Places to visitOut Islands

Hidden Treasures Restaurant fine dinning with Chef Trevor

4.6
(111)
•
5.0
(80)
4.6
(111)
•
5.0
(80)
cheap
Restaurant
Farmers' market
Souvenir store
Placeholder

About

Hidden Treasures Restaurant is a must-visit dining spot on Cat Island. Chef Trevor's culinary skills are exceptional, and his wife Denise ensures efficient and friendly service. The menu boasts delectable options such as blackened grouper, jerked lobster, jerk pork, and more. The restaurant has relocated to a new building along the road but remains easily accessible. Guests can enjoy freshly prepared dishes like fried grouper, grilled chicken, and burgers served with a smile.
Why you should go
    1
  1. Savor freshly prepared dishes like jerk pork, grilled chicken, grouper, and lobster
    2. 2
  2. Enjoy standout items such as blackened grouper and jerked lobster
    3. 3
  3. Relish in the warm hospitality of Chef Trevor and Denise
Your itinerary and your map in one view

No more switching between different apps, tabs, and tools to keep track of your travel plans.

Learn more
What users say about the app
Love love love! ❤️ Planning travel has actually been fun instead of tedious because of this app.
J
Julie G.
Exactly what I needed to plan a trip. I can’t imagine anyone not loving this app!
J
Jen S.
Wanderlog makes planning a trip so effortless. Seriously, this app does it all!
B
Brad C.
This site and app let me do all the planning for our 15 day trip in a little over 6 hours! I can’t recommend it enough!
A
Amanda W.
Amazing!! The organization this app provides has taken a huge weight off my shoulders.
G
Garrett V.
This is the crème de la crème of planning apps! Don’t think about it - just click download right this minute.
C
Chris C.

Your itinerary and your map in one view

No more switching between different apps, tabs, and tools to keep track of your travel plans.

Menu and popular items

Map
Address
The Bight Settlement, Bahamas
Phone
+1 242-424-9237
Hours
Su
Sunday: Closed
MoMonday: 11AM–8PM
TuTuesday: 11AM–8PM
WeWednesday: 11AM–8PM
ThThursday: 11AM–8PM
FrFriday: 11AM–8PM
SaSaturday: 11AM–10PM
The Bight Settlement, Bahamas
Wednesday: 11AM–8PM
Su
MoTuWeThFrSa
Su
Sunday: Closed
MoMonday: 11AM–8PM
TuTuesday: 11AM–8PM
WeWednesday: 11AM–8PM
ThThursday: 11AM–8PM
FrFriday: 11AM–8PM
SaSaturday: 11AM–10PM
+1 242-424-9237

Highlighted reviews

Slide 1 of 3
On Valentines, we were anchored in the bay off of New Bight and had come ashore to hike the Hermitage. We made our way down the beach to check out options for dinner and found Hidden Treasures. They were kind enough to make space for us and we had an amazing 4 course dinner (Salad, Soup, Entree, Dessert). One of the better meals we've had in the Bahamas and so glad we stumbled in. We'll definitely be back!
This is the best restaurant on Cat Island. Chef Trevor is a wizard in the kitchen and his wife Denise is very efficient and quite friendly. Best grouper and lobster we have had. They offer many different preparations but the blackened grouper and jerked lobster were remarkable. Reasonably priced too. I had the jerked pork and it was unforgettable. Killer slaw and fries. Mango daiquiri is worth dreaming about. We went three times while we were on the island. Don’t miss this place!
We made a reservation and had friends join us. There is an option for indoor seating. I had blackened grouper with coleslaw and sweet potato fries and my husband had the jerk pork with peas and rice and coleslaw. We both enjoyed the flamingo daiquiri very much. The meals were outstanding. We will definitely tell our friends be back.
On Valentines, we were anchored in the bay off of New Bight and had come ashore to hike the Hermitage. We made our way down the beach to check out options for dinner and found Hidden Treasures. They were kind enough to make space for us and we had an amazing 4 course dinner (Salad, Soup, Entree, Dessert). One of the better meals we've had in the Bahamas and so glad we stumbled in. We'll definitely be back!
This is the best restaurant on Cat Island. Chef Trevor is a wizard in the kitchen and his wife Denise is very efficient and quite friendly. Best grouper and lobster we have had. They offer many different preparations but the blackened grouper and jerked lobster were remarkable. Reasonably priced too. I had the jerked pork and it was unforgettable. Killer slaw and fries. Mango daiquiri is worth dreaming about. We went three times while we were on the island. Don’t miss this place!
We made a reservation and had friends join us. There is an option for indoor seating. I had blackened grouper with coleslaw and sweet potato fries and my husband had the jerk pork with peas and rice and coleslaw. We both enjoyed the flamingo daiquiri very much. The meals were outstanding. We will definitely tell our friends be back.
See all reviews

Know before you go

  • Consider calling ahead to arrange for pick-up if you prefer not to walk to the restaurant
  • Try the recommended mango daiquiri for a refreshing drink option
  • Don't miss out on specialties like blackened grouper or jerked lobster
  • Engage in conversation with hosts Trevor and Denise for an unforgettable dining experience

Reviews

Hidden Treasures Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience on Cat Island, with Chef Trevor showcasing his culinary wizardry and wife Denise providing exceptional service. Reviewers praise the freshly prepared dishes like jerk pork, grilled chicken, grouper, and lobster served with a smile. The mango daiquiri is highly recommended, along with standout items such as blackened grouper and jerked lobster. Guests appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and efficient service at their new location along the road. Hidden Treasures is hailed as a must-visit for its flavorful food, reasonable prices, and warm hospitality.
Review score
4.6
out of 5
Wonderful
111 reviews
From Google
Review score
5.0
out of 5
Exceptional
80 reviews
From Tripadvisor
5 stars
87
4 stars
12
3 stars
7
2 stars
2
1 star
3
5/5Jen M
•
Feb 15, 2025 from
Google
On Valentines, we were anchored in the bay off of New Bight and had come ashore to hike the Hermitage. We made our way down the beach to check out options for dinner and found Hidden Treasures. They were kind enough to make space for us and we had an amazing 4 course dinner (Salad, Soup, Entree, Dessert). One of the better meals we've had in the Bahamas and so glad we stumbled in. We'll definitely be back!
5/5Steve S
•
Feb 24, 2024 from
Google
This is the best restaurant on Cat Island. Chef Trevor is a wizard in the kitchen and his wife Denise is very efficient and quite friendly. Best grouper and lobster we have had. They offer many different preparations but the blackened grouper and jerked lobster were remarkable. Reasonably priced too. I had the jerked pork and it was unforgettable. Killer slaw and fries. Mango daiquiri is worth dreaming about. We went three times while we were on the island. Don’t miss this place!
5/5The V
•
Apr 22, 2025 from
Google
We made a reservation and had friends join us. There is an option for indoor seating. I had blackened grouper with coleslaw and sweet potato fries and my husband had the jerk pork with peas and rice and coleslaw. We both enjoyed the flamingo daiquiri very much. The meals were outstanding. We will definitely tell our friends be back.
5/5Cheap T
•
Feb 27, 2024 from
Google
Mango daiquiri was recommended. Excellent choice, must have👌🏼. Everything was great. We had jerk chicken, chicken wrap, mac and cheese (excellent) black beans and rice and cole slaw.
5/5Elizabeth S
•
Jul 6, 2024 from
Google
Some of the best food and service on the island. The view is amazing the people are so nice. Everything is made to order. So sit back enjoy a drink while they make your order.
All Google Maps reviews
All Tripadvisor reviews
Create your ultimate travel itinerary

Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.

Learn more

Create your ultimate travel itinerary

Plan your itinerary, find lodging, and import reservations — all in one app.

Best-of categories in the Out Islands
Restaurants
Family restaurants
Bars
American restaurants

Explore nearby places

All related maps of the Out Islands

the Out Islands throughout the year

Map
Address
The Bight Settlement, Bahamas
Phone
+1 242-424-9237
Hours
Su
Sunday: Closed
MoMonday: 11AM–8PM
TuTuesday: 11AM–8PM
WeWednesday: 11AM–8PM
ThThursday: 11AM–8PM
FrFriday: 11AM–8PM
SaSaturday: 11AM–10PM
The Bight Settlement, Bahamas
Wednesday: 11AM–8PM
Su
MoTuWeThFrSa
Su
Sunday: Closed
MoMonday: 11AM–8PM
TuTuesday: 11AM–8PM
WeWednesday: 11AM–8PM
ThThursday: 11AM–8PM
FrFriday: 11AM–8PM
SaSaturday: 11AM–10PM
+1 242-424-9237
Planning a trip to the Out Islands?
Save all the best places to visit with WanderlogDownload the travel planning app everyone's been raving about
  • Itinerary + map in one view
  • Live collaboration
  • Auto-import hotels and reservations
  • Optimize your route
  • Offline access on mobile
  • Optimize your route
  • See time and distance between all your places
Learn more
Get the iOS app from the App Store
Get the Android app from Google Play
0 places saved to your trip to the Out Islands