Things to do in Kelleys Island in May

When is your trip?

Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Looking for a different month?

Overview

May is a good time to visit Kelleys Island. The weather is usually mildly cool and slightly windy, with temperatures ranging from 53—67°F (12—19°C).

Kelleys Island has plenty to offer for visitors of all ages and interests. In this article, we tell you the top things to see and do for your May trip to Kelleys Island. Get inspired by the events, activities, attractions, and experiences unique to May. We’ll let you know where to explore events based on your interests, whether that’s food, culture, art, music, sport or others.

We’ll let you know everything you need to prepare for the weather in Kelleys Island in May. Learn about what to wear and pack for your trip, the average temperatures throughout May, temperature changes from morning to evening and much more.

Visiting Kelleys Island? See our Kelleys Island Trip Planner.
Your itinerary and your map in one view

No more switching between different apps, tabs, and tools to keep track of your travel plans.

Learn more
What users say about the app

Best events and things to do in Kelleys Island in May

Top experiences in May
We couldn't find any experiences in May
Holidays in Kelleys Island in May
May
  • Cinco de Mayo (May 5)
Other notable holidays

Weather in Kelleys Island in May

Temperatures on an average day in Kelleys Island in May

The average temperature in Kelleys Island in May for a typical day ranges from a high of 67°F (19°C) to a low of 53°F (12°C). Some would describe the temperature to be mildly cool. The general area may also feel slightly windy.

For comparison, the hottest month in Kelleys Island, July, has days with highs of 81°F (27°C) and lows of 69°F (21°C). The coldest month, January has days with highs of 32°F (0°C) and lows of 22°F (-6°C). This graph shows how an average day looks like in Kelleys Island in May based on historical data.

Visiting Kelleys Island? See our Kelleys Island Trip Planner.

Historical temperature average in May
67°F
highs
53°F
lows

General weather summary

Mildly cool, slightly windy
Feels like
41%
Chance of rain
0.158 in
Amount
15.1 mph
Wind speed
76%
Humidity
14.5 hrs
Daylight length
6:12 AM
Sunrise
8:42 PM
Sunset
42%
Cloud cover
Sweater
What to wear
What to wear in May
With an average high of 67°F (19°C) and a low of 53°F (12°C), it generally feels mildly cool and slightly windy. There might also be a small chance of rain. With that in mind, most people would dress in something moderately warm like a sweater and remember to bring an umbrella
Create your ultimate travel itinerary

Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.

Learn more

Best attractions for Kelleys Island in May

Besides the array of exciting events and activities Kelleys Island has to offer for travelers in May, we want to remind you of the classic attractions in Kelleys Island that are great to visit at this time of the year as well! You can’t miss these iconic landmarks, local favorites, and places rich with cultural heritage. We hope to give you insights and inspiration into the best things to see and do to make the most of your visit. Here is a list of our top attractions in Kelleys Island for May.
Glacial Grooves
1. Glacial Grooves
4.7
(719)
Nature & Parks
Geologic Formations
Limestone bedrock with fossils & deep grooves caused by glacial activity around 18,000 years ago.
Slide 1 of 8
This was a very well laid out and built park on the island. It was a great stop on our visit and would absolutely recommend it as a point of interest if you were visiting. There was a very nice hiking trail that ran alongside the park near the entrance that we only had the chance to partially explore.
These grooves are ridiculous, they alone make a trip to the island worth it. The walk-way/stairs around the grooves blend in so well with the natural scenery. This is a must see in Ohio and I don’t know how anyone could give this less than five stars.
The grooves were carved by glaciers dragging boulders over the rock. The sign said they were almost 400 feet long, the longest example of glacial grooves that can be visited. There are some informative displays and a path around the grooves. It's a neat reminder of the size of the glaciers that once covered the area and geological time scales as those glaciers were able to slowly carve the grooves into the rock.
I thought it was awesome!! They had very interesting facts located around the area. Learned a lot!! The surrounding landscape was absolutely beautiful!!! Trees everywhere!! ❤️❤️
This is a free historical site that contains the remains of huge boulders of limestone that were carved out by glaciers hundreds of millions of years ago. It is amazing that ice could cut through rock with such force. Nature is powerful beyond the imagination. The state has done a wonderful job in building the walkway and picnic area around this site. There are also fossils embedded in the rock, that are visible with the naked eye, once you know that to look for. They have informative plaques that describe the history and what this site contains. We were thrilled to be there. Thank you.
For fellow nature nerds and others! It's a bit of a trek to get to these grooves, but it is totally worth it. Amazing piece of natural history!
These glacial grooves are pretty amazing. (Being a believer in the creation theory, I don't they this event took place as long ago as they think it did) But they sure are cool to look at a take a few photos of.
Very beautiful area. a full walk around where you get to see all views of the glacier & the quarry that is still there.
Kelleys Island State Park
2. Kelleys Island State Park
4.7
(1235)
State park
Nature & Parks
Accessible via ferry, a preserve offering camp sites, fishing & a boat launch into Lake Erie.
Slide 1 of 8
This is my favorite of the 3 islands. The grooves alone are ridiculous. However, I do think this island has the best nature preserves and a good amount of food options without feeling too touristy.
This is my opinion and should be taken as such. What an awesome place this was to stay at with a camper. Plus, taking it on a ferry was a first. We traveled with a friend and the ferry captain got us both on the same ferry to and from. The views was spectacular, we were on site 94. The lake was incredible. The island was not totally open as we went prior to their season started. But the businesses that were open were pretty great. We hung out at the Sand Bar one day and Kaz made it an awesome time.
The Island itself is great for those that love nature or wine. Not a party island so take your alcoholism elsewhere. The State park is also great if you enjoy true camping with plenty of nature and water access to lake Erie. Trails and a beach highlight the access. The Glacial grooves are definitely worth seeing and makes you feel like you are taken back to a different time seeing all of the layers of rock.
Campground and beach are well kept. Looking forward to newer bathrooms some day. Mgr Chris does a great job with the funds he has. Bring bug spray for occasional flies at the beach. Or just stay in the water.
Pretty nice camping spot. The female bathrooms/ showers were clean, hubby said the men's were not so much. The prices were nice for a water and electric hook up spot. Quiet, and peaceful, kid friendly. If youre looking to use your phone, you won't be able to, at least not with Verizon lol. We only got service near town or at the ranger station at the entrance where they had wifi. To be honest though, I loved being unplugged. You're walking distance from the glacial grooves and the swimming beach. We will definitely be going back sometime.
BEWARE OF BUGS! My family and I rented out the Sherman Cabin 101 in Mid-July. We checked in and went on with our day until it was dinner time. That’s when the current occupants came out, Earwigs. How did I know? One CRAWLED across the microwave as I was heating something up, BARF. Then another one appeared from under our Air frier, I lost my appetite. As the night went on they seemed to multiply, I looked them up and they are nocturnal. There was an infestation. I took my kids and we slept in our Mini-Van, it was hell on Earth. The next day the cleaning staff were very apologetic, offered solutions and cleaning supplies but insisted they were not allowed to spray anything. I went to the office and management was not there, the office was closed for the whole day. Then Thursday I spoke with an office rep and they said they didn’t know when the manager would be back. He took my name and I never heard back. The next day (after looking for him again) the manager said he couldn’t do anything but would come by to check it out, he never did. I got a hotel for two nights (almost 1,000.00 total) with my children because bugs crawling on the bed was enough for them to see. It ruined our vacation. There was no assistance offered from management nor a mention of a money back. They do not care. It’s pretty much “deal with it.” The last day I had a few items left in the cabin and they were actively crawling out of shoes, bags and the Heavy cooler! We came home and they came home with us. It took me over three hours to shake out all of our things because they were still alive. This place should be condemned, this park should be ashamed of themselves. What a waste of money and time off to spend buying our own bug defense. If you are ready to have claws bite you, bugs in your food and sleeping next to you, then this is your vacation spot. The feeling of being there made me want to throw up so the pictures were taken in a hurry. You have been warned.
This state island campground is more than expected! worth the ferry travel, a paradise kept secret. We stumbled upon this island by accident along our travels after Labor Day and we totally fell in love. The water front camping, swimming, boating, kayaking, historic sites, attractions and facilities are superb. Everything you need and more than you expect. We traveled in with our 34’ trailer. The ferry cost was a bit high, around $200 round trip for us, truck and camper….but it was worth it!! The campground is immaculate, quiet during the week especially after Labor Day, the weekend brings a larger crowd. Walking trails, sites, boating and swimming all available from campground. Sandy shallow beach with beautiful view. Ice, firewood and a store conveniently located at campground. The campground is small and sites a bit tight but spaced accordingly and comfortable. Two waterfront cabins and two yurts available for rent as well. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and the island overall. The glacial grooves, limestone crusher, north loop trail, beach and boat launch all withing walking distance. We rented bikes downtown to explore rest of island, including winery, cantina and local bars. Counting the days to go back.
Camp ground was amazing. Lake Front sites are a must!!
Caddy Shack Square
3. Caddy Shack Square
3.5
(42)
Temporarily Closed
Bicycle rental service
Fun & Games
Slide 1 of 8
Food was delicious and delivered quickly. Beer was ice cold and the bartender knowledgeable and personable. Those who chose another restaurant/bar missed the boat!!
OK...Let me start by saying, we totally understand it was island fest, and the island was busy but this place was by far the biggest disappointment of the weekend. We ordered food and waited almost 2 hours for sandwiches! We were told by the TERRIBLY RUDE kitchen staff that we could not cancel our orders because they were in oven. After waiting an additional 30 minutes, we tried to cancel again because we had to get our golf cart back and catch the Ferry. These employee were unbelievably mean and lied to us nonstop! We weren't the only ones having this issue. So many customers were complaining 🙄 Just unreal!
Worried about the putt putt course. Right downtown in the action and such a fun option, but each year the condition gets a little more sad. This summer, no water, broken features, missing features, etc. Set expectations reasonably.
Garbage. Less than 1 star if Google would let me. Make sure that you understand their NO REFUND policy. Bad weather rolled into Kelleys and the ferries stopped running. Needless to say, we had to cut things a day short to get off the island. Caddy Shack couldn’t care less and offered no refund.
Do not rent golf carts from them !!!! They were sold out when we got there, we were put on a waitlist (never received a text from them all day) after hanging around the area for a hour we came back to see how close we were on the waitlist and were told to make a reservation online which we ended up doing. They could have told us the first time they took reservations online. Came back a hour later at our reservation time and were told we didn’t have a reservation. Extremely rude and did nothing to help they basically told us to just go away that our name wasn’t on there, wasted half the day waiting around for a golf cart from them. Walked down the street to a different rental place and luckily they had one cart , very nice people who were very helpful and we got to enjoy the rest of the day. Don’t waste your time/ day waiting around on them !!! Terrible service
Shady wouldn’t rent golf carts from these guys. Rented a 6 seater golf cart which for starters the parking brake didn’t work and then the employee showed us that you have to get out of the cart and then use your hand to push the pedal down really how safe is that and then today in the afternoon basically a week later calls and says the golf cart tires are messed up which didn’t tell me how and now I owe him $200. Not exactly hot rodding a six seat golf with 2 autistic boys and a young child and also when we returned the golf cart it was inspected thoroughly tires,brakes, and etc. and I also told them to not forget that the parking wasn’t working properly and they acknowledged that and one more note it took them roughly an hour to find my paperwork and credit card I’d give these guys a zero if I could
Sell out of everything VERY fast. If you don't make reservations online, don't bother.
The service was easy. The golf cart was in good condition and the Caddy Shack was located close to the Jet Express drop off. All of this made it easy for my mother, whose mobility is not the best, to enjoy her day on Kelleys Island. We explored every nook. The price was fair and comparable to others across the islands.
Inscription Rock
4. Inscription Rock
4.3
(97)
Historical landmark
Sights & Landmarks
Slide 1 of 8
Although a lot of the original inscription has weathered off, you can look at the model and pick out some of the patterns near the edges. Also, we took a walk on the beach by there and found quite a bit of pieces of sea glass
A neat little stop while visiting Kelly's Island. The inscription was carved by indigenous inhabitants long ago. The inscription itself is worn and weathered, so it is hard to make out, but they have depictions of the original carvings that show you the detail. This is an Ohio History Connection site. You can take a rubbing off the marker to fulfill your passport book.
Interesting historical rock with petroglyphs. Unfortunately, the petroglyphs are mostly worn away and illegible.
Interesting piece of history. Sad that the petroglyphs have not been protected and the weather has worn them down to almost nothing. There is a sketch of what the markings looked like when they were first discovered. But it is very hard to make out the images now. The rock is under a roof. But not much else to protect it. You can wander around the rocks and walk along the pebble beach. But that is about it. There is no parking lot, but most people just park along the road. We walked from the nearby shops. Not a must see attraction, but it is only a short walk from the shopping area. So at least worth the short walk.
This was a huge boulder with petroglyphs carved in it by ancient Native Americans, several hundred years ago. Unfortunately, most of the carvings were barely visible due to the weather over time. I was a nice historical site though and I am glad we stopped there.
Love viewing history in my home state
You really can't see the inscriptions any more except for random, lines and grooves. It is neat to be connected to history. Just don't expect perfect inscriptions. It's worth taking a look at if you are at Kelly's Island already.
I was so happy to finally get the visit this historic landmark. However I was disappointed to find that the petroglyphs have been mostly eroded away. Some petroglyphs could be made out faintly. I am so sad that the preservation of this history has not been taken very seriously. Surly it is a fine example of Native American culture slipping away from us. The building around the inscription rock is very exposed to the outside elements. I was grateful to see the plaque had the original petroglyphs drawn out.
Kelleys Island Historical Association
5. Kelleys Island Historical Association
4.7
(132)
Temporarily Closed
Local history museum
Museums
Small museum featuring local history exhibits, plus a shop with books, cards & unique gifts.
Slide 1 of 8
These people love what they do, and it shows. Everyone we met here was full of information about the island and its people. I was looking for information about my mother, who graduated from the school there in 1943., and was thrilled to find her name in one of the school annuals. I was also able to visit her former home. The Historical society put me in touch with a woman who had lived next door to mom as a small child. My visit was successful on many levels. Kelleys Island is a beautiful retreat and we had a wonderful time.
Fantastic local museum highlighting a very interesting history for the island. You are sure to learn something fascinating here! There is a great kids room too with cool videos and some toys and books. Support local history and visit this museum!! Absolutely worth the trip. Thank you for a great visit!
Great place to recharge! The museum was free for our daughter's island birthday celebration so that was nice We were early in the season so it wasn't crowded & got to see some migratory birds also!
Not a big building, but it has some interesting historical information about the island and displays of items that were used on the island and some nice older photos. There's also a small gift shop as well.
Attended a wedding and was very impressed with the well kept and preserved facilities.
Fun place to visit and learn about the island history
This was a nice area. The church has a original house that belongs to the church set up as a little thrift store that supports local people in need. Stop buy I'm sure they will have something you will like plus you can read the history of the church and the house. They are both historical land marks. They have a big sign that tells the history of both. The lady that was running the store was very friendly.
Nice little Museum someone usually pieces
Charles Herndon Gallery and Sculpture Garden
6. Charles Herndon Gallery and Sculpture Garden
4.6
(114)
Art gallery
Sights & Landmarks
Slide 1 of 8
The gallery was amazing! We hopped off our bikes and walked through the grounds enjoying the beautiful artwork all around. Truly fabulous!
Interesting outdoor display of the artist's work. Clearly different phases of the artist's journey - metal, cement, rock. I especially liked the rock pieces - clearly a significant effort to use natural glacial erratics and sculpt them into interesting and beautiful representations. The garden is way out on the back roads of the east edge of the island but a nice addition to our day on Kelley's Island.
When the female form is embraced to this level, you have to wonder about the drive of the artist. Absolute quality, interest, artistry, texture, balance in the art pieces, especially the granite in my opinion. Definitely worth stopping by when visiting the island.
A cute little walk through path with concrete & steel sculptures..Glass blowing on Thursdays.
Sculptures galore at the beautiful Scenic spot on the water. Most of the Arts is done by Charles but there are some other artists on display including some amazing art glass blown on site. I'll be back someday for the chess set.
One of my favorite places on Kelly's island for a nice refreshing stroll through a lifetime of fine artworks, Bring the family over here for an adventure through the strange and unusual mama mind of Charles Herndon And enjoy his garden and take it all in, Don't forget to say Hi to his dog very friendly little critter if I do say so myself
We came upon the garden by pure luck while riding our bikes on a day trip to the island. It was a nice spot to get off and rest a bit. We walked through many of the little trails admiring the sculptures. I'm sure we even probably missed a few, as they were tucked into many different areas of the property. We will certainly make it a point to come back and enjoy the garden again.
The garden was nice but the gallery was not open it's stated hours when we went.
Kelleys Island General Store
7. Kelleys Island General Store
4.6
(304)
Temporarily Closed
Gift shop
Shopping
Slide 1 of 8
Best rates for golf cart and will rent 24 hrs. Staff is very fast service and recommended areas to visit on the Island. The camper ground beach is a great visit.
Was visiting Kelley’s Island, OH for the 2024 Solar Eclipse. Popped into the Kelley’s Island General Store for a few minor items. They got you covered for anything souvenir related. They sell shirts, hats, keychains and magnets. The staff were friendly, courteous and helpful.
Great establishment offering quality garments and one of a kind Kelly’s Island gifts and souvenirs. Very well managed. The golf cart rental never disappoints! Well done gang!
Nice gift shop/ store that sells clothes and souvenirs.
Awesome staff, great clothes, affordable golf cart rentals. The go-to place on Kelleys
Great place with Super friendly staff and great prices on the golf cart rentals.
Awesome carts! Awesome service! Very friendly people. The place to go for carts on the island!!
We love the store for clothes and items we may have forgotten
Scheele Preserve
8. Scheele Preserve
4.8
(63)
Nature preserve
Nature & Parks
Slide 1 of 8
A must see nature preserve for the sole reason the trail ends at a beautiful white sandy beach! The trail is about 1/2 mile and you return on the same path. There are some muddy areas, but volunteers have added stepping stones along the path. There is plenty to see along the path and most of the path is shady. At the end of the path is a very pretty small sandy/rocky beach. You can take a moment to wade into Lake Erie or take a swim. It is nice to walk along the beach and see the stone "artwork" others have done. I was not expecting to see the beach when I set out. There is a bench provided and when we went out it was very secluded!
My favorite place on Kelley's Island! The trail here is about a half mile long and very easy to walk. We took a stroller with our 14 month old and our dog as well. The trail opens to a beautiful and secluded beach. Highly recommend if going to the island. The day we went we were the only ones there! Absolutely loved it!
I finally found a hiking trail that leads to a white sandy beach! No, but really, it's a nice easy hike through a variety of landscapes. A few muddy spots, but people have put down stepping stones. Nice prairie, nice trees, beautiful beach. The lake was calm when I was there.
Definitely the best beach on the island. It's small because of private property but it's empty and pristine. Easy, short walk. There is a bench on the beach, perfect for a snack or a small picnic. This was my dog's favorite beach too.
Scheele Preserve is one of Kelley's Island's must visit sites. It is nearly a half mile trail that leads to a white sand beach. This trail is great for families. The amount of wildlife will surprise you!
Great short hike that ends at a beautiful beach! Definitely pack a snack and go stay a while.
Beautiful natural area. We were with Tom Bartlett when he banded his 100,000th bird here on October 22, 2021. A Northern Saw-whet Owl.
When the trail opened up to the beach it felt like we walked into the Caribbean! My favorite spot so far on Kelleys Island.
The Village Peddler
9. The Village Peddler
4.3
(14)
Clothing store
Shopping
Slide 1 of 7
Had the pleasure of visiting Kelley’s Island, Ohio for the 2024 Solar Eclipse. I was in dire need of a cooler and was unable to locate one due to the small town being limited with resources. The lady working at The Village Peddler was AMAZING! I told her that I was visiting from out of town, and she gave me a cooler. I was thrilled that a total stranger would offer a complete stranger a cooler. It truly made the trip ten thousand times better. The store has many, many items of ladies clothing, and some self care items along with amazing knitted kids toys. Not to mention a garage area with many more vintage items. If you happen to be on Kelleys Island, Ohio please stop by The Village Peddler, you will get the best deals and value for your money.
Clothes are super cute, old surf shop vibes with a lot of options, loved all the patterns and brands available
A nice gift shop on Kelly’s Island.
Lots of good things to purchase, clothing, home goods, and ?!
This lady was so rude to us for no reason. We just asked her to clarify her sign, very kindly, and she greeted us with a terrible attitude. We left immediately without buying anything. There’s so many other shops where the workers are so friendly and helpful. Don’t recommend
Cute store...but WOW whoever was working at the register looked like I was going to murder her or steal the store. Some better customer service for the over priced goods would have been nice. We did find one cute thing that we decided to buy but felt VERY unwanted the whole time we were shopping.
Kelleys Island Chamber of Commerce and Visitor Bureau
10. Kelleys Island Chamber of Commerce and Visitor Bureau
4.6
(14)
Chamber of Commerce
Service establishment
Slide 1 of 6
Stayed at Pine Cottage, it was wonderful. It's new, and spotlessly clean with a full kitchen and high end appliances. It has a fire pit out back and our hostess set out firewood and fire starters each night. 3 bedrooms and it was quite comfortable for 6 adults. Only one bathroom, but that wasn't really a problem. The island has lots to explore and do and many dinning options, though we cooked each night and just ate out for lunch. They include a little charcoal grill that was great for burgers, brats and veggie kabobs. Bring food with you there isn't much of a grocery on the island.
The KI Chamber of Commerce is the go to hub for visitors to the island and vacation rentals.
The summer kids manning the golf cart rental booth were great.
Fantastic chamber for conducting commerce. 5 stars!
The best place to contact for questions about visiting Kelleys Island.
Kelleys Island Adventours
11. Kelleys Island Adventours
5.0
(7)
Tour agency
Tours
Slide 1 of 4
Me and my parents took the sightseeing golf cart tours (we did a combination of the Quarry History and the Island Treasure Nature Tour) with Dawn. She explained the best place to rent the cart (by the ferry is closest but downtown is the cheapest). The cart is separate but its definitely worth it since you can use the cart after the tour! Since it was just us, it was really great since we could see all the things we wanted to (glacial grooves, inscription rock, the state park, the old quarries, some of the beaches). Trekking the island without someone who knows the area, it's hard to appreciate the history and its easy to walk right past things. These pictures were all from the tour. When I come back I'd love to try the kayak tour!
Dawn was an excellent guide. She is very knowledgeable about the wildlife and local birds. She taught us a lot and we had a lot of fun on the kayak tour. The waves were fun, but expect to get a little wet when you launch. Altogether a great time.
This was a very fun experience. Dawn was very knowledgeable and friendly and took her time showing us the island's beauty and explaining its history.
Northridge bus garage end of year trip was awesome. Thanks to Dawn and helper they took us on energetic informational wilderness tour. That we would have never found on our own. Had such a great time for our group. Thank you so much!
Island Mining Co.
12. Island Mining Co.
4.3
(15)
Rock shop
Shopping
Slide 1 of 8
Perfect little place to stop over at and pick up a gift for your loved ones you can find necklaces fossils gems earrings all kinds of really cool stuff
Gem shop on Kelly’s island. It was closed so we could not go in.
Righteous and rocktastical rocks and stones and such to make good gifts for friends that weren't cool enough to come to Kelley's Island with you. Xavier was a super nice and helpful dude to chat with and made our rock shopping experience even more rocking than I might have guessed. Rock on
Almost didn't stop in when I saw the previous reviews, but after finding out it was just due to the store not being open...we decided to try. IT WAS PRETTY COOL! for 12 bucks the kids got to shift for gems from these bags in the shop. We really enjoyed it and definitely worth a stop if you have kids. Ours are 6 & 8.
Great looking jewelries for reasonable prices. Great place to shop for rocks. Very nice staff.
Would have left zero stars. Website says open till 6. Rushed to make it by 5:45 and the teenager running it said they were closed.
Definitely stop in! Had a great time super fun and worth it.
Store was closed when the hours of operation says it supposed to be open.
Sand Trap Tiki Bar
13. Sand Trap Tiki Bar
4.5
(141)
Temporarily Closed
Bar & grill
Nightlife
Slide 1 of 8
#Breezy, #island vibes #kelleysisland - Nice Breezy and cool atmosphere with music in background. #hangout spot #BAR
Prices were reasonable; staff was knowledgeable; completely outdoor bar; overall a fun summer venue. The grilled chicken (with pineapple and teriyaki sauce) was outstanding! This is usually the last place open at night.
This place was awesome everyone got served their tabs correctly. Don’t go to dockers they will try and charge you for drinks you didn’t order. When confronted they will try and charge you more! Then the other bartender that is drunk gets involved that doesn’t know what to do.
I frequented this bar last week for the week of the 4th of July and I absolutely fell in love with it! Great service especially from the best bartender ever Delaney! Amazing atmosphere, incredibly clean. I also really loved the food from the corner grill from i believe his name was Jimbo. Just all around amazing little slice of heaven! Whoever is in charge of this place should be proud because it's the best.
Bartender took our money off the bar for her tip without asking if we were done. Asked the other bartender what the ringing of the bell ment. She said if you have to ask you can't afford it. Very poor customer service.
Hi. I was there over the weekend and got double charged. I've tried to message on Facebook but it wouldn't go through, l also have sent an email with all the details and cannot get in contact with anyone
Sand Trap Tiki Bar is a great outdoor bar on Kelly's Island. The staff and bartenders are attentive and the food from the small walk up grill was good and reasonably priced. Add the Sand Trap to your bar crawl when on the island.
We didn't eat there, but sat at the bar for drinks. Service was attentive. When there is a popular sports game on t.v., it can get crowded. Food is cooked on an outdoor grill.
Scheele Preserve
14. Scheele Preserve
4.8
(63)
Nature preserve
Nature & Parks
Slide 1 of 8
A must see nature preserve for the sole reason the trail ends at a beautiful white sandy beach! The trail is about 1/2 mile and you return on the same path. There are some muddy areas, but volunteers have added stepping stones along the path. There is plenty to see along the path and most of the path is shady. At the end of the path is a very pretty small sandy/rocky beach. You can take a moment to wade into Lake Erie or take a swim. It is nice to walk along the beach and see the stone "artwork" others have done. I was not expecting to see the beach when I set out. There is a bench provided and when we went out it was very secluded!
My favorite place on Kelley's Island! The trail here is about a half mile long and very easy to walk. We took a stroller with our 14 month old and our dog as well. The trail opens to a beautiful and secluded beach. Highly recommend if going to the island. The day we went we were the only ones there! Absolutely loved it!
I finally found a hiking trail that leads to a white sandy beach! No, but really, it's a nice easy hike through a variety of landscapes. A few muddy spots, but people have put down stepping stones. Nice prairie, nice trees, beautiful beach. The lake was calm when I was there.
Definitely the best beach on the island. It's small because of private property but it's empty and pristine. Easy, short walk. There is a bench on the beach, perfect for a snack or a small picnic. This was my dog's favorite beach too.
Scheele Preserve is one of Kelley's Island's must visit sites. It is nearly a half mile trail that leads to a white sand beach. This trail is great for families. The amount of wildlife will surprise you!
Great short hike that ends at a beautiful beach! Definitely pack a snack and go stay a while.
Beautiful natural area. We were with Tom Bartlett when he banded his 100,000th bird here on October 22, 2021. A Northern Saw-whet Owl.
When the trail opened up to the beach it felt like we walked into the Caribbean! My favorite spot so far on Kelleys Island.
Original Island Fudge Shoppe
15. Original Island Fudge Shoppe
4.5
(6)
Temporarily Closed
Candy store
Shopping
Slide 1 of 6
After having different flavors of fudge all across the country, I believe Original Island Fudge Shoppe may be the best in America. I had the peanut butter fudge and my wife had the dark chocolate fudge. Both were very creamy, not too sweet, and none of the waxy / plastic taste you get from commercial places. I highly recommend it.
Not your typical fudge shop filled with other sweets/candies although what they do have (fudge and only fudge) is some of the best I've ever had.
Best Fudge I've ever had super creamy. My favorite is the cookies and cream.
Fudge was excellent especially Tiger Butter. I wish there was a valid phone number available for the Fudge Shoppe or a website available to make a shipment purchase.
We were there after the main season and it was closed. However we met the owner at the convenience store next door and she opened it up just for us! We purchased some as gifts as well as for us. It was delicious.
Closes too early!
Best-of categories in Kelleys Island

Looking for day-by-day itineraries in Kelleys Island?

Get inspired for your trip to Kelleys Island with our curated itineraries that are jam-packed with popular attractions everyday! Check them out here:

Planning a trip to Kelleys Island?
Save all the best places to visit with WanderlogDownload the travel planning app everyone's been raving about
  • Itinerary + map in one view
  • Live collaboration
  • Auto-import hotels and reservations
  • Optimize your route
  • Offline access on mobile
  • Optimize your route
  • See time and distance between all your places
Learn more
Get the iOS app from the App Store
Get the Android app from Google Play
0 places saved to your trip to Kelleys Island