed up our order whether it be forgetting sodas and then they come back 45 minutes to an hour later after everyone has eaten. To forgetting one pizza we ordered and then they say oh we can bring it to you, again another 45 minutes and also not to mention the slimy disgusting salad they brought to us. Then forgetting cheese bread and bringing it later again which we asked for a refund and refused. Today was my last straw ordering from Lucy’s pizza. They arrived 25 minutes late than they stated, the gave us the wrong pizza and burnt the calzone. My husband called them and they refused to refund the whole pizza because they got the other half of the pizza correct lol. So they refunded for the half of pizza . Also they requested pictures of the food because I assume they didn’t believe us so they needed proof.So ridiculous! I don’t know what’s happened to this location but I hope one day they get it together
The first bite? It's like a party in your mouth and everyone's invited... especially your tastebuds, they're the VIPs. It's a whole mood. You'll forget your troubles, your bills, maybe even your own name for a few minutes. It's so good, it's almost suspicious. Through the eating experience, you'll probably make involuntary happy noises. You might start inventing new words to describe the flavor. Don't be surprised if you find yourself trying to hug the pizza. It's a natural reaction to something this good. So, if you're tired of pizza that's just food, then get yourself to this place. It's a guaranteed riot for your tastebuds. Just be prepared to have your pizza standards raised so high, every other pizza place will seem like a sad imitation. You've been warned... and you're welcome! 😉🍕 Go grab these pies now!
So I had the meatball sub...and the bun was a bit charred and the cheese was barely melted...sauce was skimpy as well as the cheese...and no way the sliced meatballs were 10 ounces! And sadly the meatballs were either bad...they tasted ok...but they literally had me on the toilet for 2 days! I should have had the pizza!
We have been long time customers and always happy with service and the food. However the past few times they have messed up our order whether it be forgetting sodas and then they come back 45 minutes to an hour later after everyone has eaten. To forgetting one pizza we ordered and then they say oh we can bring it to you, again another 45 minutes and also not to mention the slimy disgusting salad they brought to us. Then forgetting cheese bread and bringing it later again which we asked for a refund and refused. Today was my last straw ordering from Lucy’s pizza. They arrived 25 minutes late than they stated, the gave us the wrong pizza and burnt the calzone. My husband called them and they refused to refund the whole pizza because they got the other half of the pizza correct lol. So they refunded for the half of pizza . Also they requested pictures of the food because I assume they didn’t believe us so they needed proof.So ridiculous! I don’t know what’s happened to this location but I hope one day they get it together
See all reviews

Know before you go

  • Try specialty pies like Zestpian or CCB to experience unique flavor combinations
  • Visit during summer months to enjoy sitting outside by the Snake River and soaking up the warm weather
  • Consider ordering classic favorites like antipasto salad, cheese sticks, or cannolis along with their renowned pizzas

Reviews

Lucy's New York Style Pizza has received mixed reviews, with some customers praising the delicious and flavorful pizzas that make them forget their troubles, while others have experienced issues with orders being incorrect or late. The pizza is described as a party in your mouth, raising the standards for all other pizzas. Positive comments highlight the thin crisp crust, flavorful toppings like salami and mushrooms, friendly service from staff members like Ryan who went above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience. Despite occasional mishaps with orders and burnt food mentioned by some reviewers, Lucy's remains a popular spot for its incredible food offerings.
Review score
4.4
out of 5
Excellent
1122 reviews
From Google
Review score
4.2
out of 5
Very Good
69 reviews
From Tripadvisor
5 stars
738
4 stars
217
3 stars
60
2 stars
45
1 star
62
5/5Zephyr F
•
Apr 30, 2025 from
Google
The first bite? It's like a party in your mouth and everyone's invited... especially your tastebuds, they're the VIPs. It's a whole mood. You'll forget your troubles, your bills, maybe even your own name for a few minutes. It's so good, it's almost suspicious. Through the eating experience, you'll probably make involuntary happy noises. You might start inventing new words to describe the flavor. Don't be surprised if you find yourself trying to hug the pizza. It's a natural reaction to something this good. So, if you're tired of pizza that's just food, then get yourself to this place. It's a guaranteed riot for your tastebuds. Just be prepared to have your pizza standards raised so high, every other pizza place will seem like a sad imitation. You've been warned... and you're welcome! 😉🍕 Go grab these pies now!
1/5Elijah M
•
Jan 23, 2025 from
Google
So I had the meatball sub...and the bun was a bit charred and the cheese was barely melted...sauce was skimpy as well as the cheese...and no way the sliced meatballs were 10 ounces! And sadly the meatballs were either bad...they tasted ok...but they literally had me on the toilet for 2 days! I should have had the pizza!
1/5Taylor M
•
Aug 15, 2025 from
Google
We have been long time customers and always happy with service and the food. However the past few times they have messed up our order whether it be forgetting sodas and then they come back 45 minutes to an hour later after everyone has eaten. To forgetting one pizza we ordered and then they say oh we can bring it to you, again another 45 minutes and also not to mention the slimy disgusting salad they brought to us. Then forgetting cheese bread and bringing it later again which we asked for a refund and refused. Today was my last straw ordering from Lucy’s pizza. They arrived 25 minutes late than they stated, the gave us the wrong pizza and burnt the calzone. My husband called them and they refused to refund the whole pizza because they got the other half of the pizza correct lol. So they refunded for the half of pizza . Also they requested pictures of the food because I assume they didn’t believe us so they needed proof.So ridiculous! I don’t know what’s happened to this location but I hope one day they get it together
4/5Eric N
•
Jul 12, 2025 from
Google
Amazing pie! Some of the best pizza I’ve tasted. Cool location, fast service, fair prices, amazing food. Only crime here is not having Coke.
5/5Bob B
•
Jul 25, 2025 from
Google
Well done Lucy's. NY style sounds easy but it's not. Thin crisp crust with also a good chew is tough to get right and you did it well. Everything had good flavor, the crust, the sauce, the cheese, the salami, the mushrooms. The service was great the young lady that took my order and ran the register was super, great attitude, smile and personality. She even did a great job getting those canoli's put together. We were just passing through, but if ever in the area again this place is definitely on the list.
All Google Maps reviews
All Tripadvisor reviews
Create your ultimate travel itinerary

Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.

Learn more

Create your ultimate travel itinerary

Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.

Map
Address
560 W Broadway St, Idaho Falls, ID 83402, USA
Website
https://www.lucysnypizza.com/
Phone
(208) 524-2800
Hours
Su
Sunday: Closed
MoMonday: 10:30AM–9PM
TuTuesday: 10:30AM–9PM
WeWednesday: 10:30AM–9PM
ThThursday: 10:30AM–9PM
FrFriday: 10:30AM–10PM
SaSaturday: 10:30AM–10PM
560 W Broadway St, Idaho Falls, ID 83402, USA
Wednesday: 10:30AM–9PM
Su
MoTuWeThFrSa
Su
Sunday: Closed
MoMonday: 10:30AM–9PM
TuTuesday: 10:30AM–9PM
WeWednesday: 10:30AM–9PM
ThThursday: 10:30AM–9PM
FrFriday: 10:30AM–10PM
SaSaturday: 10:30AM–10PM
People typically spend 1 hr here
(208) 524-2800
https://www.lucysnypizza.com/