The 50 best desserts and snacks in Florida Keys

We loved this place it was such a great time. So eclectic and cool. The key lime pie was delicious. My husband had the mahi sandwich which was juicy and flaky. I ate the shrimp and grits as well which was tasty. We went as a group and everyone of us enjoyed the food. The service was amazing. It was fun to have the chickens hanging outside while we ate. Super cute gift shop I bought a tile with chickens on it. They also let you bring your catch of the day and cook it for you which is really neat

Really neat and eclectic place to eat! The food was delicious, and albeit very expensive, you could tell they emphasized food quality and prioritized organic, local, and farm to table produce and food. Their key lime pie was also very delicious. There are free range chickens roaming around and live music playing. It’s loud, but definitely a really cool experience. I don’t think I’ve eaten at a place quite like it. It feels like a haven inside key west.

If you’re in Key West, Blue Heaven absolutely lives up to its name — it’s a little slice of paradise on a plate! We went for Sunday lunch while on vacation, and even though the place was super busy (we waited about 1 hour and 20 minutes), it was totally worth the wait. The vibe is pure Key West — open-air, al fresco dining, colorful decor, chickens wandering around, and live music adding to the laid-back island feel. I ordered the Surf and Turf Benedict, which features Filet Mignon and Lobster — and wow, it was phenomenally good. Perfectly cooked, rich, and absolutely unique. My friends’ dishes were just as amazing: the BLT Benedict (where the “L” stands for Lobster) and a Shrimp Omelette that was loaded and flavorful. Of course, we couldn’t leave without trying their famous Key Lime Pie, and it did not disappoint. Tangy, creamy, and just the right amount of sweet — easily one of the best I’ve ever had. Whether you’re a foodie or just want the quintessential Key West experience, Blue Heaven is a must-visit. I’d recommend it to anyone heading to the island — just go early, be patient, and enjoy the tropical atmosphere while you wait.

As always a fun and amazing place! Breakfast was amazing on a Saturday! My crew and I got there nice and early just a little after open and walked right in. Certainly filled shortly after. Still all good because they open the bar across the street to get your vitamin c on. Most of us got the Lobster grits and BLT Benedicts which were delicious! Service was amazing!

Low key but relaxing and cool outdoors setting. Great spot for breakfast and brunch probably for dinner too. Come early before 10am to escape the long wait line. The line gets so long they have a waiting area across the street, the size of a restaurant. The food does not disappoint but doesn’t wow either. The roosters trying to catch a chicken and flying over our table were a bit much for me, but people seemed to enjoy it.

Perfect Brunch Spot!! my friends, and I came here before our snorkeling adventure, we had to wait about 30 minutes before being seated, but it was so worth it! Our server was very nice and told us about all of the specials! The lobster omelette was a big hit at our table as well as the lobster Benedict! The lobster was so fresh and yummy!! let’s not forget the FAMOUS KEY LIME PIE! WOW!! 100/10! I’m usually not a Keylime pie person but the one at Blue Heaven definitely changed my mind!! I highly recommend coming here and checking it out! I can’t wait to bring my family here next time we come to visit!

This place is so cool!!! Live music and a lot of roosters to make you company for breakfast. 😅 We waited in line for 15/20 minutes but Service was so fast! We ordered some blueberry pancakes, egg Benedict’s with lobster was from another world! It was soooo delicious!!! Definitely recommend!! Key lime pie was really creamy and the merengue was good. A place that we you come back, for sure, next time we go to Key west.

What a cute place!! Service was great! Staff super friendly and kind. Atmosphere felt like a place that I already know and loved. The pastries were sooo good!

OMG!!! I’ve been here 13 years and I’ve never gone here… I have been missing out! I’m on a mission to try new things and decided to pop in on this cute little place. I ended up ordering an Italian sandwich. Let me tell you it was divine. If you’re ever in town go there I ordered dessert ( the OMG Brownie) as well and it was awesome. I think I found a new favorite spot.

This bakery had (in my opinion) the best Key Lime pie on the island. I tried enough during our vacation to know! I also bought their peach cobbler Danish. OMG! Absolute heaven. Highly recommend stopping by and checking out their goodies.

Nice local grab and go place. Danishes are delicious, curry chicken sandwich was a little dry but great flavor. Which they would matchstick cut the apples to be easier to eat. Breakfast burrito best protein option, but felt like a lot of tortilla to filling ratio. Good coffee too. Only a bench outside, so recommend taking it Togo. Would return and try the 🥐, guava pastry was super flake, wish it was bigger and had cream cheese.

Freshly made bakery items with huge breakfast sandwiches and strong coffee. The staff/ owners were lovely. I knocked over a drink, they were so sweet to clean it up, and offered to replace it. The key lime pie was a little more tart than others, as I was on a mission to try as many version of local pies as possible. We enjoyed our visit. Try walking to the shop if possible since parking is a struggle, but is worth the challenge.

Best spot for great baked goods and sandwiches! Tucked away in old town this spot came highly recommended and we totally were not letdown. A cute bakery that offers takeaway only. Sticky bun was my fave! Lightness of a croissant with the gooeyness of sticky bun! Perfect match! Very reasonably priced too! We liked it so much we went back twice! Had the Italian sandwich based on a recommendation of a local patron and it didn't disappoint! Make sure you go early as they close at 3 pm and their stuff sells out! Tip: walk down towards the water to the ferry terminal and you can grab a seat in the shade on the second floor and enjoy your treats/lunch while watching the boats in the marina!

As soon as the door opened the heavenly smell of freshly baked bread assaulted my senses! Fantastic case of bakery goodies and great sandwiches to go using their baked bread. Coffee was good as well. Value is definitely 👍. The rooster and hen we fed was an unexpected pleasure😊

Our first stop in Key Largo did not disappoint! This was the ‘small’ location so not a tons of room, but the atmosphere and Knick knacks were still awesome - they used to do license plate collecting but have now moved to a signed dollar bill. The fish was also great and of course the pie! We had their infamous key lime pie - highly recommend. Our server was absolutely amazing as well! Highly recommend.

I love this little place, and I stop here as often as I can when I'm driving through the Keys. They have the world's best Key Lime pie 🥧🍋‍🟩!!! I also love getting the alligator bites. They even had my name on the Wall!!

Now that's a breakfast. Very fresh and awesome. The farmer's omelette was perfect. Our server Nona made us feel right at home. Thank you.

Amazing service and breakfast food. We were pleasantly surprised by a greeting at the door by a hostess, got some great food, including crab cake eggs Benedict's and the best key lime pie we had in Key Largo.

Walked here in a few minutes from Holliday Inn. Cool funky decor. Wait staff so smiling and friendly. Texas Benedict is very nice but the chocolate malt is amazing!! The coffee is strong and tasty. I highly recommend a black coffee and a chocolate malt (my favorite) after a dive. Great place for our family of 6 to eat.

Maybe the best onion rings I’ve eaten. Loved being greeted at the door when we walked in. Food was delicious and atmosphere really fun. Texas Benedict was fantastic

We went for a late breakfast and it was the perfect diner breakfast. We had the pita breakfast sandwich and eggs with sausage and toast. Then we had the key lime pie. Loved it! It has a creamy texture and is served almost frozen which is the perfect treat for the FL keys heat. Do yourself a favor and stop in for a bite and the pie!

Great place! Homemade Bakery items delicious!! Full breakfast menu available. Great server. Cute Little mom and pop type place. Small inside so it must get busy during season and on weekends.

Food was good, had the egg and cheese croissant and hubby had the B.B.S, which he really enjoyed. We also had the french toast filled with cream cheese and strawberries, which I loved. Service was quick and friendly. The only comment would be the prices vs portion sizes...as the portions were a bit small compared to other similar places. Overall it was a good experience.

Great little place for breakfast. Had about a 20 min wait when we showed up at 10am.. Lala is awesome, Taylor is adorable but ur not getting our key lime cookies!! Ha! I got the blue crab Benedict and flavor was spot on.. I don't know how the cook managed to hard poach one egg and the other was perfect but it still was good! She got the chicken sand w fries.. good sandwich and the fries were crispy on the outside and almost like mashed potatoe consistency on the inside.. next time we are in the keys, we will be back for sure!! Also thanks Lala for the fishing advice!! We bought 2 bags of key lime cookies otw out so that's why the price was high per person so dont factor that in when you decide to come here..

Amazing baked goods and food!!! Small place inside, so I bet they get quite busy and have a wait for tables. We stopped by around noon on a Friday and were the only customers at that time. Sadly the bakery case was mostly sold out, but understandable. Crab cake Benedict was delicious and wow... The cinnamon bun was so good. I will definitely be back!!

Giant cinnamon Bunz & huge sticky Bunz with Pecans!! Mini cinnamon bunz & key lime cookies! A chocolate & vanilla swirled cinnamon bun too!! They were busy and we had 3 kid's, so I forgot to grab the key lime cookies. I really wanted to try too, I'm so sad, I waited a long time to visit this area and I forgot the key lime cookies!! They were in top if my must do things! Oh goodness what a shame! Hahaha I wish I could have them shipped to me because I really wanted to try them! Also the service was great!! Thanks Bob's Bunz!!!

Delicious home made treats, just like Mom's. We had a Cinnamon Twist, a Cinnabon and a chocolate chip cookie. All were really, really tasty. It was the perfect place to stop on our way back from Key West. Will make it a regular stop from now on!

Great spot for breakfast, buns are very good probably the best I’ve had in a while , prices are fair , has that vintage look and homie feel to it. I will definitely stop by again on my next visit to the keys. Great staff.

Definitely on the pricey side for donuts but that comes with the benefit of being high quality. They're not overwhelmingly sweet. Outside almost has a light crust making for a great bite into the soft interior. Pictured is the key lime & Boston creme, filled with plenty of filling! This order cost me $10.30

The donuts, coffee and staff were great! This place has so much potential — if the ambiance matched the food, it could easily be packed with people who would stay longer and order more. Unfortunately, the smell of cleaning products was so strong that it almost smelled dirty, making it hard to stay and eat. There were also lots of extra donut boxes lining the walls, which made the space feel more like a storage unit than a donut shop.

4 stars just because of price... I realize everything in the Keys is expensive, but almost $5 a donut was a little steep for me, even as a guy who's favorite sweet is donuts. We were on vacation so we had to sample a half dozen, and the flavors, taste and size were 5 star. The key lime was delicious and I loved the seasonal pumpkin spice. As well as a bakery it's also a very cute coffee shop with a decent amount of inside seating. It's just a block between Truman's Annex and Duval street, so a great location for anyone staying at that end of the island. As the only shop I could find doing traditional donuts, and given how tasty they were, I'd justify the price again if I ever make it back to the keys.

Yes! I really appreciate great donuts. These were exceptional. Had the jelly of the week (guava) and a buttermilk glazed. I want to try them all!! In an atmosphere where heat and humidity are constantly changing, I appreciate the craft of working with dough to bring some happiness to people each day. These guys are brilliant. 100% would go back.

Super friendly fun place to go. Nothing like a great donut to start the day. Excellent flavors and wonderful smells highlights the adventure here. I love a perfect glazed donut not to sweet but fresh. They hit the nail on the head!!

Great donuts!! Get there early if there’s a specific kind you want because they do sell out. We tried the glazed and Cuban coffee and loved both! Freshly baked every day! Definitely worth checking out.

Glazed Donuts is a delightful spot in Key West with a creative, welcoming atmosphere and consistently high-quality selections. The space features fun robot-themed wall art, a U.S. map of donut shops, and an informative board describing their coffee roasting process and menu... small details that really add to the experience. One of my favorite features is the front window where you can watch the kitchen in action. It’s clear a lot of care goes into every batch. I always pick up a lemon poppy seed roll while also trying something new. The coffee is also good, with a self-serve area for customization. There’s seating inside, including a few children’s books along the wall, making it comfortable for a quick breakfast or a relaxed start to the day. The bathroom is clean, and the shop itself is well-maintained. I usually visit early, and by the time I leave, there’s often a line forming out the door, and indication of how good the donuts are. The staff are friendly and provide excellent service. A great stop for locals and visitors alike.

We ordered a key lime pie so everyone in our group could try it. The cashiers we're very nice to give us small plates, napkins, and forks. We sat in the store and ate our pie in a cool environment. Key Lime pie isn't for everyone. Its tart and rich and the "lime" comes through. Many of us enjoyed a slice and others tried a bite and that's all they could do. To each his own. This small bakery also has a small attached gift shop with many great options.

Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West is a great stop for anyone wanting to try the city’s signature dessert. The pies are creamy, tangy, and have that perfect balance of sweetness with the tart lime flavor. They also offer other treats and products to take home, making it a nice spot for both tasting and shopping. The atmosphere is casual, and the staff is friendly, which adds to the experience. Definitely worth a visit if you’re exploring Key West and want to enjoy an authentic slice of key lime pie.

I had high expectations for this iconic Key West spot, especially for my first Key Lime Pie experience. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to the hype. The Key Lime Pie was nothing special—I was expecting something fresher and more vibrant. The Coconut Cream Pie was even more disappointing. It was mostly whipped cream, with only a sprinkle of coconut on top. Honestly, I could’ve found a similar slice at a grocery store for half the price. Overall, the food just didn’t deliver. I was hoping for something memorable, but it fell short.

Is this the original? There's some debate. But! It is fantastic. I loved their coconut key lime pie. I will be craving it for years to come. The shop offers all kinds of key lime treats if pie isn’t your thing. I wish there was more seating, but hey, that's a really small complaint.

Key Lime pie...ehh ok...Mattheessen's blows this place apart... Coffee at 9am had to be made..none "ready"...not tasty... Over $7...bad.. Some cute trinkets..marked $5.95 charged $6.19 plus tax for a magnet... Def tourist trap...no thanks..🐓 Cute building, woman was nice.

A must try Keys Lime Pie!!! 🥧 This version is delicious. The best I've tried so far. A balanced amount of sugar and the pleasant sour lime taste. Staff is nice and prices are average. The bakery sells many unthinkable products with Key Lime Pie flavor. 🤔 For the joy of tourists!!! Two tables and a couple of benches are the only options for those who want to enjoy tasting the pie seated on the spot hoping these aren't already busy. 🔝

If you love all things key lime, this is your spot! Their pie was very good, and they had all sorts of other treats and goodies to take home. Great little stop.

Stopped by for some key lime pie and a cookie. Lots of sweets to choose from! The staff was friendly and there was line inside to wait a few minutes before I could get my sweet fix. Well worth the wait!

We went to 3 ice cream shops in Key West and we can say this is the best!!! Cookie selection was great too and the size of each cookie was huge! ❤️ wish we knew this place sooner ❤️amazing staff too! Drop by and support them!

Mattheessen’s has their own spin on Key West key lime pie, with a fairly thick hand made graham cracker crust, and whipped cream by request. I like a thicker crust, so I enjoyed the flavor fusion of crunch with the creamy smooth tart lime flavor. This place is made for tourists, much like Kermit’s, though has more general dessert options including giant cookies, fudge, and ice cream. Sure to find something sweet for everyone’s taste in the family!

We were walking along Duvall and my daughters noticed these cookies in the window. Wound up getting the chocolate chip macadamia nut. Soooo good!! They gave me a small piece and I wound up eating half of it. LOL! Highly recommended stop!

Key lime pie was good, but ice cream is even better, according to my son, and he loves ice cream. He said it was the best ice cream he had ever eaten. I dont do ice cream, so I dont know. Whether you try pie or ice cream, you won't be disappointed.

This place is amazing. Got a cookie myself and two other people in my group got a key lime pie on a stick and key lime ice cream. Overall really positive. The cookie was great and really flavorful (Peanut butter and chocolate fudge). I was told that the both key lime pie items were pretty good. Overall a really cool place. Definitely worth it. Only reasons it isn’t 5 stars is because it was pretty pricy and there was a lot of sugar in the cookie. Kinda like a crumble cookie but fresher, better flavors, and felt like a little less sugary and buttery.

Ordered fudge cookie, priced higher than the other cookies, as well as a chocolate chip cookie. As my husband put it, this was beyond the best chocolate chip cookie and worth so much more than those fancy boutique cookies in our local town. So soft in the middle, and it took us three days to finish just one cookie. Will come here when I am craving another cookie in KW.

Such a charming little shop! I finally got to try the famous Key Lime Pie here after doing a lot of research, it was my very first time having one in Key West. The pie was incredibly fresh, soft, and so delicious that it practically melted in my mouth. I loved it so much that I finished the whole thing in just four minutes!

Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop on Elizabeth Street is a fantastic stop in Key West. The key lime pie is delicious and refreshing, and they also have unique treats like lemon cookies that are worth trying. What makes it even better is the variety of samples available so you can taste before you buy. They even had a little snack for our dog, which was such a nice touch. A fun and welcoming spot to enjoy local flavors.

I know this place is always one of the top rated Key Lime pies in Key West. It ended up being my second favorite (tried 5 during the week). The pie was thicker (less creamy) than the others, but had a really nice lime flavor. I thought the piece was small, and while the shop had a lot of different key lime snacks and souvenirs, it felt a little over commercialized with just grabbing a pre-cut piece from a refrigerated case and checking out at a counter. It wasn't busy when we were there, but you could imagine days with large lines waiting to grab their piece of pie and go find a seat in the dining area. As I mentioned, the shop was cute, and there was a large indoor/outdoor seating area for when it's busy.

I stopped by Kermit’s Key Lime Shop and I have to say, everything about it was amazing. The key lime pie cheesecake was incredibly tasty, rich, creamy, and full of that perfect tangy sweet key lime flavor. Honestly, it was one of the best desserts I have ever had. I also tried the classic key lime pie, and it was just as good, smooth, refreshing, and not overly sweet. You can tell they really know what they are doing. The shop itself is cute and full of charm, and the people working there were very kind and welcoming. Everyone had a smile and made you feel at home. It is one of those places that feels local and authentic, not touristy at all. If you are in Key West, Kermit’s is a must visit whether you are a dessert lover or just curious about why key lime pie is such a big deal. You will walk away happy, maybe even with a few extra slices to take home.

This place is charmingly decorated and welcoming with yummy Key Lime delights inside. I never leave the Keys without a frozen Kermit’s Key Lime Pie for home and send these to clients around the country. Bring your own cooler or you’ll have to pay for a frozen bag. Tried their Key Lime Taffy samples for the first time and ended up buying two bags because they were so yummy. Took one star off because only after, did I read that they’re made with corn syrup and palm oil and I avoid those ingredients for obvious reasons.

This was definitely one of the best key lime pie I've tried out of all the keys, but I will say, it's better in the store than buying a whole pie and taking it home. The crust gets almost soggy when its frozen. The prices for everything were pretty reasonable, expect for the pie. Way overpriced, especially for soggy crust. Just need some work on how to keep the crust and it would be worth it because the filling is delicious.

Amazing and delicious key lime pies! I was staying at simonton court inn & this was just a short 2 minute walk around the corner which was fantastic! The staff was friendly and the atmosphere and aesthetic of the shop was absolutely perfect and there are so many treats and souvenirs you can grab to remember your trip by, bring back to your family & to enjoy back at your hotel. I highly recommend the coconut cream pie, my boyfriend who is not a fan of citrus, even said it was yummy and refreshing! We also got a limeade for our walk back which was also refreshing, and we grabbed a few items to bring back as souvenirs! This was a great last stop on our trip before we left and I'm so glad we went. Can't stop thinking about the delicious coconut key lime pie!!

Always thought Kermit’s had the best key lime pie, this blows it out the water. Not too sweet and not too “limey”. The perfect key lime pie, 10/10.

Medium sized, older, but nice corner store selling various foods and drinks. The employee working was very nice and helpful with my questions. We tried the Key Lime pie which was very good, refreshing and very sour, tart and nicely sweetened. I don't have much experience with Key Lime pie, but theirs was very good. I highly recommend buying some to take home. They have a full sized pies, smaller pies and individual slices. They also have Key Lime from the Key Lime Lady. Be aware this is a store not a restaurant, but take your pie to go!

First caught sight of this on Google Maps as 'Key Lime Pie Lady,' but it's actually a product that is sold at this trading post. There is also a coffee shop, burrito shop, boutiques in the same lot. They looked really good too, but I was too stuffed to get anything else. I just had some beers and tacos at Jaliscos Tacos 2 at the Florida Keys Brewing Company about a 10 minute walk across the street. Super worth it by the way! Great brewery and food truck!! So, I needed something sweet and saw this on the Googs. I really wanted a Chocolate Key Lime Pie Slice, but they were unfortunately out! So, I got the Chocolate Key Lime Bar instead. Still refreshing and had the crust mixed in so I was happy with that. Aside from my sweet tooth, this is a pretty well stocked post with ready-to-eat meals and necisities as well.

Stopped by for the chocolate dipped key lime pie slices and ended up meeting a local conch who shared some family stories from the 1935 hurricane. Their Key lime pies are delicious and happy to support a local grocery store too!

A little shop selling groceries and the key lime pie, which is one of the best tasting pies I've so far tried! Not overly sweet, tangy and limey. Delicious.

This key lime pie is unbelievable!!! I can’t even put words together to describe it. I’m not exaggerating. You need to try this!!! (We bought it from the trading post and ate it in the car) We called her, and she happily told us her story. She makes the pies from scratch and it shows.

Yummy Key Lime pie! It’s frozen, so it’s perfect to grab on your way out of The Keys.

The food was mediocre I thought. The lobster nor the steak had much flavor. My wife said her fish tacos were really good. The staff was friendly. It was outside dining and the flies were bad. The view was amazing. We all thought it would be a great place to go back and have drinks with friends. Not a dinner destination that we would return to.

Did dinner here on vacation. Our 2nd time dining here and highly recommend. They had a lobster special where it was fried and accompanied by a mango salsa. Yum. Macaroni and cheese was a bit plain but delicious (you can add pulled pork, lobster, shrimp or bacon and jalapeño for an upcharge.

We checked out this place recently and we enjoyed it. Our waitress was Amy and she was very nice and efficient. I got the burger/fries ($20.45) and my wife got the fish tacos ($18.95). My burger was wonderful and so were the fries. My wife said that fish tacos lacked flavor. The view was nice and parking was easy.

View at sunset is magical 😍 Now about the food! Disappointing lobster. Waitress had difficulties with separating the bill. Also waitress added 20% tip for party of 8. That was fine but she was disappointed that we didn't tip more. She actually came out and asked what she did wrong. Not good. So watch your bill for sure.

Great little place tucked away, right on the water in Islemorada. Not quite in the hidden gem genre, but most certainly an off the beaten path stop if you're on your way to Key West. Right on the water, all tables offer a great view. Service is friendly and courteous. Food and drinks are all excellent. Definitely a recommended stop.

Food was fantastic! My husband had the blackened snapper and I had the coconut shrimp. The service was great and the view was even better! Definitely a dining highlight to our trip

The perfect “Keys” vibe. Beautiful waterfront setting for sunset views. Bar feels like something from a Jimmy Buffet song. Bartender was amazing: friendly, moving a hundred miles an hour and fun to watch. And it wasn’t even busy. Conch fritters were perfectly done and our fish was also fresh and nicely prepared. This isn’t fine dining, but delicious and such a fun setting. My girlfriend (in her 50’s) grew up coming here and it was so great to see nothing has really changed since she was a kid. Places like this are what make the Keys so special and unique. May they be here another 50 years!

It was a great experience. Desserts were delicious. My only recommendation is the following : we wanted to try a few things, but we didn't realize how rich and large the desserts were. I wished the waitress would have been upfront with us about the size desserts and the give us a little heads up about the amount we ordered. Otherwise no complaints at all. Very fun. The missionary dessert was amazing!!!

A tasteful, exciting and sensuous experience. I was so glad my friend recommended this. The drinks are unique and delicious. I just wish I had more room in my stomach for the desserts or if there was a variety of sampler plates one could have I wanted to try so many more things, but The ample portions of what I did choose tapped me out

So amazing!! The staff was so friendly and helpful with choices. The drink where amazing. The dessert were so good. Cheesecake was creamy. Carrot cake with so good. And the chocolate cake to die for. My husband is not a dessert guy but the caramel on rim he couldn't stop talking about. I highly recommend.

Everything was wonderful from the delicious desserts to our amazing drinks with coated rims or as they will call it “a rim job” but my girlfriend and I had a great time. Great art on the wall! Atmosphere was not my personal style however it was matching the vibe. It just made the restaurant look closed at first because the windows are all blacked out on the exterior. Delicious desserts tho, well worth the price and trip. (Dessert was our dinner that night it was so good)

Love this place! I make it a point to come every trip! The desserts and the drinks are amazing! Make sure to have a reservation. Sometimes it can be very busy.

Come for the Cake, Stay for the Innuendos This place had me blushing before the dessert even hit the table. The menu alone is worth the visit, a cheeky parade of cleverly named creations that’ll make you giggle, raise your eyebrows, and maybe double-check you’re not reading it out loud in front of kids. The desserts are bold, indulgent, and generously portioned, like your favorite guilty pleasure. Whether you're a chocolate fanatic, a caramel dreamer, or just in the mood for something creamy and unapologetic, there's a little something for every taste bud. Now, full honesty: the drinks weren’t my favorite part, especially the wine pairings with chocolate and caramel. It felt a bit like a blind date between two people who just weren’t vibing. But hey, dessert is the main event here and it delivers. The staff? Flirty, funny, and clearly in on the joke, just the right mix of sass and sweetness. The name? Well deserved. Would I go again? 100%. Perfect for when you want to laugh, indulge, and celebrate your sweet tooth (with zero shame).

Everything was fantastic. The food, the service. The presentation of the desserts was incredible. The creativity behind the verbiage and how it translates to the final product was quite clever.

Great location! Came in for the first time with the family and we absolutely loved it. To drink I had a mango margarita which was very yummy. The lobster fritters were ok, but not much lobster found in them. The boys loved their meal. Cheese personal pizza and chicken tender with fries. I usually don’t finish my meals , but the snapper was so tender and flavorful that it was gone in a second. My meal came with a fried corn in a cob which was also really tasty. The full reach of ribs was also good and huge! Service and vibes were great from beginning to end.

Really good food and great service! The space was beautiful, would try and get a water view next time. Parking was a little difficult but not bad. Love that the Mac and cheese was not an up charged side. The passion fruit habanero margarita was super good. Will be back if we head back to Marathon!

We had breakfast. Eggs Benedict, biscuits and sausage gravy, key lime French toast. Everything was good. Eggs in the Benedict were over cooked and the hollandaise was skimpy (but good). The grits were fabulous. The key lime French toast was quite good, but very sweet. The biscuits were fluffy and the gravy was generous and had good sage flavor.

We stopped on the way to the keys, looking for a drink and fun atmosphere. And you nailed it. Fun decor, good drinks and we had some gator bites! Sat under cover but open windows over looking the water. Great, fun spot! I recommend checking it out.

5.0 restarant for sure! Great Keys vibe but with excellent food (not just vibe). Our waiter, Kerr, was engaging, informed about food options, made great suggestions & perfected our first visit skillfully. Loved the salt and scrub in the ladies room. Buying it in the way out. Nice touch!

Absolutely a Florida Keys favorite experience for me. The Keys vibe here checks all the boxes. Drinks are well made with alcohol, food is an experience with the deep fried Key Lime pie being an addiction! We drive from wherever we are to get this succulent dessert! All of the entrees are good portions and the entertainment is Carribean and Midland motivation.

My husband and I came here to marathon on our honeymoon, we came to porkys twice while staying had to come for dinner & breakfast! Vibes were great, service was great and food was amazing! We will come back on our yearly anniversary trip no doubt!

What a fun cafe! We enjoyed breakfast with biscuit and gravy with scrambled eggs added. The biscuits and gravy were delicious and everything you expect them to be! In addition to that we got the French toast special which has a strawberry sauce. While I loved the French toast, I was not a fan of the sauce. I will try the eggs Benedict next time.

What a hidden gem! This rustic, slightly divey spot has so much charm and character. The food portions are huge and absolutely delicious — every bite felt homemade with love. And the key lime pie? Hands down the best I have ever tasted — creamy, tangy, and unforgettable. Definitely a must-visit!

Our first stop in Key West was Pepe's Cafe. We had chosen our destination well in advance... and we weren't disappointed. The service was very friendly and professional. We were served delicious coffee and a great American-style breakfast. The place itself has a unique atmosphere and a strong sense of time, as evidenced by the photos of its guests hanging around it... including Ernest Hemingway. It's worth a visit for a coffee and a trip back in time.

This is an iconic place as this is the oldest restaurant in key west. However, it is not for me. The sandwiches werent as tasty and I even ordered the special of the day. I think what affected my rating too is because I had set a very high expectation on this place.

If you look at this place from a certain angle, while trying to avoid the Gulf Coast sun from blinding you, it almost looks like it is closed. It wasn't until we got really close to it that we realized that it was fully functional. As we got closer, a friendly voice welcomed us in and directed us to the bar. Once we got there, Katie Mae simply knocked our socks off with her sense of humor, conversation, and knowledge of the island. Of course we ordered the $1.75 oysters and my friend ordered what's considered the best Mojito in town. My beers were cold and frequent. We truly enjoyed our two visits to Pepe's during our Key West adventure.

Out of the 6 dinners we had in KW, Pepes was our clear favorite. Unpretentious, friendly, quick, fresh and fish so tasty we're still talking about it. We sat at one of the hightops in the bar area. Luke ran the section and we followed all of his great recommendations; pepes style snapper and blackened snapper with a slab of keylime pie that was supposed to be eaten in the morning. The pie didnt survive the short walk back to the hotel. Its with good reason this place has been around longer than any restaurant in Key West. EAT HERE!

The key lime pie here was my husbands favorite in Key West. The rest of the food was pretty good. Convenient location after a dolphin and snorkeling trip.

Cool atmosphere with a lot of character and Cuban vibes. The outdoor seating area is spacious and has a nice setup. The food was okay — not the best I’ve had, but decent. The fried whole fish looked impressive, but the flavor was average. Dessert was also just okay. The biggest issue was the service — it took a long time to get our food, which was frustrating. Overall, worth checking out for the ambiance, but be prepared to wait.

What a fun place!! Great place to enjoy live Cuban music and enjoy the vibe while watching the sunset and eating great apetizers! The Scallops are a must as they are seasoned well with a butter sauce. Planting chips are good and add to the atmosphere. The Shrimp were on a another level and some of the best we had in Key west! Go for the atmosphere and enjoy the food while listening to some great Latin music

Get the #80. You wont be disappointed! My husband and I always share this one when in town. Delicious variety and love the atmosphere! The location is perfect to end your evening with the Mallery square sunset! Beautiful!

At first I was skeptical because of the previous ratings BUT we ordered the # 69 and the relleno appetizer with our mojitos and let me tell you it was delicious. The pork was tender and marinated just right. The mojitos were strong and minty. The server was super friendly and helpful! The ambiance was very authentic inside the restaurant and out.

Very busy place! But thankfully, we got seated in no time! Service was fast ...! You get free cuban bread as a starter. Dipping sauce was good. I liked the spicy one better. Entree was of generous servings! The drinks i loved! Not too much alcohol added ... it was just a perfect amount so I have enjoyed both my food and my drink!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Must-Visit in Key West – Incredible Food, Atmosphere & Hospitality! El Meson de Pepe’s completely exceeded my expectations and was the highlight of my trip to Key West! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warmth and hospitality that made us feel like family. The vibrant atmosphere, infused with Cuban culture, lively music, and rustic decor, set the perfect tone for an authentic dining experience. The Food – A Culinary Masterpiece! Every single dish we tried was an explosion of flavor, showcasing the rich and bold essence of Cuban cuisine. Here are some of our standout favorites: ✅ Whole Fried Snapper – Crispy on the outside, tender and flaky on the inside, topped with fresh onions, peppers, and citrus—absolutely perfection! ✅ Ropa Vieja – The shredded beef was succulent and packed with flavor, perfectly paired with black beans, sweet plantains, and yellow rice. ✅ Vaca Frita – Crispy, juicy, and seasoned to perfection, a must-try for any meat lover! ✅ Tostones Nachos – This creative twist on nachos, with crispy plantains, savory shredded beef, cheese, and fresh toppings, was an absolute winner. ✅ Cuban Coffee & Mojitos – The perfect drinks to complete the experience. The mojito was refreshing and well-balanced, and the Cuban coffee was bold, rich, and energizing. Service – 10/10! The staff at El Meson de Pepe’s went above and beyond to make sure our dining experience was flawless. Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive, making great recommendations and ensuring our drinks were always full. Atmosphere & Entertainment Beyond the incredible food and service, the live music and outdoor seating in the heart of Mallory Square made this an unforgettable night. The energy of the restaurant, the smell of delicious food in the air, and the sound of a live salsa band transported us straight to Havana! Final Verdict: A MUST-VISIT! If you’re in Key West and looking for authentic Cuban cuisine, phenomenal service, and an unbeatable atmosphere, El Meson de Pepe’s is THE place to go! Whether you’re here for a romantic dinner, a lively group outing, or just passing through, this spot delivers on all fronts. 🌟 5 STARS & HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! 🌟 ✍️ Pro Tip: Come hungry, order a mojito, and don’t skip the tostones nachos!

The most terrible experience I’ve ever had at a restaurant. Our server Jose was the most disrespectful server I’ve ever encountered. First he took the order for appetizers and after that took forever to come back and get our order for the meal, by the time he came back he had to tells us that they were out of white rice and arroz Moro which is what we planned to order. We didn’t mind and made our order and actually had to go one by one saying what we wanted and substituting the sides for fries. When the food finally arrived it was completely wrong. Basically all the sides were supposed to be fries and 2 of the orders had yellow rice and black beans, which we never would have ordered together and we mentioned that to our server while he took the order. The worst part is that we ordered 3 churrascos and only got one. The server Jose realized the mistake and started blaming us very rudely, saying we should have been paying more attention while ordering which was extremely disrespectful and rude. He started fighting back and forth on how it was not his fault the order was wrong when it was him who should have realized that we were six at the table and he only had 4 orders. After that he never came back to our table until we went up to him to get the bill because all we wanted was to leave. Everybody saw the way he spoke to us because he was very loud, rude and condescending and no manager or anyone intervened. I included pictures of the state of our table when we left. The plates from the appetizers were never picked up and we ordered multiple mojitos and the empty glasses were all there. Also the food was not good at all the black beans we never ordered were grey and and watery. We thought it was a sauce at first. Overall terrible experience, would not recommend and will not be going ever again.

Another fabulous dinner spot in the Keys! The Stoned Crab is such a fun experience — good food, good service, and a great view! I had the shrimp with a fresh salad, and my husband went with the shrimp and lobster fettuccine ~ both were delicious. The atmosphere is relaxed but lively ~ you can even feed the sharks while you wait for your food 🦈 It's a unique and memorable dining experience ~ definitely recommend! ➡️ Follow us on Socials for more detailed travel tips @Sweet_Southern_Living

Was going to go Outback. Seen this place and stopped because not a brand name place. Seated right away. The waitress didn't come up right away for drinks. Took drink and appetizer order. The appetizer came quickly, no forks or napkins on the table. Had to ask another waiter for these. Main food came, asked for extra butter. Waited more than 5 mins, and had to ask the other waiter again for butter. He responded right away. Looked like a nice place for great seafood. Got a crab combo bucket with the 1/2 Lobster tail. The food was bland tasting like cheap crab boils. Regular butter also. Garlic butter would have made a difference. Should have gone to Red Lobster.

The food is simply okay. I ordered a lobster mac and unfortunately all I tasted was butter lol. The bathrooms are a pretty tight squeeze (I’m not fat or anything) the parrot is Lexi at the bay ibis

I had a great experience! The service was great and very quick. The food was very good and so very fresh, the view was nice and they have nice props around the restaurant to take pictures, i will definitely be visiting again.

I am not sure why this place has a 3.5 rating. The food here is absolutely amazing. It's well seasoned cooked to perfection 👌 and the menu has plenty of options. The service was outstanding, staff worked as a team and were a pleasure to talk to. Although its outside there were no peaky flies bothering us so im not even sure how that is possible 😅. Overall great experiences both days I went because the food was so good. I had the yellow and red snapper with fries one day and yellow rice the next day and both options were very tasty!!! Speed over to this place to eat or you are absolutely missing out. Oh...that pie...YEP yes and yes go and get you some!!

Our first trip to Key West. The Stoned Crab came highly recommended, and it did not disappoint. The food was outstanding. We enjoyed crab, octopus, shrimp, and chicken fetticcine. The atmosphere is beautiful. Our waitress, Medarling (Amanda) was fantastic. Prompt and professional. Her welcoming smile goes a long ways. We will definitely visit again on our next trip to Key West. A+

We had an amazing experience at Stoned Crab in Key West! The food was absolutely delicious, fresh, and full of flavor, but what really made the visit unforgettable was our waitress, Diana. She was incredibly friendly, attentive, and went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. Thank you, Diana, for your exceptional service — you truly made our evening special! Highly recommend this place to anyone visiting Key West.

AB Lobster in Key West is a must-visit for both the food and the setting. The view while dining is absolutely incredible—breathtaking scenery that makes the whole experience unforgettable. The food was excellent—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. The dessert was delicious and a sweet finish to the meal. The drinks, however, were a bit of a letdown compared to everything else, especially given how high-quality the food was. Still, the overall experience was wonderful. Between the fantastic seafood and one of the best views in Key West, I’d happily return to AB Lobster for the food and scenery alone.

Everything was absolutely delicious. Our service was amazing. Michael won us all over with his suggestions and as I was torn between the lobster and the scallops he made it happen that I got both. The espresso martinis were on point in the old-fashioned which is their house drink was fabulous. The creme brulee was outstanding and the key lime pie was the best we have had so far. I highly recommend this restaurant if you are here!! Thank you Michael 😊

Delightful experience dining at A&B Lobster House in Key West this week. Don’t be fooled by the low rating, dragged down by odd reviews! Beautiful location overlooking the marina in the Key West bight. Pavel was our waiter, did a fantastic job, helped us navigate the menu. Attentive but not intrusive! Dinner was excellent, cocktails followed by Pinot Grigio, grilled scallop with caviar, crab cakes, and triple-tail catch of the day, rare menu item … all delicious! Great location, fine dining! Ambiance awesome. Highly recommend!

Absolutely phenomenal! We had the absolute BEST time eating here during our family vacation. We started with the Oysters, which were so delicious. We each got a mixture of food and tried little bits of each, between the Tuna Steak, Alaskan King Crab Legs, Surf & Turf, and more.... Every single dish was perfectly cooked and plated. The staff was also just as pleasant as the food and are very attentive as well. Im also obsessed with the old-school type bar/bathroom in this place as well. Its a Key West GEM! We can not wait to come back!

I had an amazing dining experience here. I ordered the filet mignon and a truffle risotto, and both were absolutely delicious — perfectly cooked and beautifully presented. The meal started with warm bread and butter shaped with the restaurant’s initials, such a thoughtful detail. We sat in the outdoor seating area, which was lovely and made the evening even more enjoyable. I also tried the Espresso Martini, which was excellent and tasted like a coffee dessert. Highly recommend!

We were Key West two weeks ago celebrating our 35 Wedding Anniversary. My husband made reservations at another restaurant, I wanted to be surprised. We got to the other place and we're VERY disappointed by just the atmosphere when we walked in. We had asked our concierge to recommend a really nice place for this special evening. We wanted three things for sure. Lobster and steak, Lobster Bisque, and a view of the water. We got there and NO table with a view. The menu came and it had NO Lobster anywhere on the menu. We left.. Pretty upset because it's our anniversary. But the concierge there(it was at a hotel)helped us and we found an even better place! We ended up at A & B Lobster House and let me tell you from the second we walked in we were extremely impressed! Greeted immediately!! The whole vibe was amazing! Great atmosphere! They had our reservation and we were facing the water at Sunset! Amazing! We were quickly greeted by Nicholas who would be our server for the evening!! Fantastic customer service! Polite, funny, and ok new the menu perfectly! Our meal started with the Lobster Bisque, divine! I had a martini and my husband had their special Old Fashioned both did not disappoint! For our main course I had the Grouper and he had the Steak and Lobster both were cooked perfectly and we ate every bite. Nicholas checked on us several times throughout the meal and took a very nice photo for our Anniversary! Then he surprised us with a special dessert of their in house homemade Key Lime Pie!! Soooo good! Overall and absolutely amazing experience and they really made our Anniversary dinner so special! Highly recommend!!2

So make a reservation like a week before. That’s key to get in here and get sat. We had an great server who looked exactly like Julia Roberts. She was amazing!! We sat on the balcony over looking the marina, where they were feeding the huge tarpons. For the appetizer we had a king crab, crab cake. Holy moly was that packed with crab. We had some cocktails with the appetizer. Tito’s n soda and my girl had a mojito. Both were bangin. The main courses were the surf n turf awesome! My girl had a fat spiny lobster tail! Both were great. Dinner was pricey, $280 with a tip but it was really worth it.

Salute! On The Beach offers a truly relaxed Key West dining experience, blending good food with unbeatable views. Nestled right on the beach, the location alone makes it worth a visit — you can feel the ocean breeze, hear the waves, and watch the sun dip low while enjoying your meal. It’s casual yet scenic, perfect for a laid-back evening out. I ordered the pesto pasta with Salute’s vegetables, which was vibrant, fresh, and satisfying without feeling too heavy. I paired it with a stout and a Bradley beer, both of which complemented the dish nicely and added to the mellow, beachside vibe. For my daughter, we ordered noodles with red sauce and cheese, a simple and comforting plate that she really enjoyed. Service was quick and efficient — we didn’t have to wait long for anything, and the staff was friendly and attentive throughout. The overall experience was easygoing and enjoyable, ideal for families or anyone looking to enjoy a relaxed meal just steps from the water. Definitely a great spot to unwind with good food, drinks, and that classic Florida Keys backdrop.

This place was awesome! The folks greet you at the door and they exude positivity! The bar is just what you'd expect for being on the beach, but is perfect! The food is delish and portion sizes are healthy. Got the lasagna and the yellow tail snapper. Both were awesome! Parking is plentiful on days when the beach isn't crowded. Highly recommend!

First time trying Salute on the beach and it was great! Nice beach view outdoor seating and atmosphere all around. Mark the Host was so friendly and fun, he’s the best! Jesus was our server and he also took great care of us! Literally everything we tried was soooooo delicious! The fresh bread they bring to the table started off our meal the right way…so fresh and tasty! You can tell the chef put a lot of thought into these menu items. You gotta try the calamari! Might be the best I ever had; it’s sautéed instead of breaded and has a spicy red sauce, we loved it! Make sure you get the key lime pie for dessert! Thanks for an awesome time!

The food was amazing. We ordered the muscles in the white sauce it was to die for! The fresh fish was so yummy and tender the sauces on both of our fish dishes were amazing! The food made me dance. It was so delicious and filling, I had the yellow snapper and my husband had the grouper. The staff was very friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was very relaxing and romantic we sat pretty much on the beach. This is our favorite restaurant in Key West hands down!

I rode the rental bike to Salute restaurant. I arrived around 11:00 AM to have more seating options. I had the popular dessert named Key lime pie. The meringue is sky high, complimenting the outdoor beach scenery. Vhuntermassage LLC

This spot was an absolute gem! Tucked away by a peaceful public beach, it offered a welcome escape from the usual tourist bustle. We thoroughly enjoyed both the mussel pasta and the filet mignon; they were delicious! If you're looking for a tranquil beachside meal away from the noise, this place is definitely worth a visit. Just be prepared for the occasional rooster strutting through the dining area; a minor quirk, but not the restaurant's fault.

We had the blackened mahi sandwich and the mahi and shrimp pasta in a shrimp tomato sauce. We definitely recommend. We sat outside with our feet in the sand watching a volleyball game with a beautiful view. This place was recommended to us by a local.

We had breakfast here, and the breakfast burrito was plentiful. Bring your appetite if you order this dish. The atmosphere was great, you can sit inside or outside l - there are plenty of tables. The avocado toast was also brilliant. I will be coming back 2 or 3 more times on this 6-day trip here in Islamorada!

We had a great experience here today! My kids enjoyed their kids pancake plate (1 pancake, 1 egg, bacon and fruit for $8 was perfect for them), I enjoyed the Greek chicken salad wrap with a side of lobster bisque with pita chips. It was fantastic, a great light, yet filling brunch. My husband enjoyed his wrap and pasta salad as well. They had a beautifully tempting display of baked goods as well as a nice selection of gifts. The service was fast and friendly! We enjoyed sitting outside! I would definitely be sure to make a stop here!

If you’re looking for a great brunch spot, you have to stop by Midway Café! The food is amazing, and they offer both indoor and outdoor dining with plenty of delicious options. I had the omelette and the almond croissant both were incredible! Their menu has everything from breakfast and lunch to coffee and smoothies. Whether you’re staying in Islamorada or just passing through on your way to Key West, this place is a must-visit. Simply delicious!

My and family and I were staying at Islamorada for several days and checked out Midway Cafe and Coffee Bar for breakfast. I loved the bright, colorful eclectic decor, and local art. The service was good and the food was great. We liked Midway Cafe so much that we came went there a few times during our stay. Highly recommended ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Great place to grab lunch/breakfast. My family stopped here on our way back from Key West to Homestead. Has both outdoor and indoor seating. Lots of food & drink options as well. Very fresh food too. I got the ‘Everyone’s Favorite Sandwich’ and it was delicious. My dad got the club wrap and loved it. Right off the road. 10/10 recommend.

We stopped here on our way out of the keys and it was one of the best breakfasts I’ve ever had. We had the green egg sandwich, single pancake, coffee and my husband made his own sandwich. Free refills on coffee, superb food! 10/10 definitely stop. Also the most reasonably priced spot!

This was the CUTEST little cafe. Excellent breakfast, the espresso is delicious. The wait staff is so friendly and sweet. A must stop.

Lots of interesting dishes especially if you are vegan. I only had the opportunity to try the vegan key lime pie, as the night we planned to have dinner here it was pouring rain. The key lime was ok - I’ve had better dairy free pie before. It wasn’t creamy enough -very solid. And no gluten free crust which would have made a big difference. The service was wonderful, very friendly. The inside was beautifully decorated. But as in most key west restaurants, no a/c, at least not turned on. It’s often so hot in the key west restaurants. I would recommend though. Wish I could have tried more things!

A gem for vegetarian eats in Key West! The kale caesar is next-level—crisp, flavorful, and totally crave-worthy. Their noodle bowls are just beyond, fresh-pressed juices are pure sunshine, and the ordering process is a breeze with quick, seamless pickup. Every visit feels like a little burst of joy—always fresh, always delightful. We live in the middle keys and it's always on the schedule when we are in KW- My son says "the waffles here are better than lego-land"....that's a big deal! Cheers to your 3 fabulous years and lots more to come.

Vegan options! WOW the food is really tasty. They have lots of vegan, vegetarian and gluten free options including desserts! We went for lunch. I had the "Chicken" salad sandwich with the bean salad - both were delicious! My husband had the Ceasar Kale salad which was a generous portion. I got the Fresh limeade (also very good). I saw they have breakfast/brunch options too so will definitely be back!

We came by a chance and experience was fantastic. Wand was very kind and also Samantha very attentive to details. Good food and pescatarian and vegetarian food with great flavors. Cocktails were delicious. Highly recommended

This place was a fantastic surprise. Went there as a group. Every single dish was absolutely delicious, fresh and full of flavor. Even the coffee is amazing, haven’t had a good cup of coffee like that in a long time.

Great choice for vegetarians and vegans! Delicious food that was very filling. My entire family was able to eat without having to worry about the ingredients! We had the quesadilla with vegan cheese and sour cream (super rare for restaurants to offer vegan options like that!), the grande burrito, BBQ un-wing dings (super crispy), and more. Amazing service as well, was checked on plenty but not intruded! Would highly recommend!

Delicious vegetarian spot in Key West! Stopped by The Café and loved everything we ordered — the polenta sticks were perfectly crispy, the spinach quesadillas were flavorful and satisfying, and the truffle fries were absolutely addictive. Great atmosphere and friendly service, too. Highly recommend if you’re looking for tasty vegetarian options in Key West!

Key Lime Pie is down as a must have if visiting the Keys. This place was listed as a good place to visit, wasn't disappointed. The pie was lovely 😋😋 Staff were really friendly, the shop has a wide variety of key lime items to choose from too. Highly recommend.

Made the visit for our first key lime pie ever. Parking to the side of the shop and also across the road next to the bank. Variety of other lime related products inside but we were only interested in the key lime pies. Went for a chocolate topping key lime and a meringue one. Loved the strong lime flavour of the lime married with a biscuit base. Couldn't finish in one sitting but had the rest later in the day. Would recommend!

Blonde Giraffe is an absolute gem! The moment you walk in, you’re greeted by the sweet, citrusy aroma of freshly made Key Lime Pie — and it’s every bit as delicious as it smells. Their classic Key Lime Pie is smooth, tangy, and perfectly balanced with a buttery graham cracker crust. I also loved their chocolate-dipped Key Lime Pie on a stick — such a fun treat and a true taste of the Keys! The shop itself is charming and colorful, with a relaxing outdoor garden area that’s perfect for enjoying your dessert. The staff are friendly, welcoming, and clearly proud of what they make. You can tell everything is crafted with care. If you’re traveling through the Keys, don’t miss Blonde Giraffe. It’s not just dessert — it’s part of the full Florida Keys experience!

We’re from the UK and this is our first time in Florida so had to try the key lime pie. For the purpose of research we went here, to a place in Key West and another place in the Keys, Blond Giraffe won for us, it was simply the best. I didn’t think I would like key lime pie as I’m not a big fan of lime but it was AMAZING and I can’t stop thinking about it! You have to try it here, it was creamy, tangy and absolutely delicious and I would never travel through the Keys again without stopping here!

Every time I go to the keys, getting key lime pie is a must. I saw this place as I was driving and decided to try somewhere new to pick up key lime pie. I tried the Key Lime pie with merengue and it was so delicious. The merengue was a perfect pair with the acidic taste of the key lime pie. I also tried the chocolate key lime pie with whip cream. It was good but I liked the key lime pie with merengue better. I also loved how this place has a cute garden in the back. You can get love locks and add to the fence. There’s also beautiful trees that provide a lot of shade. The back has clean bathrooms for anyone who needs to use it. I loved this zen area as it was very peaceful. It’s a great spot to sit and enjoy the desserts that you just purchased. The service was also great. I will definitely stop at this establishment for key lime pie when I go to the keys again.

This place was super easy to get in to and order. While everything in here is key lime related you shoukd probably enjoy key lime as much as I do. The place is not cheap but what is these days....so unless you're willing to make your own definitely give this a try and have the chocolate dipped key lime pie on stick...the best

If you’re passing through the Keys, this place is a MUST-STOP! The Key Lime Pie at Blond Giraffe is absolutely delicious — creamy, tangy, and perfectly balanced with that graham cracker crust. You can tell they’ve mastered the recipe. I also picked up their famous Key Lime Meringues — light, airy, and full of flavor, and to top it off they’re gluten-free and fat-free. The shop itself is charming with a tropical vibe, friendly staff, and a nice selection of sauces, jams, and other local treats. It’s the perfect spot to grab souvenirs or just treat yourself to authentic Key Lime flavors. Highly recommended for anyone visiting the area!

We went to Key West for our honeymoon and this was one of our stops to visit. The ice cream is delicious!!! A lot more pricey than I would have liked, $20 for 2 people, but it was yummy.

Whoever was working tonight was so sweet,attentive and helpful. And I'm sure we were annoying with all our questions but she seemed to really enjoy helping. The strawberry ice cream was super fruity n creamy. Loved the chocolate chip. It was just like we used to get when I was a kid. Light flaky chocolate chips. Lots of chocolate. Was not a huge fan if the chocolate amaretto. Promising but it had a slightly fake alcohol flavor to it. Maybe a minor adjustment in the recipe would fix it. The best by far BANANA CINNAMON! Light, fluffy, and velvety and a little sweeter. It's my new favorite. Anyhow definitely the best ice cream in Key West. We've had them all. This one is the most flavorful and absolute best service.

We come from Lancaster County Pennsylvania, where there’s Cow to come ice cream on Every corner, yours is amazing what’s more, we were Here almost twenty years ago (maybe 18 or 19) I said to Katie last night “were ya’ll Here 20 years ago She said Yes!!!! We’ve been proudly serving for like forty years!!!!” She was WONDERFUL The best ever really you meet some people occasionally who serve others with a Kind Heart interested in Helping others she’s one of them, and the ice cream was spectacular too, a can’t miss on your list of Key West Experiences

Very delicious ice cream and a wide selection! The staff is very polite and friendly!

This place needs more credit on the island as it definitely seems underrated. They have so many fun and fresh flavors to offer and some local ones like Cuban coffee and key lime. They also have variety as they serve sorbets, frozen yoghurt and gelato-style ice cream. I had the coconut and guava and both of them are excellent. The coconut has actually shreds of coconut that gives it a nice texture and the guava is the prettiest color. It did get a little crowded and chaotic while I was there as there was only one person running it but she was super nice about offering samples and being patient. Highly recommend just dropping by as you walk around!

I live in Florida but was my first time in key west. West to this place yesterday. OMG. Ice cream was so good. I got guava and key lime, my wife and daughter chocolate and my son vanilla. Chocolate was really good and I am not a big fan of chocolate ice cream. Guava was delicious with a natural flavor. But I will tell you, the key lime flavor was amazing. I this was the best ice cream I ever tried in the US honestly. Definitely worth coming back for that.

Delicious! I had French chocolate, coconut and chocolate Kahlua my fiance had mango, lavender and banana. Go big or go home get the three scoops for $7.75. they don't take credit cards so make sure you have cash on hand. Highly recommend trying them. There's also picnic tables outside to sit on.

We had ordered Thai Basil Chicken Fried Rice, Chicken dumplings, Spring roll and Thai Basil Tofu fried rice. Food was good, dumplings were a bit dry, could have been better. But fried rice was flavorful and I would recommend to eat along with one spicy side they give.

The food was soo good, the views, the service and overall i can’t wait to be back! The food had a lot of flavor, the desserts were just right in sweetness and they have many options, i do recommend!!

Great service! It was hot and muggy so we ate inside. Outside they only had one fan not worth the view of the marina. I got the shrimp pad Thai no spice. It was very sweet and the cabbage wasn’t cooked into the food. It was raw and on the side. The spring rolls were delicious & I ordered the peanut sauce to go with it. Husband ordered chicken fried rice; he said it was fine. We won’t be returning not with the $61 ticket price. They charged us $4 for a bottled water as well.

We love this place! Jocelyn, the downstairs bartender, took very good care of us and even drew adorable customized Pomeranian/mermaids on our to-go boxes. Big bonus they are dog friendly!

The food was fantastic, and the atmosphere was great! Plus, the customer service was truly commendable.

Amazing food and service. Brought our fresh caught Mahi here after a charter. Highly recommend.

I can say this restaurants is (was) one of my favorites in Key West because of the really good food, this Saturday we came for lunch and the server not even said hello. The table was dirty, sticky and when I asked to clean it she didn’t like it. The food was really good as always, but she never came back to ask us if we would like a dessert or something else she just came with the bill. We paid and said good bye forever to one of our favorites restaurants because we are not coming back.

Gluten free cupcakes and desserts! Also love the mint chocolate chip (oddly, the plain chocolate wasn't my favorite). They also have a shop stocked with local artists' items. We finally found cute jewelry for my niece! I was surprised at how many places down here don't have earrings for young girls! Love what we bought here!

Great variety of regular and gluten free dessert options. They also feature a coffee bar for drinks, and have a side room with ample seating if you have multiple people together. The service was friendly, the bathroom was clean (and cute, love the salt scrub option!) and the rum raisin ice cream I enjoyed was refreshing. Brought home a chocolate covered key lime and cupcake for later! Prices were fair for baked goods. They also made a note at the cash register about their pricing transparency (some items being more now post-tariffs) and I commend them at wanting to maintain an honest relationship with their customers. They clearly communicate the change in that flyer and as a customer it makes me want to support them more knowing they were mindful about taking steps to ensure they weren’t price gouging.

Ice cream is rich and creamy with a ton of great diverse flavors. Fun signage and options add some variety to the aesthetic. Key lime pie is so thick and dense and the whipped topping is fresh and flavorful. Really one of the the best pies I've had in the keys. S'mores cookie was gooey and soft with the perfect ratio of marshmallow and chocolate. Cost is reasonable against portion sizes and the little shop and seating is clean and abundant. Def a must stop in marathon.

This was our first time visiting Sweet Savannah’s, and wow—what an amazing treat! Hands down, the best ice cream in Marathon. The variety of flavors is impressive, and every one we tried was absolutely delicious 😋. We’ll definitely be back, and we highly recommend Sweet Savannah’s to anyone looking for a sweet and satisfying experience!

Amazing!!! Many gluten free options that tasted like normal desserts and priced fair. Their gf key lime pie is the best I’ve ever had (even better than non gf)! My husband had the normal key lime pie and also said it was the best he’s ever had. We each had a cheesecake slice as well. Additionally, the shop was absolutely adorable. If you’re visiting the keys, you must stop here for ice cream, a baked treat or a cute gift or keepsake!

Husband and I stopped in here on vacation. Sweet little place with delicious desserts. We got key lime pie ice cream and key lime pie cheesecake. Both were awesome. Their whole dessert display case was a temptation. Staff was friendly. Highly recommend.

Adorable store with a separate seating area. Ice cream, baked goods, souvenirs. The key lime pie has the right amount of "tart", not too sweet like some of them. Good variety of cupcake flavors (the website lists flavors of the day, but there are more flavors available). Prices are reasonable (for the Keys).

Thank you so much to Key West Cakes for the most delicious and beautiful wedding cake!! We ordered a heart cake for an intimate wedding, the inside was vanilla and chocolate marble with Bavarian cream. 10 out of 10!!! The cake was moist and rich, absolutely perfect for our needs. Steve handled my order all the way from Maryland and had it delivered to the wedding reception. It absolutely exceeded my expectations. Thanks again so much!! Highly recommend.

We were absolutely blown away with our wedding cake! We got a vegan cake because I am dairy free and it was the best cake I have ever had. We choose a chocolate cake with raspberry filling and vanilla frosting. Our guests haven’t stopped talking about it! Key West Cakes has been a pleasure to work with- you will not go wrong with a cake from here!

Key West Cakes did our wedding cake, and I couldn't have been happier! We chose a coconut cake with coconut icing, and it was such a crowd pleaser. I normally find wedding cake to be boring and dry, but this cake was so moist, fluffy, and flavorful. Our guests loved it! We tried saving the top tier but ended up devouring it with family the next day because we were all talking about how good it was. I will dream of this cake until I'm able to be back in Key West for a slice again soon!

We walked a mile to get to this place in the heavy, humid heat, but man it was worth it! I wanted to grab a couple cupcakes for my husband’s birthday, and so we each picked one of these enormous things out! We were able to walk right in without ordering ahead of time. The staff was extremely friendly, and they even attached a birthday candle to the one my husband picked out so that we could celebrate properly! My double chocolate cupcake and his lemon one were both fantastic in their own ways. I would recommend this spot to anyone. They also do wedding cakes, which I can only imagine are amazing.

Heavenly cupcakes! I picked up 6 of them today and tried the Funfetti as soon as I got home. A perfect 10 for me. The buttercream frosting is wonderful, it is not too heavy. There was a good amount of frosting on too, which is my favorite part of any cake so it was a hit for me. I can't wait to try the other flavors I got: mint chocolate chip (which has green mint cake vs chocolate cake), guava, lemon lovers, coconut bliss and key lime pie. They look incredible and based on the first one I tried I'm sure they will be just as delightful. A must-try for any cake lover. I can't wait to go back and try different flavors and also try their cookies. I do have one recommendation though, either drive to get these (they have some parking) or put them in a cooler to get them home if walking or biking. I had the cupcakes in a sealed bike bag during the hottest part of the day and got them home in under 10 min and some of the frosting had started to slide off and kind of "melt". Totally my fault and lesson learned. Next time I will have an ice pack in my bag.

Dave and team at Key West Cakes was an absolute pleasure working with for our wedding this past June. We worked with the team to develop a dessert menu of key lime tartlets and gluten free cupcakes (celiac guest). Not only were the tartlets delicious but the team at a Key West Cakes promptly delivered and setup our dessert table. Highly recommend Key West Cakes for any event in the keys. We will be going back for the tartlets everytime we visit!

Ordered a cake for my girlfriend’s birthday, 6 days in advance mind you, it was a waste of money. When ordered six days prior, the staff had asked us to come pick it up September second at 2pm thinking that it would be ready by then. The cake was not done and still being made at the time we were asked to arrive to pick it up, and looked nothing like the reference picture. It tasted disgusting and looked terrible. Their excuse for not having it on time was that they didn’t have a black ribbon to put on the cake and that’s why they waited 6 days to make a cake. Below is the reference photo and the cake I was handed for my girlfriend’s birthday. Thanks for ruining her 20th, will definitely not be coming back here anytime soon.

Terrible maintenance and no hotel personnel. Bathroom sink had no stopper. Shelf missing in the bathroom. Peeling paint everywhere outside. Water pressure was terrible. Water wasn’t warm enough. Electrical plugs were broken or not secured. Receptacle plates were missing. Blinds don’t work. Dirty carpets. Exterior Wood trim coming off on various spots around the property. Storing luggage in the public dining room is ridiculous when no one to protect your stuff. Wallpaper in the main building coming off. Termite and powder post beetle damage in the fancy woodwork that should have been repaired in the main house. Room needs painted. The room I booked online with pretty woodwork and wood floors was far from what I got. Our room was in the adjacent building with carpet and painted woodwork. Not even close to how we were misrepresented or bait and switch with the room. The picture online of the room we booked wasn’t even close to what we got. I should have read the reviews before I booked. Run fast. Way more places better than this for the money. Terrible room for my birthday. Will never stay there again.

Abysmal. Curry Mansion has a lot of history. I stayed here in the 90’s with my parents when it was a family-friendly bed and breakfast. Those days are long gone. Now you’re lucky if you don’t get woken up in the wee hours by trashy people fighting over who-knows-what (drugs? money? baby momma drama? Take your guess!) by the pool. The location is convenient, but I’d personally rather go somewhere better (and cleaner) farther out for the same price. I should also mention that there isn’t any staff to help. You’re on your own, or you can email and wait about a day for a response.

Having previously stayed twice at the Curry Mansion Inn when it was still owned by the Curry family, my husband and I had no hesitation in booking a deluxe king room with balcony for our recent trip to Key West. What a disappointment on this occasion. The room itself was not clean and I found some maggots in the corner of the room. The door to the balcony would not shut and the sink in the bathroom was rusty and not cleaned properly. There are no staff on site except for a lady that serves coffee and a couple of items for breakfast over in the main house, which you have to pay separately for. Previously, breakfast was served round the pool and included in the price as was a happy hour 5-7 every evening. The rooms are not cleaned at all during your stay . The staircarpet to the first floor rooms looked as though it had never been vacuumed and was filthy. I would certainly not recommend people to stay here any more.

Check in was simple, but if you were expecting a representative on site surprise no one was available. The good news was text messages worked and became very import as our stay progressed. The mansion is impressive, but our room was discussing the carpet had not been vacuumed in a long time and was badly stained. Do not walk on it in bare feet!! and then to our surprise a extra large sound stage was set up outside our room and during sound checks our room vibrated severely. We checked out and found another hotel for our stay. top price for crap. I will never stay at the Amsterdam Surry Mansion again.

pros: Central. Walking distance to sunrise pier and other restaurants, bars and pubs.Neat rooms. Restaurant on site was nice but basic, and service was good. Service was shocking. Booking is done through an offsite agent. 10am check. Doors lock up and we could not get back in to pack. 3am fires alarm woke everyone. No Apology or explanation. Eventually someone arrived to open our door so we could pack up. Definitely lacks service with a smile…

This was not a perfect place but it was clean . Convenient to everything. Would like to see this place back to what it was. Not a aibnb. This place needs love and care. Don't like how know one is there. If I owned it I have it the way it was supposed to be. I will stay there again. Thank you. Not much parking so be prepared.

Very cool hotel, just steps off Duval. Its tucked away and very private. A great place to enjoy Key west. Dogs allowed too which is awesome.

Refreshing Key lime pie the crust was crispy. Very good I also had the toasted coconut ice cream. Very good not to sweet just right. Lots of things to buy.

Besides a slice or whole pie and other desserts, you can step in and find all sorts of key lime mechandise. Not only dessert but marinades, sauces, and rubs. They also have a section of clothing key west style of course.

Nice little shop had souvenirs,clothes snakes and ice cream. The key lime pie was great !!! Staff was very friendly. Key lime pie in key west is the best 👌

I’ve been recommended to try this place by a colleague from work in Phoenix. WOW!!! You can sample here almost everything, they do have them - so nice! I liked so much the ambiance of this store and the girls at the counter were so welcoming and cute. They have a huge diversity of key lime delicatessens- Key lime cookies, candies, cakes, coolers, chocolates, ice creams and more. The Kermit’s pie and pie on the stick is a must to try - so delicious, LOVE it! Will go again for sure when be back to Paradise. Would definitely recommend this place to everyone who’s visiting Florida keys. Cheers!

This wasn’t on our plan but noticed it while walking on the street. I wanted to try key lime pie in key west and accidentally stumbled on this place which had best key lime pie. I have never had key lime pie before so I cannot compare but it was delicious. Small cozy place which has few chairs outside. We sat outside eating our pie and drinking tea. Our son had ice cream. We saw few chickens running around which reminded me of my childhood back in India where chickens were just part of life in villages.

This is where I ate key lime pie. The real key limes are small but full of sweet juice. The locates all said to try here 1st so we did. Keep up the good work. I tried my first my pie on a stick, so neat.

THE most delicious key lime pie ive ever had in my life. Im not a fan of key lime pies, i dont usually order them as desert. But since i was here in key west, i decided to give it a shot and it was the best decision of the day. It was amazing. Every taste bud was happy. Very easy going atmosphere, really nice to eat the key lime pie on the porch looking at the interesting people.

Super friendly staff and cute location. They have a ton of options for flavors (but as someone who is mindful of high fructose corn syrup, red dye #40, and other stuff that’s not super great for us, I was discouraged). I did enjoy a chocolate covered banana that had Minimally processed ingredients and thought it was delicious!

I felt rushed to make a decision so picked something I wouldn’t normally pick. I wish I hadn’t. It was a very milky milkshake. Def spent almost $36 on three milkshakes and a scoop of ice cream. I would’ve liked to try one of the handmade popsicles though.

We found this place through a Tik Tok video. It was a hit for the whole family. They had lots of choices with the popsicles. We went three times during our stay. We had the cookies and cream, cookie dough, strawberries and cream and the mango nada. They were all good. My only complaint was that a bottle of water was $2.50.

Recommended 💯. Don't miss it!!! The service, quality, and flavors are excellent. 😉👍 The ice cream and juices are exquisite.

Paradise Flavors is a true hidden gem in Marathon seriously, it’s next-level. This place has everything going for it: outstanding quality, spotless clean, super friendly service, free parking, and an insane variety of flavors that’ll thrill anyone. The owner, who’s Mexican, brings his heart and heritage into every scoop and paleta it’s the full package. Whether you’re craving classic favorites or adventurous creations, they’ve nailed it. Great prices, great taste, and a vibe that feels just right. Trust me, you’ll be bragging about it to everyone you meet.” We had the mineral Michelada also the Ferrero Rocher Paleta and few others hand crafted. Thank you Cesar.

This is by far the best ice cream I have ever eaten. It was incredibly creamy and had extraordinary flavor. My favorite was the coconut and butter pecan combination. My wife got the key lime pie and coconut, my daughter got the mint chocolate chip , and my father in law got mango and key lime pie. The atmosphere was top-notch, and the customer service was phenomenal. Annedy knows the definition of AMAZING CUSTOMER SERVICE!! It was my father in law's 75th birthday, and she gave him a special ice cream deal! Thank you for an awesome experience!!

Delicious ice creams and Milk shake. We tried 7 Mile milkshake. Recommend it. Very reasonable price. Friendly service. A paradise for sure for little ones 😀

Fun ice cream shop with novelty ice cream concept. The staff were very friendly and helpful. The ice cream was good with plenty of choices.

Super fun way to make ice cream! We had never seen the nitrogen and it was super fun to watch. The ice cream was very thick and rich, with great flavor.

We were visiting from out of town and my daughter wanted ice cream. Found this place on google and it looked really good. For being such a “cool” place I expected to see a lot more people in there, but we quickly realized why no one else was in there. The employees acted like we were inconveniencing them. One of them had head phones on staring at her phone and didn’t look up one time other than to laugh and talk to the other employee. My wife who has a dairy aversion was excited to try the dairy free option which they were out of. When she asked about the other options the lady who was helping us was rude and pretty much said this is what you get. The ice cream that was made for my daughter was good, and the way they do it is actually pretty cool, but as someone who visits the Keys regularly I will say that we will never go back here. The employees single handily turned me off from this location. Hopefully management reads these reviews, because after our experience I began reading them and guess what, we aren’t the only ones who think the employees are the problem.

My family loves Sparky's Sweet Treats! Every time we come to the Keys we stop in at least once but definitely more if we are able. Great place, Amazing Ice cream and nice & friendly staff. Our favorite place for a sweet treat.

I’m giving one star because the ice cream was good. But costumer service is the worst we ever experience and wasn’t clean. We are visiting Tavernier and my daughter found this place on Google, unfortunately, we agree with the other reviews. employees are on their phones, no eye contact, barely acknowledged us when we walked in and made me and my family feel uncomfortable, we almost walked out. Love my family time in the area, management should take the reviews into account since there is not a lot of options and Ice cream quality is good.

Best Icecream I've even had. Got Sparky's strawberry cheesecake and it was amazing!! Not usually a sweets fan, but this place was fun and great quality.

Cool place and the process they use is awesome but the person that was working the counter looked like they hate their job. They looked like they just got out of bed only it was 7:45pm, they were in sweats and a tank top and kept talking to their friend while we waited, they literally didn’t say a world to us and even looked annoyed when I asked a question about a product they had. Ice cream was good though lol.

Wow was this place busy! Cute atmosphere! Popular place and it shows. Lots of traffic in and out. We stopped late in the evening and there was just one young lady working. She had her work cut out for her as the line was VERY long. She never wavered and served everyone with a smile. If you have time to wait, it’s a good stop. And be sure to give the server a good tip because they earn it!

Ice cream is super good. Cute little spot. Just wanted to shout out to Sean who served us the ice cream. Super patient and chill vibes you should expect from an ice cream shop. Yknow I just really want to say that you hardly ever walk into an establishment these days - be it ice cream shop or otherwise - and experiences the friendliness and chill good vibes that Sean is holding down behind the counter. So nice and makes us want to come back!!! Thank you Sean!!! Fill that tip bucket!!!!

❤️A must stop for the BEST frozen chocolate dipped Key lime pie on a stick! It’s a must have for me every time we come to the keys. Their ice cream is delicious also. They also sell delicious key lime pies as well. Don’t pass this little gem by!

We stopped by to try the ice cream. Very clean and courteous. The smells inside were to die for. Free samples of the different types of ice cream they have on display before buying. They offer gluten free key treats as well. Outdoor seating. *They have Key Lime pie Ice cream* 👍🏼

Cute on outside and inside. Wouldn't go out of my way. The line for ice cream goes right by chocolate counter. Stood long enought not to be interested in getting a box of homemade chocolate and truffles. Saw no employee in that area. Maybe register person, but she was gone 5 -10 minutes. Husband got 1 scoop of strawberry, not one strawberry insight. I got vanilla bean with raspberry chocolate chip. Not one black vanilla bean and very weak flavor. Maybe I missed something and it was a special type. It was a steady pace of customer, but 3 employees had little room. Just FYI for owners, needs repainting and maybe replace rusty, uneven chairs. 2 places. Got big fancy wrapped or painted truck.

The chocolate sent this place has is delicious. It hits you the moment you walk in. I came to try the Dulce De Leche ice cream. The ice cream here is good. It was a flavor I had not had here before. It started like vanilla ice cream. I was a little disappointed but I had always been happy with the ice cream quality here. I also got an Ore cookie and a toffee crunch. I liked the cooking both very well. The place is easy to find. It's big and pink. You can not miss the place. The staff is nice and the chocolates are delish.

Cute Lil place to enjoy delicious treats. Ice cream and KEY LIME 🥧 PIE. Has a small sitting area outside, you have an option to buy the whole pie's. Their ice creams are very creamy 😋

Conch Custard Ice Cream is an absolute gem! The ice cream is incredibly creamy, flavorful, and clearly made with care—every bite tastes like a little vacation. They have a great variety of unique and classic flavors, and the portions are generous without being overwhelming. The shop itself is bright, welcoming, and spotless. It’s refreshing to find a place where not only the seating area but even the bathroom is exceptionally clean—something that speaks volumes about their overall attention to detail and customer care. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this is one spot you don’t want to miss. Can’t wait to come back!

It was a hidden gem with some of the nicest people out there and the ice cream is out of this world… great selection and flavors are homemade… they have some of the creamiest ice out there… worth the stop and will make your day… a must have if you are in the area..

Really terrific custard that kept us coming back day after day. We loved the cookies and cream, salted Carmel, Butterfingers and of course The Brody. Ask for the Brody! All the staff have been wonderfully helpful and pleasant.

Conch Custard is a Marathon must-stop in the Keys! Their homemade ice creams are on another level, especially the Andes Mint Chip. For something different, try their Gelati (raspberry and chocolate combo) highly recommended. Friendly service and that homemade touch makes this spot 5 stars.

This custard shop is a must stop if you are anywhere in the Keys. We are from Wisconsin and there is lots of custard up here and it's better than ice cream. We have had our fair share of Wisconsin home made custard and Conch Custard is up towards the top of the best custard we've ever had. The owner is really really nice and you can tell he's passionate about his craft. Tons of flavors to choose from. If I could rate it higher than a 5 star I would.

Nice, cozy, family-friendly ice cream parlor! Very nice staff with helpful attitude! I suggest it to everyone! Delicious ice cream BTW…

5 stars easily! Great customer service—very patient and efficient even with our seven kids! Incredible selection of flavors. Mix and match to get the most of your trip. Enjoy!! It’s so worth it!

Of course the trolley we rode on through Key West passed in front of Kermit's Key West Lime Shoppe. Of course a human dressed in a key lime-colored baker's outfit was right curbside showing off a whole key lime pie to us all. And of course my spouse had to have one. After throwing down a few and enjoying some conch around town, we popped in before getting back on the cruise ship. MENU: Pies (by the slice, whole, even shipped to the lower 48), ice cream, smoothies, beverages. DESSERT: Key Lime Pie On A Stick An actual slice of frozen pie was covered in a dark chocolate shell. I personally would've liked it more if it was milk chocolate as the combined tartness of the pie and dark chocolate made it extremely tart for me. Key Lime Pie I'm not a key lime pie expert or fan, but it was good to me. A bit tart, light, not overly sweet, with a thin and moist crust. SERVICE: The male staff member who assisted us was welcoming and friendly. TIP: They sell other snacks and items as well. Mosey around the store! OVERALL: If you're a key lime fan, I'm sure you'll love this place.

The BEST coconut key lime pie bar (omg)!!! I could eat every day! 🤣 the store is amazing. They offer free cookies, for you to try and decide if you want to buy it. It’s always busy but have a lot of space to enjoy your sweet in peace. Staff is so friendly and kind. They have a lot of options for gifts. I also bought a key lime pie lip balm and I LOVED IT! Smells like key lime pie and tastes great. 😅 Loved loved loved!!! 💚

Delicious!! Love all the varieties of met line. We ordered the regular key lime pie, strawberry key lime pie, and gluten free l Ed Mon cookies - all excellent. They d en offer free samples of some items (not the pie). We liked the key lime jelly beans. Friendly service too. Highly recommend

Great place to grab a slice of key lime pie! Super fun environment. They have lots of options as well. (Ice cream, cookies, etc.) We got the original as well as the strawberry flavored one. Great photo spots too. 10/10 recommend!

Had to try what I was told was the best key lime pie in KW. It was delicious indeed but I’ve got to believe there is better. Also the size of the slice is tiny. A slice of pie should be at least close to as long as the fork you’re eating it with! The shop had a lot of personality however, and i liked the free samples of some of their other goodies.

Shari and I popped into Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shoppe while in Key West on way to Rum Distillery Tour. It smelled like a slice of Heaven in there. We sampled a few cookies and a few pieces of Key lime candies But we bought nothing we were In a rush to the tour

Definitely some of the best key lime pie on the island, during my time in Key West I had thr famous and popular pie several times and it was the best out of them all. I liked how they didn’t overdo the meringue like others and topped it with some simple whipped cream. More on the tangy side and the store was really cute and had a good vibe.

I’m a key lime pie fan. We went by a few places to try their key lime pies. We got a small pie, it frozen, we ate it about a day later and it wasn’t good. It felt as the crust melted (got runny like the caramel of a flan). The texture wasn’t good, I’m not sure if it was because we got it frozen but it’s definitely not worth it. My daughter ate the whip cream. Publix key lime pie is a whole lot better.

Grabbed a key lime pie to go. Will say I had a decent amount of key lime pie this trip. I will say this one’s ok. Maybe it’s because for me I’d like to have a bit more crust for a texture difference or contrast, also the pie was more tart than sweet. Basically, if those flavor profiles matches your fancy, absolutely come in and grab a slice.

This was the MOST delicious key lime pie I had ever tasted. Such kind and friendly staff and amazing key lime pie merch for a reasonable price. The store was also beautifully decorated which made the experience even better. It was walking distance from our cruise ship and if you are ever in key west you need to stop by. I also got the most heavenly scented key lime pie candle, an authentic beignet and the most refreshing key limeanade. My only complaint is that I don’t think I will be able to eat another key lime pie again unless it is made from this place, it’s that good

This was the absolute best key lime pie I have ever eaten. My niece and her husband actually saw this company on The Profit and said the gentleman stated the same thing. I guess you’ll have to visit Key West to get a taste of true key lime pie or order it online and have shipped. I wish I had bought more!! I highly recommend visiting if in the area.

Absolutely delicious 😋!! My Hubby and I came in December 2023 all the way from Atlanta during a cruise and now I returned in May 2024 on another cruise with my Mom. The key lime pie is light and refreshing. I also enjoyed the key lime punch so authentic. What I appreciate the most is that it's not tart!! The most delicious choice in Key West...give them a try.

Very well clean place with nice designs and space. The service was friendly. The slices of key lime pies weren’t that tasty. It’s nice to see the process of making pies in front of you but personally I didn’t like the taste.

Definitely the BEST Key Lime Pie in the Key West!!! We have tried Key Lime Pie from other locations during the same visit, but their Key Lime Pie and taffy definitely have that Key Lime punch, great consistency and taste as well. We the the mini version, soft serve. Great service, great ambiance. I would definitely love recommend and I know I will definitely crave it when I’m back home.

Having breakfast at La Grignote is a great idea. It’s usually busy, and you may need to wait 10–15 minutes for a table, but you can grab a coffee while waiting. We ordered the Salmon Eggs Benedict with extra avocado and it was delicious. The latte was also great—creamy and smooth. The food came out quickly. Definitely recommend!

La Grignote – A Breakfast Gem in Key West If you're searching for the best breakfast in Key West, look no further than La Grignote. This charming bakery and café delivers an unforgettable morning experience that blends authenticity, quality, and warmth. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of freshly baked goods sets the tone. The sourdough bread is truly exceptional—crusty on the outside, perfectly soft on the inside. It’s clear that craftsmanship and care go into every loaf. The menu offers a delightful range of options, from classic pastries to hearty breakfast plates, all made with fresh ingredients and a touch of elegance. The coffee is strong and smooth, complementing the food beautifully. Service is friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere La Grignote is highly recommended—a must-visit for anyone who appreciates great food and genuine coffee.

We had an absolutely fantastic experience here. The staff was extremely attentive and the food was top notch. The house quiche and lobster Benedict were both outstanding. The view of Duval St was enjoyable while sipping mimosas. Highly recommended and we will be back.

Walking in you immediately understand that everything done there is done properly, and with care. That sounds funny talking about food, but baked goods are topped perfectly, bread is baked to perfection and while the restaurant was definitely busy, the staff is working tirelessly to turn tables over, to get new customers seated. Not just the “staff”, the OWNER! I told him that if the owner is willing to bus his own tables, that is a formula for success, especially in a place like Key West. Now for the food! Just as I saw in when I walked in, everything that arrived on our plates was fresh and delicious. My kids raved about the bacon, and it is served as half sized. Mini bacon strips! Who knew a tiny little change would be such a hit? The eggs Benedict is light and tangy and the waffle comes with a giant dollop of whipped cream. The tables are situated so that even with the small space, you don’t feel cramped. Prices were not ridiculous, but the food and service would have been worth the price, even if they were. Upper area of Duval is a nice change of pace from the downtown vibes.

La Grignote is a simple and cozy café in Key West, with a laid-back, beach-style vibe, wooden tables, colorful dishes, and a relaxed atmosphere. The highlight was definitely the service: all the staff were super friendly and attentive from start to finish. I chose to sit outside, which was very pleasant. Inside, there's a big display case with lots of tempting sweets, croissants, and other baked goods. I ordered a Croque Madame with 2 poached eggs on top. The portion was huge, and it ended up being too heavy for breakfast. It had a lot of béchamel sauce, which made the flavor kind of repetitive and overwhelming. Wasn't that good to be honest and I couldn't finish it. It came with a small bowl of fruit on the side. My boyfriend ordered a croissant with egg and bacon, and that was excellent! The pastry was light, flaky, and crispy on the outside. The only downside was the sausage that came on the side: fried and very greasy. Overall, it was a good experience. The food had its ups and downs, so it's worth choosing your dish carefully, but the great service and welcoming, no-frills environment made up for it. I give it 4 stars.

We got breakfast on a Sunday morning, there. We park ou bicycles literally next to us, and enjoyed our food. It is a small place, with inside, balcony, and covered patio, seating options. Absolutely great service, creative food suggestions. Very influencing and friendly decoration of the space. I got the orange juice and my girl got the strawberry lemonade, both were surprisingly awesome!

This place was so amazing for breakfast! The Belgian waffle and Tartine were so beautiful plated and tasted great. The porch/bar road side seating was great for a breeze and people watching. Definitely a must try when visiting.

I had a savory crepes and cappuccino for my breakfast, and purchased assorted pastries to enjoy on my ride to Miami. Oh boy, they're all fresh and delicious!

J'aime beaucoup! Lol loved this charming coffee, pastry, and sandwich shop! A good assortment of tasty treats in a tastefully designed and decorated space. Friendly, helpful staff. Nice small town feel. Get here early as they close at 2:30.

Lovely French bakery tucked away off the side of the major road running throughout KW. Without looking it up honestly this place would be very easily missed but missing this place would be a mistake. Very delicious and artfully crafted baked items. Can strongly recommend the chocolate and almond (bear claw?, not quite sure but I loved it) all items were delicate and sweet but not overwhelming. I could definitely go through several of these without an issue so I had to restrict myself to half a baked item a day. Flew a few back home they were so good. In the $4-5 range for most items. Absolutely make a stop here

What a wonderful surprise to find this charming French bakery hide in the Key West/Stark Island. We originally stopped in just for a cappuccino, but ended up staying until closing time, enjoying different tartines and the most delicious key lime beignet. The dough was absolutely perfect. We even picked up some croissants to take with us on our six-hour drive — and they were worth every bite. The staff were welcoming and friendly, which made the experience even better. I highly recommend this place — a true treasure in Key West!

We spent every morning of our trip to the Keys here for coffee and breakfast, and it never disappointed. From cappuccinos and lattes to frappes and food, everything was absolutely delicious. The portions were generous, and even when it was busy, the wait was never long. We especially loved the quaint atmosphere of the back patio- it became our favorite spot to start the day. Highly recommend!

We had an almond and chocolate croissant and an omelette with spinach, Brie and Swiss cheese. Delicious all of it! Our double espressos were caffeinated perfection! I highly recommend this bakery cafe!

Nice little breakfast spot. Not super French though - crepes were chewy, but tasty and espresso was served in styrofoam cups. Ugh. Outside of that, pretty fabulous. Very nice staff, clean, prices not too bad. Breakfast sandwiches on croissants were on point.

A local recommended Keys Chocolates for dessert, and since I absolutely love chocolate, I had to stop by for a sweet treat. The shop has a colorful ambiance and features work from local artists, which gives it a fun, creative vibe. They also serve ice cream on one side of the store, along with their signature Key Lime desserts (which I, unfortunately, couldn’t try due to an allergy). I ended up getting a box of 8 chocolates and one truffle, which came to almost $30 with tax. I hesitated because it felt a little pricey, but decided to purchase anyway to support the local business and try them out. The chocolates were definitely tasty, though I can’t say they stood out compared to other chocolates I’ve had at a lower price point. Service was polite, though the staff member helping me didn’t seem very knowledgeable about the chocolates. When I asked for recommendations, he mentioned that he never eats chocolate himself—which honestly left me unsure what to think. Overall, it was a fun spot to visit once, with a nice atmosphere and good treats, but I’m not sure I’d rush back.

Oh man, if you're craving a sweet escape, Keys Chocolate and Ice Cream is your ultimate paradise! This spot is a total delight for all things sugary – from creamy ice cream scoops to decadent chocolates, fun candies, and even cute gifts that'll make your heart skip a beat. My crew and I dove into some epic cones: the peanut butter swirl was like a dreamy hug from a peanut butter jar, mint chocolate chip brought that refreshing zing, caramel was pure gooey heaven, and the espresso flavor? And gluten free options! Total caffeine kick in dessert form – buzzworthy and bold! The place is adorable inside and out, with cozy indoor seating for those chill vibes and a sunny outdoor patio perfect for people-watching while you indulge. Whether you're flying solo or with friends, swing by and let your sweet tooth run wild – you won't regret it! 5 stars all the way!

Great shop to pick up sweet treats and a spectacular key lime pie. It is very clean and neat inside and has some seating indoors and outdoors as well. We took our pies to go and enjoyed them at home.

It’s a cute little shop. The sorbet and ice cream were amazing. My party ordered 2 milkshakes and it took 10 mins to make them. The blender (mixer?) is on its last legs! Staff were very nice, we didn’t feel rushed, even when it was slammed.

Staff was good even tho it was super busy and close to closing. I don’t understand their chocolate pricing. 4 little pieces for $10, 8 for $17. (Plus tax) I was just in Brussels Belgium in July and don’t know how these are more expensive than Belgium chocolate in Belgium on a shack on the side of the road. They were just ok. But the jewelry style box they come in makes them present better. Key like pie was $24.95. Was pretty good. Creamy and not too tart. A slice was $7 so I e basically just locked in dessert for the weekend lol

The ice cream was delicious and the staff were so friendly and welcoming, the place itself is designed beautifully with place to seat outside. It worth to stop and have a rest after long way to key west!

A fantastic opportunity to stop on your way through the Keys. We all had lovely fresh ice cream scoops. Choose the Key Lime and amaretto chocolate, they are both sensational

Such a cute place for desserts, wished we tried the ice cream. The cookies are absolutely huge and we got the snickerdoodle and chocolate chip. It was delicious but it didn’t WOW us. Overall the atmosphere and customer service were great!

This was a good ice cream spot; the ice cream is especially creamy which suggests to me that it has a higher cream content. The key lime pie was quite tasty; sweet yet tart and had a thick yummy buttery graham cracker crust. The gentleman added some whipped cream as this is not the “meringue topped” type of key lime pie. We also had some Cuban cappuccino which was essentially an Italian cappuccino but it was very good. The gentleman serving us surprised us with a taste of an affogado (espresso and some vanilla ice cream) which was really tasty! There are also giant cookies, fudge, gluten free chocolate macaroons but we did not try those. The ice cream is made down the street but it is essentially made on site as is the key lime pie. Good place!

I can't rave about their cookies enough!!!!! I died and went to heaven after my diabetic overload (No seriously I survived)! They were so good, that we went back the next day just to grab some more and plus some on the road trip back to Bradenton, Florida to visit some of our relatives. Definitely, didn't share with the relative. The last cookie didn't make it past the turn off from Alligator Alley to I-75. ----- Author C.A. McJack

Mattheessen’s Homemade is absolutely delicious! The ice cream sundae was incredible, topped with warm, fresh cookies that smelled amazing the moment you walked in. The whole place is filled with the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked cookies and sweets. Everything tasted rich, homemade, and full of flavor. If you’re in Key West, this place is a must-visit!”

By far the best key lime pie in all of Key West! The crust was incredible , and the key lime flavor is spot-on — tangy, smooth, and just right. We actually stumbled upon this spot while looking for ice cream but decided to try the pie instead… and I’m so glad I did! Highly recommend — even better than Kermit’s!

Wonderful overall experience! Nice people, delicious ice-cream and the ½ lb. cookies looked scrumptious!!!😆

Excellent customer service and delicious Ice cream, maxi cookies and Key Lime Pie.

Delicious creamy ice cream and smooth flavor filled fudge. I had the Key West Mud Slide in a waffle cup and my wife got a pierce of each peanut butter and chocolate caramel fudge. The peanut butter fudge was still warm!!! We were so focused on eating we forgot to take pictures.

We love this location in Key West! Every time we are in town we make a stop. Ralph and the team are so nice and personable! Literally everything we’ve had is amazing including the ice cream! If you’re on Duval street, make sure you stop by and get some treats. So many options and many handmade on site! Thanks!

Billie was such a joy and I loved the chocolate. The fresh made warm peanut butter was my favorite. Love the team work and family like business of friends. Suly thanks for making the peanut butter Great treat in key west!

Ice cream & artisan chocolate shop with a huge range of options of ice cream flavours. Queue might be quite long during peak tourist seasons. There is very few seatings available and are all outdoor next to the dirty streets - which isn't the best when you are eating.

Loved the atmosphere and smell of sweet treats! Ice cream was amazing! Ask for Billy (from WV)!! He was extremely friendly and provided samples of ice cream and chocolate! We will go back to visit again!

My sister and I were walking by when we did a complete 180 because this shop smelled so good from the doorway. After, we went here every single day of the trip. Mint chocolate chip in a cake cone! Ice cream in every bite and it was amazing.

Can’t say enough good about this place! Everything was delicious and the employees are so nice and helpful. My favorite ice cream was the toasted coconut! The all American two berry pie was also delicious- both unique to this shop.

I stopped by here on my way to Key West. The place is clean with friendly employees and amazing food. I had the Churrasco Special (Steak sandwich with Churrasco sauce, grilled onions and fresh tomatoes on a toasted bun.) This sandwich was absolutely delicious!! I will eat here every time I drive through.

My Son and I were in the area and enjoyed the deserts here!! They were delicious. We tried the red velvet and the fruit tart!! They were excellent. The Cuban sandwich was very basic but good. Would definitely visit again if in the area!

Great spot for Cuban coffee and quick bites! Empanadas,pastries & sandwiches were delicious. Must stop by here when in Key Largo!

10/10 food, coffee and pastries are great! We ate supper breakfast and lunch here. Such good food

Authentic Cuban food, a must have breakfast every time we visit the keys. Truly a local’s spot, though tourist feel highly welcome! We will be back!

Best looking bakery ive been to here, the deserts are beautiful and the staff are super friendly and everything is super clean! Will definitely be back!

This place is very cute and has a huge selection of sweet and savory foods - visually it’s amazing and tastes even better. Highly recommend.

Ice cream is very good. They have a lot of variety of ice cream. I will definitely will be coming back.

Good ice cream with great portions!! Absolutely to share with a friend or loved one! A little disappointed I couldn’t try the frozen chocolate key lime pie as they were sold out… I suppose I’ll have to return! 🍨🇺🇸

Great ice cream!! Large selection of flavors and cones. My kids both said it was “the best ice cream ever”

Mr G’s son is a funny dude behind the counter. We had a very welcoming greeting as we came in. If you like to smile or even like being picked on all in fun then you will have a great experience. If that is the experience you want then stop in for a large selection of ice cream and a very informative, helpful staff. Big portions, great taste, reasonably priced ice cream ! BTW my group arrived shorty before closing and a couple of them had difficulty deciding on flavors. Dude behind the counter was not only accommodating but was great in assisting them in making their selections. They only except cash but there is an ATM located inside. Highly recommend!

Great service and let me try anything I wanted. Super nice guy and the-ice cream is Blue Bell. Mmmmmm

While visiting the Keys for the first time in 2018, my husband and I visited this ice cream shop. And we went multiple times during our 10-day stay. We've had Blue Bell Ice Cream in the past so knew it would be good. Mrs. G's did not disappoint! Naturally, we visited multiple times during our visit this year. The coconut ice cream is our favorite :) The employees are friendly and genuinely seem glad to welcome us to their store. This is a cash-only establishment. There are a few tables inside and one small bathroom. We have not eaten inside, as we prefer to enjoy ours while watching the sunset from spots around town. We tried other ice cream shops in the area and none compare to Mrs. G's. I hope they continue to serve Blue Bell Ice Cream and if we can get down to the Keys again in the future, this will be one of our must-do stops. One suggestion I'd make would be not to allow pets in the store. Perhaps they don't this year (2019). Last year, a family came in with a large dog. The dog obviously wanted attention and was approaching us. We did not know the other guests, nor their dog, and did not appreciate the dog getting in our way as we tried to accept our cones and pay for our purchase. I do realize many places allow pets; however, a small ice cream shop with a small space to look at the offerings, get your order and pay is not the place for animals.

Best coffee in the keys! I highly recommend this coffee/ice cream shop. Excellent customer service!! Very clean!! The espresso is top notch! Gino is very personable, funny, and makes a great cup of coffee! I’m so glad I stopped here! Definitely recommend!!!

Great outside seating, and decent treats. The grounds and store are in need of some loving care as windows, inside area and walkways are dirty and seemingly uncared for. Owners - do better.

Quick service. No line. Got a free small caramel malt shake for new app users but the cashier didn’t really know how to apply the coupon but it all worked out in the end. My snickers blizzard was nice with lots of snicker pieces.

Alway my go to for soft ice cream. Think this one in the keys was fast and cheapest I’ve been too. They were real busy and were banging out food and ice cream quick. Most you go to take their time and by time you get food it’s cold, and ice cream melted. .good quick service at this one .

Place needed cleaning. The blizzards were good but not mixed all the way. There was a lot of vanilla ice cream on the bottom. The young man in the register charged me for 3 blizzards instead of two in which I did not realize until after I had paid and the blizzard was already made. We go to this particular dairy Queen often and it hasn't improved no matter how many reviews.

Workers were very attentive and patient with clients. Place is getting a little out dated. Only gave a 4 on food because they had ran out of chocolate soft serve, the chocolate dip was too light and the blizzards were not mixed correctly.

Got 3 large blizzards, staff were very friendly and helpful. Haven't been to a dairy queen in years but I'm glad I went to this one. Definitely worth it after a long drive.

Jordan is the best server he makes the blizzards in a jiffy and is super nice

Out of towner here. What a fun experience. Was cool to watch them make the ice cream with nitrogen. Talked with the owner(?) who makes the batter for the waffle cones. Was complimenting her on the taste of it and she said she makes it in-house. Ice cream was cold and solid - just the way I think ice cream should be, not soft and melting. I come this area yearly and now I will be making sure to stop here again. I snapped some before and after pics. People who say its pricey - well, nitrogen is expensive. To me its worth it. $7 for a large ice cream with waffle.

I am pretty sure they forgot one of the ingredients when they made our vegan ice cream. We ordered four of them. They tasted like frozen milk with a hint of peanut butter with strawberry in them. There was no sweetness whatsoever. My family was incredibly disappointed was I. I would have said something, but I tried mine last and we were already out the door when I realized this.

Great idea to make ice cream this way. Depending on individual choice, ice cream might taste better or worse - I don't fully understand why people complain about their own choice. Service was ok, the spot looked a bit meaningless from the outside, the room insight is a bit too small, so overall marketing could possibly improve.

It was fun to watch them make the ice cream right in front of you. You can make any flavor that you want very very good.

Ice cream and service are impeccable. there are even a few games to play while you enjoy your ice cream like mini billiards, Jenga and Checkers. The owner or management could put a little more energy into the ambiance of the place, but the ice cream is a real treat.

Or girls enjoyed watching them freeze the cream with the liquid nitrogen. For four people to have a bowl of ice cream it cost us about $26. Was definitely worth the experience!

Place was great! Me and my sister loved it so much <3 will definitely come back! The one thing that gave it from a 5 to a 4 was that they were a little slow. Understaffed. Took about 15 minutes for my family of 4 to get our ice cream ready and made. It was an amazing experience to feel the nitrogen! It was so cold and cool. Also I ordered a small. They gave me a regular! I love this place.

Do not tip until you get your order. New owners are terrible! We have so many wonderful ice cream shops in Key West. This is not one of them.I always get the same thing. The grasshopper. It always had the graham cracker sprinkles in it. This time I was told it would be extra. When I got home, I did my research. Lots of photos and specific details regarding what is in the grasshopper. Including the graham cracker sprinkles. Seriously, if I wanted two scoops of mint chocolate chip ice cream, I could’ve just gone to the grocery store for half the price. Instead of arguing with a customer, just give them what they want. I took two bites of my ice cream and told the server to put it in the trash. I have no desire to go back here ever again. Hope you all are reading this and enjoyed my tip.

This is my absolute favorite ice cream shop in Key West. We go and get our blizzards from Timea. She is the best. Ice cream shops all over town but you can’t get DQ for service, good ice cream and great prices.

Beautiful location! This is the southernmost Dairy Queen, and they have fun things for kids to play with. All seating is outdoors and it is an ICE CREAM ONLY location. 🍦

I wrote special instructions for what the cake should say (& it had nothing to do w birthdays. It’s for a farewell). Yet, I received a birthday cake. Why offer the option for special instructions if they’re going to be ignored? Now I’m giving my friend a birthday cake vs a farewell cake

I wish they spend 30 seconds more to blend everything together for the smoothie as I still have chunks of ice in it … my husband god an ice cream with added brownie and chocolate and it was extremely sweet with cheap taste as synthetic! I won’t buy anything again from this store.

A stepback into time, family friendly, a must stop for everyone.

Ice cream is normal but the attention is the worst thing you will find in the keys of Florida. The lady who attends has a bad attitude and makes disliked facial gestures, if she doesn't want to work, she's better stay at home

We had ice cream from here four nights in a row! We don’t have much to compare it to because after our first visit, we were hooked and didn’t feel the need to try anywhere else. Our go-to combo was Mexican vanilla with Oreos and strawberries—absolutely delicious. The two ladies who helped us each night were incredibly kind and even shared some of the shop’s history with us, which made the experience even more special. We’d 100% recommend this spot, though to be fair, our recommendation is based on our overall love of ice cream rather than comparing it to other places in the Keys.

$20.99 for ONE small scoop of strawberry ice cream in a cup and a small vanilla milkshake is INSANE! This is taking advantage of people! They have no prices posted on their menu in store so you don’t know that when you get to the register, you will be paying a crazy price. Generally, there is an expectation of price that would seem fair and reasonable for things, but this is ridiculous. Never again. RESPONSE: of course we ate it as we did not plan to waste it after purchasing. And, nowhere did I say it tasted bad. I strictly said your prices are horrible and they are.

Delicious small batch ice cream in the heart of Key West. Tried the coconut agave and Kermit’s key lime. Both were really good, though the coconut agave was super trick and creamy. I appreciate that the key lime ice cream wasn’t too sweet.

We loved Wicked Lick so much, we went three days in a row while visiting Key West! The ice cream is fantastic—my girls couldn’t get enough of the one scoop with the waffle cone nacho chips (such a fun and tasty twist). The service made it even better—the ladies behind the counter were personal, friendly, and so warm every time we came in. It’s rare to find a spot that hits both the flavor and the experience this well. We’ll definitely be back next year!

I left the owner a message about the service but the actual ice cream, the dairy free VEGAN REEF DIVER with the Oreo cookies and the fresh strawberries and the berry sauce. Oh my God!!!! it was it was not enough 🤪😂 we wanted more!!! So much that me and my four year-old we were fighting for the last spoonful. I KID you not! It is absolutely delicious and worth every PENNY! I hope to see more of these around the US!!!! Kudos to you for making such a great vegan nut free, SOY FREE ice cream!

Incredibly disappointed in the quality & pricing of this “ice cream.” The texture was very icy, the flavor was lacking and it was $8 for a small! They have very basic flavors and you have to pay extra to add toppings, as nothing is mixed in. We tossed our $10 worth of ice cream (chocolate with crushed Oreos on top) and went to Dairy Queen. I’ll pay for quality ice cream, but this did not check any of the boxes unfortunately :(

Delicious ice cream worth it They have original homemade flavors, me and my boys had late night coffee ice cream with Oreos Heavenly delicious

This is one of the many food shops around town! They have rolled ice cream, ice cream, and normal ice cream. It's a little pricey and there are stores selling what they have for cheaper, so many just walk around before you go buy a $7 cookie haha not bad for taste though!

Delicious icecream with a wide variety of flavors to choose from. Most importantly, the people who run this place are very nice and gentle. Definitely five stars. ❤❤❤🌺

We had 1/2 lb chocolate chip cookie. It was good. Not too sweet but also had cake type feeling, I for sure like it that way but not sure of everyone looking for cookie would enjoy. For sure worth giving a try. According to the attendant their white chocolate with macadamia nut is one of the most popular one.

Ice cream was delicious and creamy! It was so much fun to watch her roll the ice cream and I believe it was reasonably priced.

A delicious place to stop! Their brownies are delicious and they were a nice snack on the cruise ride home.

We eat ice cream everywhere, all the time and travel a lot and this is the best ice cream we’ve ever had! A few of the flavors were more like a shaved Italian ice/sorbet-like texture but still creamy and delicious. So light and airy and refreshing, we LOVE IT!

The key lime, The Peanut Butter Cup, the cookie dough, and even the Papa Smurf flavor were all excellent and tasted delicious! Excellent ice cream and they all also have a creative blended flavors for braver eaters than me. 🤗🤔😁😀

Crew workers are nice and.. accommodating. We’ve visited this place 3 times. 2 out of those times they didn’t have any ice cream for one reason or another... they need better management across the board for equipment and stockage levels and restock orders.

I love this place. I don't usually eat ice cream, but I drink a lot of fruit smoothies. I usually make them myself in my Vita-Mix, but in Key West for a treat this is where I like to go. Smoothie Shuttle is good too, but they're a little confusing with all the additives and such; this is easy and quick and the people are very nice. And the smoothies are uber-delicious to my tastes! Occasionally when I exercise by riding my human-powered vehicles around the island I like to make this the end of the hard ride, and cool down with a creamy, satisfying fruit smoothie. As some have mentioned, the products are very sweet; if you don't care for that just ask them to use more tart fruit and less ice cream, they've always been very accommodating for me. Recommended.

My ice cream wasn't creamy and awesome, but broke my spoon when I tried to dig in and also had ice crystals in it. The chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream was practically vanilla with no cookie dough or chocolate chips. I was very disappointed but I am glad they have a military discount.

Just walked down there from our hotel and they only had 2 flavors. Was told they would make more the next day. It was 7pm and they don't close until 10pm, so it's not like we went in at the last minute. Went away buying nothing.

It's a good local ice cream parlor but not the best. The price is good but the quality is not exceptional but anyway it's Key West so everything is bit costly.

Brings new meaning to “ice” cream. Flavor was off as well as the texture. I would try one of the many other places down here.

Amazing caramel vanilla cupcake!! We went to several of the bakeries in key west, but this one was my favorite by far.