Trumansburg

Trumansburg is a village in Tompkins County, New York, United States. The population was 1,797 at the 2010 census. The name incorporates a misspelling of the surname of the founder, Abner Treman. The Tremans spelled their surname several different ways; "Truman," however, was not one of them. Wikipedia.
When is your trip?

Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Categories

Trumansburg on your mind?

Build, organize, and map out your best trip yet.
Need a place to stay?
When

Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

When

Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

When

Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Travelers
2
Featured guides
Slide 1 of 1
Picture of 3-Day Trumansburg Itinerary
3-Day Trumansburg Itinerary
Most popular travel itinerary
Site icon
Wanderlog

Top places to visit

4.4
(544)
4.2
(128)
Mentioned on 
cheap
American restaurant
Breakfast restaurant
Falls Restaurant & Catering, a beloved establishment in Trumansburg since 1988, is a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're in the mood for breakfast, brunch, lunch, or dinner, this family-owned restaurant has got you covered. The menu features classic diner fare as well as creative additions and a rotating selection of specials. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it a welcoming place to enjoy a meal any time of day.
We stopped in at Falls Restaurant after spending the morning exploring the trails at Taughannock Falls. What a wonderful surprise. You’ll be hard pressed to find an establishment like this out in the wild these days, but the Falls has been around since 1988. A great little spot with ample seating, great staff, and a menu of homemade breakfast and lunch items. We got the tuna melt, Falls harvest salad, and homemade creamy cauliflower soup and it was all absolutely delicious. Excellent service, both the bartender and our server were so sweet. Stop in for a delicious home cooked meal and you won’t regret it.
Evan S — Google review
Do not get the fish 😒 was just looking for a quick bite while in the area hiking. Saw tons of people in the morning there so decided to stop in for late lunch. Not what we expected on the inside. Bar area was the only spot open to eat, the regular dining area was closed off. The bar area has a dark dirty atmosphere, very different from the rest of the restaurant. The fish and chips was disgusting, burnt geasy hockey pucks with very little fish and a ton of greasy breaded coating. Cousin loved the macaroni salad tho. Ladies were nice, just not attentive to customers. I wouldn't be back
Tracey ( — Google review
Falls Restaurant is an absolute gem! From the moment we walked in, we were welcomed with warm hospitality and a cozy atmosphere. The menu offers a fantastic variety, and every dish we tried was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. Service was prompt and attentive without ever feeling rushed, which made the whole experience even better. The attention to detail, from presentation to taste, truly sets this place apart. Whether you’re stopping in for a casual meal or a special occasion, Falls Restaurant delivers every time. Highly recommend!
Matthew A — Google review
Nice diner type restaurant. Homemade bread looked very good on the sandwiches. My mother-in-law ordered the carrot cake which she liked. I did not see nor were we offered kids menus. The waitress did bring a coloring book and crayons for the kids to color in which was nice but not everyone would appreciate that it was already colored on most pages. But the restaurant was cozy and clean, wait staff was friendly and food was good enough.
Crissy C — Google review
We stopped here for breakfast before hiking to the falls. Great food, but the best was our waitress, Denise. Wonderful sense of humor and she gave us some info about the falls.
Claudia L — Google review
Good basic American cuisine! Went here for lunch and I definitely recommend the fried mushrooms, the cheesesteak, the fish sandwich and strawberry rhubarb! The service was good. The prices were affordable. Check this place out!!
Marion N — Google review
Always great food and good service. The specials are always great, so check the board on the way to the table.
Robert D — Google review
Always good, homemade food. Reasonably priced. Friendly service. Just watch out for the lunch rush, it gets very packed.
Neil W — Google review
4.7
(211)
Mentioned on 
Festival
The Finger Lakes GrassRoots Festival of Music and Dance is an annual event that brings together volunteers to build a stage and create a permanent community installation. The festival offers a diverse range of food vendors, with options ranging from gyros to catfish to pizza. With over 40 bands performing on four stages for four days, the music is a major draw, creating an atmosphere where dancing in the rain is encouraged.
This festival is magical! It is great for all ages and all different types of music. Beautiful area, amazing music and food. The Across the way camping was absolutely amazing, would recommend this festival to all my family and friends! Cant wait to go back!
Dasha A — Google review
Amazing fun festival. Looking forward to next year 🎶💃✨️🕺
Jennifer R — Google review
Off the chain. Today is the last day until next year. Great music. Great food. Great people. If your not having fun here. Then I'm sorry to tell you, but you must be a very miserable person. An nothing can help you! There is something here for everyone...
Willie I — Google review
Grass Roots Music and Dance Festival is an Amazing event. If you’re a fan of live music you can see acts from all across the country and world! With 4 days and 4 stages it is a must see event!
Ted G — Google review
This festival is really family-oriented. it's been going on for 30 years now. Wonderful wide variety of music, great food, the facilities are always very clean, everyone that works there is very nice. They've really worked the kinks out after 30 years of having this festival.
GDam — Google review
Awesome time for the whole family .4 days of music & dance 4 stages ,crafts .Vendors lots of food for every appetite .The bathrooms are very clean .the atmosphere is amazing.something for everyone .an amazing time ! Loved
Linda C — Google review
If ya haven't been, ya oughta go. Best little festival on the East coast. Awesome family vibe, still no corporate funding and incredible variety of music. The energy you take home lasts for days. Just like they say, "It's a music lovers paradise." Alright, alright, alright...✌
Popsomali — Google review
Thank you to grassroots for the press passes to this amazing event it was my first year going and best believe I will be back next year. One of the most positive weekends of my life so much love, amazing musicians and the loving people. I recommend going to grassroots to people of all ages
Don P — Google review
4.8
(11)
4.0
(1)
Mentioned on 
Museum
The Ulysses Historical Society in Trumansburg is a must-visit for history enthusiasts. The society's museum showcases exhibits that vividly depict the area's rich history, including its surrounding hamlets. Visitors can explore well-preserved architecture and learn about the region's past through various programs and events. The society also offers a pleasant coffee hour and has published an essential book called 'Tales of Trumansburg.'
A great place to visit to learn about the area. Sadly they lost Joe Baldwin who everyone loved and respected. He played a huge part of making this neat place what it is. He will be missed. Stop by and check and see what this area looked like through the years. Lots of parking and handicap accessible. If you are not from the area spend some time in town there are some unique places to visit and eat some awesome food.
William F — Google review
We attended a talk by Richard Koski about the history of the Finnish population in this area thru the years. Very interesting and informative. Glad we have such a place that these kinds of programs can be presented. The staff provided a very pleasant coffee hour afterwards
Mary M — Google review
So glad we have a group of dedicated people to preserve history for all of us to learn from. Excellent exhibits. Latest book, "Tales of Trumansburg", is a must have book.
Carol D — Google review
Lots of great stuff here
Larry P — Google review
Good place for a bit of local history
Fred S — Google review
So much history!
PamJ O — Google review
Good information
James R — Google review
4.6
(88)
4.0
(2)
Mentioned on 
Farmers' market
Shopping
Farmers Markets
The Trumansburg Farmers' Market is a charming weekly event in the picturesque village of Trumansburg. It offers a wide variety of locally sourced products including fresh produce, baked goods, artisan crafts, and more. Visitors can enjoy live music while exploring the market's offerings in a family-friendly atmosphere. The market also features handmade items like durable brooms and goat milk soap, as well as options for wine and beer tastings.
The Trumansburg Farmers Market is such a lovely scene. There are a wonderful mix of vendors, options to eat while you’re there, and live music happening every week. Parking is convenient and the location is central so that Village residents have the option to walk or bike there.
Nana P — Google review
A decent venue filled with old hippies, except they were completely exclusive which is ironic. Definitely not a welcoming vibe after getting yelled at in the parking lot while waiting for a parking spot. Visitors beware.
Jeremiah M — Google review
This farmers market usually has a diverse selection of foods and other items. A bathroom is present as well as a children's play area. Usually live music is present.
Jesse B — Google review
Great little place every Wednesday 4-7. People talking, kids playing, dogs relaxing! Local wendors selling their homemade, home grown product. Family atmosphere all around!
Norbert B — Google review
This is one of my favorite farmers' markets!
Marcus S — Google review
We live only a few miles from Trumansburg so often attend the Farmer's Market. We love the people and what they sell here.
Emily-Jo C — Google review
Delightful farmers market and community gathering spot. Small, but everything good quality and friendly atmosphere. There was an excellent live band playing the day we were there in late August.
Helix R — Google review
This is a wonderful bucolic Farmers market located in the beautiful village of Trumansburg. Features fresh garden produce, artisan products and live music weekly on Wednesday from 4 till 7 p.m. a very family-friendly atmosphere. Come visit take off your shoes and wander in the grass while sipping lemonade and fresh farm offerings, such as gourmet cheese, and local wines.
Frank L — Google review
4.6
(268)
4.5
(59)
Mentioned on 
affordable
Coffee shop
Gimme! Coffee is a small cafe located in the heart of Trumansburg, offering espresso, drip brews, and small-batch roasted coffee beans. It's known for its excellent service and baristas, as well as delicious coffee snacks. The cozy atmosphere inside makes it a great place to spend time with family and friends. Additionally, they have an outdoor patio next to a creek and offer WiFi for customers. Visitors can also trade house plants here.
We visited the Gimme! Coffee shop while in Trumansburg. The roast I had was great as well as their banana bread. I bought two bags of beans while I was there - Stargazer and Midwinter. Stargazer is very delicious with flavors of chocolate, raspberry, butterscotch and almond. I haven't tried Midwinter yet.
Kate Z — Google review
Good coffee and nice outdoor seating outside
Rahul S — Google review
Love this place. It’s truly the quintessential coffee shop. Espresso drinks done right, high quality drip, and always a great selection of pastries. Appreciate the variety of drip on offer as well. Their beans are top notch and can meet any taste preferences. Quick and friendly service, too. Highly recommend Gimme and this location especially.
Tom G — Google review
A fantastic coffee shop if there ever was one. Yes, it is small inside, but the baristas were super friendly and efficient and kept the line moving quickly. Our drinks were absolutely phenomenal - rich espresso, earthy and smooth matcha, and perfectly spiced chai. We very much enjoyed sitting on the little patio and sipping our drinks.:) My only small recommendation is that the list of syrups be hung up so you can see it while you’re in line…I drink my coffee/matcha unsweetened, but others in my group struggled with not being able to see the options until it was time to order.
Adelaide M — Google review
One of my favorite Gimme! locations. There are some seats inside and on the deck but not a lot. Great for stopping in and grabbing a quick coffee and snack. The deck access and views of the creek are quite nice, especially in the spring and summertime.
Leah — Google review
Amazing coffee. Decaf, regular, matcha - it was all five stars!!! They even accommodated the kids and made chocolate milk :) And THANK YOU for not charging for stickers. It just makes me want to buy more stuff ❤️❤️ which we did :)
Chris S — Google review
Great coffee delicious pastries and awesome service!!! This is one God coffee place. Atmosphere inside is good, nice and cozy. People are nice and friendly. Coffee fresh. Lattes are good! Good place to spend some time with family and friends. Prices are friendly.
Alexander S — Google review
This is the coffee shop that I compare all other coffee shops too. They have the best service and baristas around. Gimme! Coffee has really good coffee snacks. You can trade house plants here, you will see what I mean if you visit. They have an outdoor patio right next to a creek. Wifi is also available.
Jesse B — Google review

Top places to eat

4.7
(395)
4.6
(416)
Mentioned on 
Permanently Closed
affordable
Restaurant
Hazelnut Kitchen is a charming restaurant in Trumansburg that offers seasonal dishes and desserts made from local ingredients. Despite its small-town setting, the eatery aims to blend regional flavors with a casually elegant atmosphere, creating unique dishes perfect for the Finger Lakes region. The cozy spot features checkered-tile flooring, mismatched silverware, and an open kitchen where Philly transplant chefs prepare rustic-elegant meals using locally grown produce, grass-fed beef, and cheeses from nearby dairies.
We had the most delicious and delightful dinner experience here last week. Our server, MATT was patient, helpful, and responsive. The wine choices are plentiful. The food choices are few, but everything is delicious! We each totally enjoyed what we ordered. The 6 of us definitely recommend this restaurant for wonderful dining.
Joan K — Google review
Let's begin with the food. It was well presented, locally sourced, fresh, and absolutely delicious! After our meal, we spoke with the owner/chef, expressing our compliments for his culinary skills. He was engaging and shared with us the history of the building and how it became Hazelnut Kitchen. In all, we had a great dining experience. I would recommend it.
Wayne M — Google review
I am sooo grateful that Hazelnut Kitchen was able to squeeze me in at their counter. Actually- it was the best seat in the house! I had the pleasure of interacting with the kitchen staff as they crafted some absolutely delicious meals. I had the beets, the schnitzel, and some absolutely stunning chocolate dessert (plus a slice of the grape pie which the one chef really wanted me to taste). Best meal I’ve had in a long time- well done.
Emily C — Google review
We had an amazing anniversary meal here! Everything is so fresh, farm to table quality. Highly recommend the heirloom tomatoes and crispy pork belly appetizers, swordfish, and chocolate tarte. We also had the chicken schnitzel and it was perfectly crispy and so delicious! Will definitely be back next time we visit the area!
Melissa B — Google review
When I vacation with my wife at our family cottage at Cayuga Lake, we always make sure we grab dinner at Hazelnut Kitchen. We had our post-engagement dinner here, and we just had our fourth anniversary dinner here too (with a few in between). The food is ALWAYS exceptional. This year’s pork was particularly outstanding. A true gem of upstate NY!
Michael M — Google review
This was excellent. We had dinner in early August and the food was very good: I had the complementary bread with chive butter, feta-stuffed squash blossom tempura (amazing!) and mezzaluna in a sweet corn-based sauce. Each was excellent and each was original. I'll definitely be back.
Mark O — Google review
Went rent a cottage on Cayuga each year and always put Hazelnut Kitchen on our ‘do not miss’ list. The food was D-LISH! Bread service was nice- a little dark & crispy but slathered in the chive butter, YUM! We shared the smoked trout spread topped with tart cherries & served with yummy GF seed crackers. Spot on! I had the chicken schnitzel topped with a delicious creamy cilantro sauce and my hubby had the rabbit wrapped in bacon served with polenta & escarole. Both… A-MAZ-ING!! Nice wine selection and they always offer delicious desserts. We were just too full this time! Be sure to make a reservation, as it’s small and intimate. A limited number of table. ENJOY!
Kerstin D — Google review
Just what we were looking for! Creative cooking and menu that highlights local farms in season! Interesting ingredients too. Sat at the bar on Weds night and was pleasantly surprised that was actually a seat next to the open kitchen. Very fun to see the chef and staff in action. Ended up chatting with the chef owner who was super cool. Highly recommend for a delicious and fresh meal. Nice portions too. Had a refreshing cocktail too.
Betty C — Google review
4.8
(161)
4.5
(43)
Mentioned on 
affordable
Cafe
Nestled by Trumansburg Creek, Creekside Cafe in Trumansburg offers a unique farm-to-table dining experience with a menu featuring delightful baked goods, sandwiches, and salads. The cafe is renowned for its all-day breakfast selection, including burritos, tacos, and an array of breakfast sandwiches like the VP - a combination of fried egg, ham, caramelized onion, and melted gruyere cheese on a toasted buttered roll.
It’s late, and I should be sleeping, but I am still thinking about the Garden Delight sandwich from earlier today… fresh veggies, sliced cheddar, a perfectly baked baguette with lemon mayo. I only wish I didn’t eat it all so I could eat the rest now. Thank you Creekside! This is my new favorite. ❤️
Nadia D — Google review
Amazing Cafe! Small little tuck inside of this cute little town. Everything is freshly made and bursting with flavor. I got the avocado toast and it did not disappoint! Even my kids said it was the best egg they ever had :-) You must try the brownie!!
Jacklyn R — Google review
Had just about the best sausage egg and cheese breakfast sandwich here I've ever had! The bread was fresh, soft but crispy. The egg perfectly fried and the sausage lightly spiced and amazing quality. Add in friendly service with a smile, and a laid back chill atmosphere, and it makes this place a must visit spot for breakfast and lunch. ❤️
Lucy B — Google review
Wonderful, family owned and run Cafe with unique, locally inspired foods. The Big Salad is my current go to! Probably won't go wrong with any of the food here. Counter ordered with small seating area could mean ordering togo makes more sense.
Aaron B — Google review
Balmy sandwich was delicious!! The kimchi was very flavorful, and the bread was warm and crunchy
Michelle C — Google review
Creekside is what keeps me going every weekend! Delicious, nourishing and gorgeous plates of food made with love and worth every penny spent, repeatedly! A favorite breakfast spot full of flavor to please any foodie and a sweet spot for locals like me. Daily specials are truly special, as well as the usual suspects like the VP, #4 and Breakfast Balmy.
Being E — Google review
Very cute establishment with great food, their pastrami sandwich and breakfast burrito were fantastic. They also have a fun selection of drinks.
Thomas D — Google review
Don’t miss this spot. Amazing breakfast sandwiches, friendly staff. Nice to sit outside and enjoy a quiet morning with some yummy food.
L. O — Google review
4.5
(495)
4.5
(132)
Mentioned on 
affordable
Bowling alley
Atlas Bowl is not your average restaurant or bowling alley. It offers a comfortable and fun atmosphere for friends and family to enjoy. The place features seven old-timey ten-pin lanes, making it a great spot to hang out and have some fun. The full bar serves up a good selection of cocktails, ciders, beers, and international wines, including Finger Lakes wines on tap.
It's such a fun place! So trendy and unique! Feels like you are bowling in NYC or something when you are here. We really enjoyed the atmosphere and bowling itself. The staff was helpful and attentive. You can get food and drink service right at your lane. Reservations are encouraged because it does seem to fill up quickly. And I'd recommend more than just an hour to fit in a few games. It's definitely worth a visit!
Linda L — Google review
As a bar/restaurant it is a great atmosphere and good food and drinks. Would absolutely come back As a bowling alley it seems to be more of an activity to do rather than an actual alley. The lanes seem to have virtually no oil and the machine chewed up my ball pretty bad in only 4 throws. I ended up using the house balls to avoid any further damage to my ball.
Shaun — Google review
Super cute bowling alley! The woman at the front desk was really friendly - even moved us away from the kids to give us a more private feel. Cocktails and food were good! Mac and cheese was creamy and filling. The lanes are vintage from the 1950s I believe she said so they are a little narrow and shorter than the modern lanes.
Shayna D — Google review
I loved this upscale, contemporized take on small-town, bowling alley cuisine. There's nothing too attractive to the outside, but once you've stepped indoors, you are rolled over (haha, bowling pun) by the trendy, vibrant colors and functional modern decor. There's plenty of wait staff and a diverse menu. Beer on tap and a bar to make your own. Tables near the front windows and deeper in where the darkness may be better suited. The renovated 5 lane bowling alley surprisingly didn't create the typical commotion making the place feel like a bowling alley. Food was great! I had an 1/4 lb Altas cheese burger with the freshest slice of tomato and a side of crispy tater tots that were My wife had 2 soft tacos with mole sauce and beans with rice. The kitchen served up only strikes!
Gordon S — Google review
I’ve been going to Atlas for many many many years. I don’t bowl there because I’m a very competitive bowler and it is just not the kind of place you go to if you’re looking to work on your game and just bowl for hours. It is what it is, if you want that sort of thing you’ll need to go to Cortland or Geneva. That being said it had always been a reliable place to get food and drinks. I felt things started to go downhill after COVID, but that’s the way of the world. Again, it is what it is. What I can’t accept is the way things have gone into an absolute tailspin since they switched up their menu a few months ago. WHY?? Not only is everything way more expensive but the quality is atrocious. From a business perspective I can’t even begin to understand how the margins are better on these inflated large plates than they were on tacos and burrito bowls. The new stuff coming out of the kitchen is just bad. I love salt but I was almost transported to another lifetime by the amount of salt going into some of these dishes. Presumably because that’s the only way to get them to taste like anything. Also, why on earth would you get rid of the queso dip when you’re still selling the tots that they used to go with? Again seems like selling an $8 cup of cheese would be highly profitable. The menu is all over the place and completely uninspired. My guess is they don’t have anyone in the kitchen who really knows how to cook so they tried to dumb things down? Personally, I’ve never had problems with the service and these three stars really are for them as I think they do a great job and always have. But I seriously question whoever is making decisions about what’s coming out of the kitchen. We used to go there 1-2x a month but now it’s maybe once every few months. If they want to serve this level of food and charge lower prices, fine it would be totally palatable. But for what they are charging it’s criminal. Still a great place to go for just drinks or if you want to bowl purely for fun.
Spike W — Google review
Cool retro decor restaurant with limited, but very tasty food and beer options. Bowling lanes are also available. Service was fast and friendly, food came out quickly and was good. I got a carnitas bowl and the wife got a salad. Would recommend if you are looking for something different.
Ed B — Google review
Bowling was fun but Angela K is the worst waitress and they automatically add 20% gratuity. We had a party of 3. She didn’t return very frequently, was rude, and had a poor attitude. Would def suggest making them work for their tips.
Lexi G — Google review
Good food and drinks. When we were there they were busy and under staffed so food took awhile for our dinners.
Earl W — Google review
61 W Main St, Trumansburg, NY 14886, USAhttp://atlasbowl.com/(607) 387-3191Tips and more reviews for Atlas Bowl
4.7
(130)
4.7
(6)
Mentioned on 
cheap
Organic restaurant
Trumansburg Main Street Market is a charming destination in the village, offering a variety of culinary experiences. Wide Awake Bakery at the market provides locally-sourced goods, from pasta to pastries, and also offers baking courses for those interested in honing their skills. The market itself boasts an array of dining options, including deli sandwiches and fresh baked pastries, as well as local canned brews.
Great food! Friendly and helpful staff. Comfortable environment. What more do you need? This place is wonderful.
Jeff E — Google review
Stopped here while in the area. He had an enormous burrito, I had a taco salad. Both were huge and tasty. Small place, not a lot of seating. For a small town, there is lots of people watching!
Spunknit — Google review
I like this place. It's a small marketplace with a big heart. It has lots of delicious high quality items for sale, from: fruits n veggies, beer, sandwiches,, bon bons and much more. Service is very friendly. It offers password protected Wi-Fi, and about 4 tables for in-cafe enjoyment. This was the perfect place for a respite on my drive thru upstate NY
Tootsie P — Google review
The Trumansburger sandwich was impossible to eat — not like a sandwich and not manageable even with silverware. It lacked flavor, while the chips on the side were overly salty. The baklava tasted sour.
Diana S — Google review
A small town restaurant in a quaint beautiful town. The food was exceptional and well prepared sandwiches and salads. The food request is taken at the counter after reviewing the chalkboard menu of about a dozen items made to order. The store people were friendly and helpful. Almost all items are locally sourced and organic. Additionally there is ice cream, chocolate, beer, organic drinks and other food items for sale. A few tables inside as well as a few outside. A perfect local cafe.
Dave L — Google review
We had the Lodi sandwich. Wow! It was excellent. My wife is not a foodie but said that she was sad that the last bite was eaten and was contemplating getting a second one to prolong the pleasurable taste experience.
Sandra A — Google review
The food is fresh, healthy and delicious, the staff is friendly, and knowledgeable, the selection of food and drinks is stellar
Montgomery B — Google review
The Kan Moki and Rabbit Run sandwiches were amazing. The house made truffles were fantastic. This market is lovely and has a lot to offer and the owner is awesome. Can’t wait to come back when I’m in town.
George K — Google review
4.6
(288)
4.4
(83)
Mentioned on 
affordable
Pizza restaurant
New York Pizzeria is a casual chain pizzeria known for its brick-oven-fired pies, soups, sandwiches, and pastas. It's considered to have the best brick oven-fired pizza in the county and is a favorite lunch spot for locals. The pizzeria offers a variety of delicious pizzas by the slice during lunchtime and whole pizzas made to order anytime. Located near Taughannock Falls, it's a great stop while visiting the area.
A nice visit in a small town. Right up the road from Taughannock Falls and worth the short trip. Cool sodas and lemonades in the cooler. Extra large cheese (pictured) was $18 today. We ate in and it was a very pleasant experience. Lots of slice options readily available if that's what you're looking for. Thanks for having us.
Marshall — Google review
Just needed a snack! All the pizzas by the slice looked delicious. Quick and convenient. The crust was perfectly thin and crisp, but not overcooked.
Amy R — Google review
Great Pizza spot in the area. The pizza itself was thin-crusted and really good, with nice different ingredient options. Very impressed & pleasantly surprised with the veg pizza slice options they had.
Yash M — Google review
While visiting Garrett's Brewing next door, we ordered pizza from New York Pizzeria. The service was excellent and the pie was DELICIOUS!! Although busy, it was totally worth the wait to taste authentic NYC pizza. Highly recommended!!
SharkMan — Google review
Great pizzeria with fun sodas. Sicilian it maybe NYC style. Crispy and chewy. Great crust. lots of choices by the slice at about 2 PM. Loved it
Mike — Google review
Hands down the best pizza anywhere. This is my third review.lWe get here probably once a year on the average… If we’re lucky twice a year. Live on Long Island, have a house on the Seneca river in Jordan and we make the trip here. Also have my kids hooked on it so whenever my son comes up from Long Island or my daughter comes over from Buffalo, they go out of their way to get the pizza here. I’m eating a slice now in our RV parked out in front of the pizza shop and am in heaven. I don’t know what they do to get their crust this good but it’s the perfect thinness, perfect amount of salt, Hereand the sauce and cheese… perfect!
MARIE P — Google review
If you are in Trumansburg and want pizza, this is the place to go. So delicious, other pizza doesn't really compare! Thin crust with quality sauce and cheese. Amazing selection of pizzas by the slice at lunch time, with only a couple available slice options at dinner time. Whole pizzas made to order anytime. My go-to combos are sausage, peppers and onions, or feta, tomato and onion... although you can never go wrong with just cheese! Eat in, or take it to go. There are benches out front if it's a nice day. And, a stone table and bench at the children's village is just up the block, which is a great option if you have little ones.
Nana M — Google review
They only serve pizza! They do not deliver infortunatley. But it was delicious!
Tylor S — Google review
2 E Main St, Trumansburg, NY 14886, USA(607) 387-3700Tips and more reviews for New York Pizzeria
Best-of categories in Trumansburg

Looking for day-by-day itineraries in Trumansburg?

Get inspired for your trip to Trumansburg with our curated itineraries that are jam-packed with popular attractions everyday! Check them out here: