The 46 best desserts and snacks in Key West

If you’re in Key West, Blue Heaven absolutely lives up to its name — it’s a little slice of paradise on a plate! We went for Sunday lunch while on vacation, and even though the place was super busy (we waited about 1 hour and 20 minutes), it was totally worth the wait. The vibe is pure Key West — open-air, al fresco dining, colorful decor, chickens wandering around, and live music adding to the laid-back island feel. I ordered the Surf and Turf Benedict, which features Filet Mignon and Lobster — and wow, it was phenomenally good. Perfectly cooked, rich, and absolutely unique. My friends’ dishes were just as amazing: the BLT Benedict (where the “L” stands for Lobster) and a Shrimp Omelette that was loaded and flavorful. Of course, we couldn’t leave without trying their famous Key Lime Pie, and it did not disappoint. Tangy, creamy, and just the right amount of sweet — easily one of the best I’ve ever had. Whether you’re a foodie or just want the quintessential Key West experience, Blue Heaven is a must-visit. I’d recommend it to anyone heading to the island — just go early, be patient, and enjoy the tropical atmosphere while you wait.

As always a fun and amazing place! Breakfast was amazing on a Saturday! My crew and I got there nice and early just a little after open and walked right in. Certainly filled shortly after. Still all good because they open the bar across the street to get your vitamin c on. Most of us got the Lobster grits and BLT Benedicts which were delicious! Service was amazing!

Numerous recommendations and hype for Blue Heaven. Did it live up to my expectations? Absolutely! We arrived at 11 am and had a 15 minute wait. We had our 2 pups with us and had a bowl of water immediately provided to them. If your dog has issues with roosters/chickens, it may be a challenge but worked out well for us. Let’s just say our plates were returned empty and no take out boxes. I had a chicken salad sandwich with a side of potatoes (some of the best I have had), some fruit and a limeade. My wife had shrimp and grits, banana bread and some fruit. And to finish it off, some key lime pie, of course. Staff were great and watched the hostess skillfully handle an obnoxious whiner. Will definitely eat here again and recommend to friends and family.

Wonferful afternoon at Blue Heaven! Christy at the bar was friendly and very welcoming.. She pours the perfect cocktail!! After a short wait we were taken to our table. The garden and fresh air were just what we needed after our short flight from.Orlando. Jake presented us with menus and promptly provided the daily specials. Our food was really delicious and fresh. We ordered the daily special and the lobster Benedict. The flavors are unmatched anywhere in the Keys. We enjoyed bloody Mary cocktails while the band, Tequila Sunrise entertained. Our service was flawless. The roosters provided the Key West charm.we have come accustomed to over the past 20 years. We will return.

This is a very unique, Key West-esq place that is a lot of fun to be at. Unique foods, decor, and facility as well as great people. We had and awesome breakfast and still topped it off with a slice of their amazing Key Lime Pie. As with any place on the island, parking is very limited, so be prepared to walk a bit to get there if you're driving.

In a word, stellar. There was a one hour wait for a table for 2, but the hostess suggested if we wanted we could sit a the inside bar (first come first served). We took her suggestion and were able to sit down immediately. The bartender (Darla) greeted us quickly with menus and waters and was super friendly. I got the BLT (bacon, lobster, tomato) Benedict and my husband got the breakfast sandwich with bacon and a single pancake. The Benedict was one of the best I've ever had. Sweet lobster, savory bacon, and acidic fresh tomatoes with a perfectly poached egg and rich, creamy Hollandaise sauce. The breakfast sandwich used the same amazing bacon with a fried egg and incredible sharp white cheddar cheese that still managed to be creamy. The pancake was also very good and was served with real maple syrup. Overall an excellent breakfast.

10/10 - Grace was an amazing host, attentive, professional and funny. Had an amazing breakfast experience. Shrimp and grits and rooster special were delicious. Recommend trying the spicy sausage! The ambiance feels like your in the jungle, and the roosters/chickens running around are entertaining.

What a cute place!! Service was great! Staff super friendly and kind. Atmosphere felt like a place that I already know and loved. The pastries were sooo good!

OMG!!! I’ve been here 13 years and I’ve never gone here… I have been missing out! I’m on a mission to try new things and decided to pop in on this cute little place. I ended up ordering an Italian sandwich. Let me tell you it was divine. If you’re ever in town go there I ordered dessert ( the OMG Brownie) as well and it was awesome. I think I found a new favorite spot.

This bakery had (in my opinion) the best Key Lime pie on the island. I tried enough during our vacation to know! I also bought their peach cobbler Danish. OMG! Absolute heaven. Highly recommend stopping by and checking out their goodies.

Nice local grab and go place. Danishes are delicious, curry chicken sandwich was a little dry but great flavor. Which they would matchstick cut the apples to be easier to eat. Breakfast burrito best protein option, but felt like a lot of tortilla to filling ratio. Good coffee too. Only a bench outside, so recommend taking it Togo. Would return and try the 🥐, guava pastry was super flake, wish it was bigger and had cream cheese.

Freshly made bakery items with huge breakfast sandwiches and strong coffee. The staff/ owners were lovely. I knocked over a drink, they were so sweet to clean it up, and offered to replace it. The key lime pie was a little more tart than others, as I was on a mission to try as many version of local pies as possible. We enjoyed our visit. Try walking to the shop if possible since parking is a struggle, but is worth the challenge.

Small, take out bakery. HIGHLY recommend the chicken wrap. It was some of the best food we had on the island! Staff was friendly and the service was quick.

As soon as the door opened the heavenly smell of freshly baked bread assaulted my senses! Fantastic case of bakery goodies and great sandwiches to go using their baked bread. Coffee was good as well. Value is definitely 👍. The rooster and hen we fed was an unexpected pleasure😊

We ordered a key lime pie so everyone in our group could try it. The cashiers we're very nice to give us small plates, napkins, and forks. We sat in the store and ate our pie in a cool environment. Key Lime pie isn't for everyone. Its tart and rich and the "lime" comes through. Many of us enjoyed a slice and others tried a bite and that's all they could do. To each his own. This small bakery also has a small attached gift shop with many great options.

Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West is a great stop for anyone wanting to try the city’s signature dessert. The pies are creamy, tangy, and have that perfect balance of sweetness with the tart lime flavor. They also offer other treats and products to take home, making it a nice spot for both tasting and shopping. The atmosphere is casual, and the staff is friendly, which adds to the experience. Definitely worth a visit if you’re exploring Key West and want to enjoy an authentic slice of key lime pie.

I had high expectations for this iconic Key West spot, especially for my first Key Lime Pie experience. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to the hype. The Key Lime Pie was nothing special—I was expecting something fresher and more vibrant. The Coconut Cream Pie was even more disappointing. It was mostly whipped cream, with only a sprinkle of coconut on top. Honestly, I could’ve found a similar slice at a grocery store for half the price. Overall, the food just didn’t deliver. I was hoping for something memorable, but it fell short.

Is this the original? There's some debate. But! It is fantastic. I loved their coconut key lime pie. I will be craving it for years to come. The shop offers all kinds of key lime treats if pie isn’t your thing. I wish there was more seating, but hey, that's a really small complaint.

Key Lime pie...ehh ok...Mattheessen's blows this place apart... Coffee at 9am had to be made..none "ready"...not tasty... Over $7...bad.. Some cute trinkets..marked $5.95 charged $6.19 plus tax for a magnet... Def tourist trap...no thanks..🐓 Cute building, woman was nice.

A must try Keys Lime Pie!!! 🥧 This version is delicious. The best I've tried so far. A balanced amount of sugar and the pleasant sour lime taste. Staff is nice and prices are average. The bakery sells many unthinkable products with Key Lime Pie flavor. 🤔 For the joy of tourists!!! Two tables and a couple of benches are the only options for those who want to enjoy tasting the pie seated on the spot hoping these aren't already busy. 🔝

If you love all things key lime, this is your spot! Their pie was very good, and they had all sorts of other treats and goodies to take home. Great little stop.

Lots of interesting dishes especially if you are vegan. I only had the opportunity to try the vegan key lime pie, as the night we planned to have dinner here it was pouring rain. The key lime was ok - I’ve had better dairy free pie before. It wasn’t creamy enough -very solid. And no gluten free crust which would have made a big difference. The service was wonderful, very friendly. The inside was beautifully decorated. But as in most key west restaurants, no a/c, at least not turned on. It’s often so hot in the key west restaurants. I would recommend though. Wish I could have tried more things!

If you’re looking for a delicious, plant-based meal in Key West, The Café is a must. We ordered the spring rolls, stir-fry noodles, veggie pizza, and carrot cake (all vegetarian/vegan-friendly), and every dish was a winner. Spring Rolls: Crisp, golden, and not at all greasy—packed with fresh vegetables and herbs. The dipping sauce was bright and balanced, adding just the right tang. Stir-Fry Noodles: Perfectly cooked noodles with great bite, tossed in a savory, well-balanced sauce. The vegetables stayed vibrant and crisp—every forkful had flavor and texture. Veggie Pizza: Generously topped and thoughtfully composed. The crust was crisp outside, tender inside, and held up beautifully under the toppings—fresh and bright, not heavy. Carrot Cake: The star of the night. Moist and warmly spiced, with silky frosting that wasn’t overly sweet. A slow-savor dessert. Service: A special shout-out to Amanda, who was outstanding from start to finish. She listened carefully to our dietary preferences, clarified ingredients, and guided us to exactly what we’d love. Attentive without hovering—spot on. Kudos to the Chef: The taste across the board was awesome. You can feel the chef’s touch in the details—clean, balanced flavors; consistent seasoning; perfect textures (that wok-kissed noodle finish, those ultra-crisp rolls, and the beautifully spiced cake). Compliments to the kitchen team for executing everything so well. Ambience & Overall: Relaxed, welcoming, and unpretentious—ideal for a casual dinner that still feels special. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the menu offers plenty of meat-free variety without sacrificing flavor or creativity. Bottom line: Fantastic plant-based options (don’t miss the spring rolls and carrot cake), stellar service from Amanda, and chef-driven flavors that shine. We’ll be back—and we’ll be asking for Amanda again.

Love love love this place ! Finding a place with a ton of vegetarian options was a bliss !Everything we had was amazing ! Spring rolls - definitely try it ! It’s tastes much better than any other place The healthy chickpea and bean salad with tahini and blackened tofu on side was delicious ! Tofu was so soft and just melted in mouth . Tried Kombucha - had a different taste ! Stir fry flat rice noodles in szechaun gravy with tofu - it was a little bland with not much spice or flavor . Tofu wings - it was ok ok ! Chocolate chip vegan cake was kinda chewy and heavy .. but couldn’t resist and just ate all !

Vegan options! WOW the food is really tasty. They have lots of vegan, vegetarian and gluten free options including desserts! We went for lunch. I had the "Chicken" salad sandwich with the bean salad - both were delicious! My husband had the Ceasar Kale salad which was a generous portion. I got the Fresh limeade (also very good). I saw they have breakfast/brunch options too so will definitely be back!

We came by a chance and experience was fantastic. Wand was very kind and also Samantha very attentive to details. Good food and pescatarian and vegetarian food with great flavors. Cocktails were delicious. Highly recommended

Great choice for vegetarians and vegans! Delicious food that was very filling. My entire family was able to eat without having to worry about the ingredients! We had the quesadilla with vegan cheese and sour cream (super rare for restaurants to offer vegan options like that!), the grande burrito, BBQ un-wing dings (super crispy), and more. Amazing service as well, was checked on plenty but not intruded! Would highly recommend!

Delicious vegetarian spot in Key West! Stopped by The Café and loved everything we ordered — the polenta sticks were perfectly crispy, the spinach quesadillas were flavorful and satisfying, and the truffle fries were absolutely addictive. Great atmosphere and friendly service, too. Highly recommend if you’re looking for tasty vegetarian options in Key West!

Definitely on the pricey side for donuts but that comes with the benefit of being high quality. They're not overwhelmingly sweet. Outside almost has a light crust making for a great bite into the soft interior. Pictured is the key lime & Boston creme, filled with plenty of filling! This order cost me $10.30

The donuts, coffee and staff were great! This place has so much potential — if the ambiance matched the food, it could easily be packed with people who would stay longer and order more. Unfortunately, the smell of cleaning products was so strong that it almost smelled dirty, making it hard to stay and eat. There were also lots of extra donut boxes lining the walls, which made the space feel more like a storage unit than a donut shop.

4 stars just because of price... I realize everything in the Keys is expensive, but almost $5 a donut was a little steep for me, even as a guy who's favorite sweet is donuts. We were on vacation so we had to sample a half dozen, and the flavors, taste and size were 5 star. The key lime was delicious and I loved the seasonal pumpkin spice. As well as a bakery it's also a very cute coffee shop with a decent amount of inside seating. It's just a block between Truman's Annex and Duval street, so a great location for anyone staying at that end of the island. As the only shop I could find doing traditional donuts, and given how tasty they were, I'd justify the price again if I ever make it back to the keys.

Yes! I really appreciate great donuts. These were exceptional. Had the jelly of the week (guava) and a buttermilk glazed. I want to try them all!! In an atmosphere where heat and humidity are constantly changing, I appreciate the craft of working with dough to bring some happiness to people each day. These guys are brilliant. 100% would go back.

Super friendly fun place to go. Nothing like a great donut to start the day. Excellent flavors and wonderful smells highlights the adventure here. I love a perfect glazed donut not to sweet but fresh. They hit the nail on the head!!

Great donuts!! Get there early if there’s a specific kind you want because they do sell out. We tried the glazed and Cuban coffee and loved both! Freshly baked every day! Definitely worth checking out.

Glazed Donuts is a delightful spot in Key West with a creative, welcoming atmosphere and consistently high-quality selections. The space features fun robot-themed wall art, a U.S. map of donut shops, and an informative board describing their coffee roasting process and menu... small details that really add to the experience. One of my favorite features is the front window where you can watch the kitchen in action. It’s clear a lot of care goes into every batch. I always pick up a lemon poppy seed roll while also trying something new. The coffee is also good, with a self-serve area for customization. There’s seating inside, including a few children’s books along the wall, making it comfortable for a quick breakfast or a relaxed start to the day. The bathroom is clean, and the shop itself is well-maintained. I usually visit early, and by the time I leave, there’s often a line forming out the door, and indication of how good the donuts are. The staff are friendly and provide excellent service. A great stop for locals and visitors alike.

Such a charming little shop! I finally got to try the famous Key Lime Pie here after doing a lot of research, it was my very first time having one in Key West. The pie was incredibly fresh, soft, and so delicious that it practically melted in my mouth. I loved it so much that I finished the whole thing in just four minutes!

Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop on Elizabeth Street is a fantastic stop in Key West. The key lime pie is delicious and refreshing, and they also have unique treats like lemon cookies that are worth trying. What makes it even better is the variety of samples available so you can taste before you buy. They even had a little snack for our dog, which was such a nice touch. A fun and welcoming spot to enjoy local flavors.

I know this place is always one of the top rated Key Lime pies in Key West. It ended up being my second favorite (tried 5 during the week). The pie was thicker (less creamy) than the others, but had a really nice lime flavor. I thought the piece was small, and while the shop had a lot of different key lime snacks and souvenirs, it felt a little over commercialized with just grabbing a pre-cut piece from a refrigerated case and checking out at a counter. It wasn't busy when we were there, but you could imagine days with large lines waiting to grab their piece of pie and go find a seat in the dining area. As I mentioned, the shop was cute, and there was a large indoor/outdoor seating area for when it's busy.

I stopped by Kermit’s Key Lime Shop and I have to say, everything about it was amazing. The key lime pie cheesecake was incredibly tasty, rich, creamy, and full of that perfect tangy sweet key lime flavor. Honestly, it was one of the best desserts I have ever had. I also tried the classic key lime pie, and it was just as good, smooth, refreshing, and not overly sweet. You can tell they really know what they are doing. The shop itself is cute and full of charm, and the people working there were very kind and welcoming. Everyone had a smile and made you feel at home. It is one of those places that feels local and authentic, not touristy at all. If you are in Key West, Kermit’s is a must visit whether you are a dessert lover or just curious about why key lime pie is such a big deal. You will walk away happy, maybe even with a few extra slices to take home.

This place is charmingly decorated and welcoming with yummy Key Lime delights inside. I never leave the Keys without a frozen Kermit’s Key Lime Pie for home and send these to clients around the country. Bring your own cooler or you’ll have to pay for a frozen bag. Tried their Key Lime Taffy samples for the first time and ended up buying two bags because they were so yummy. Took one star off because only after, did I read that they’re made with corn syrup and palm oil and I avoid those ingredients for obvious reasons.

This was definitely one of the best key lime pie I've tried out of all the keys, but I will say, it's better in the store than buying a whole pie and taking it home. The crust gets almost soggy when its frozen. The prices for everything were pretty reasonable, expect for the pie. Way overpriced, especially for soggy crust. Just need some work on how to keep the crust and it would be worth it because the filling is delicious.

Highly recommend and not just for the pie! Lots of Key Lime treats! Cookies, nuts, crackers, jelly beans... with free samples. It's hard to choose a favorite Key Lime Pie but theirs with coconut is mine :)

What a hidden gem! This rustic, slightly divey spot has so much charm and character. The food portions are huge and absolutely delicious — every bite felt homemade with love. And the key lime pie? Hands down the best I have ever tasted — creamy, tangy, and unforgettable. Definitely a must-visit!

Our first stop in Key West was Pepe's Cafe. We had chosen our destination well in advance... and we weren't disappointed. The service was very friendly and professional. We were served delicious coffee and a great American-style breakfast. The place itself has a unique atmosphere and a strong sense of time, as evidenced by the photos of its guests hanging around it... including Ernest Hemingway. It's worth a visit for a coffee and a trip back in time.

This is an iconic place as this is the oldest restaurant in key west. However, it is not for me. The sandwiches werent as tasty and I even ordered the special of the day. I think what affected my rating too is because I had set a very high expectation on this place.

If you look at this place from a certain angle, while trying to avoid the Gulf Coast sun from blinding you, it almost looks like it is closed. It wasn't until we got really close to it that we realized that it was fully functional. As we got closer, a friendly voice welcomed us in and directed us to the bar. Once we got there, Katie Mae simply knocked our socks off with her sense of humor, conversation, and knowledge of the island. Of course we ordered the $1.75 oysters and my friend ordered what's considered the best Mojito in town. My beers were cold and frequent. We truly enjoyed our two visits to Pepe's during our Key West adventure.

Out of the 6 dinners we had in KW, Pepes was our clear favorite. Unpretentious, friendly, quick, fresh and fish so tasty we're still talking about it. We sat at one of the hightops in the bar area. Luke ran the section and we followed all of his great recommendations; pepes style snapper and blackened snapper with a slab of keylime pie that was supposed to be eaten in the morning. The pie didnt survive the short walk back to the hotel. Its with good reason this place has been around longer than any restaurant in Key West. EAT HERE!

A Key West institution! They will cook your catch here, so we brought lobsters freshly caught that morning and enjoyed them with 2 sides, cocktails, a round of delicious appetizers, and key lime pie for dessert. Amazing.

The key lime pie here was my husbands favorite in Key West. The rest of the food was pretty good. Convenient location after a dolphin and snorkeling trip.

Cool atmosphere with a lot of character and Cuban vibes. The outdoor seating area is spacious and has a nice setup. The food was okay — not the best I’ve had, but decent. The fried whole fish looked impressive, but the flavor was average. Dessert was also just okay. The biggest issue was the service — it took a long time to get our food, which was frustrating. Overall, worth checking out for the ambiance, but be prepared to wait.

What a fun place!! Great place to enjoy live Cuban music and enjoy the vibe while watching the sunset and eating great apetizers! The Scallops are a must as they are seasoned well with a butter sauce. Planting chips are good and add to the atmosphere. The Shrimp were on a another level and some of the best we had in Key west! Go for the atmosphere and enjoy the food while listening to some great Latin music

Get the #80. You wont be disappointed! My husband and I always share this one when in town. Delicious variety and love the atmosphere! The location is perfect to end your evening with the Mallery square sunset! Beautiful!

At first I was skeptical because of the previous ratings BUT we ordered the # 69 and the relleno appetizer with our mojitos and let me tell you it was delicious. The pork was tender and marinated just right. The mojitos were strong and minty. The server was super friendly and helpful! The ambiance was very authentic inside the restaurant and out.

Very busy place! But thankfully, we got seated in no time! Service was fast ...! You get free cuban bread as a starter. Dipping sauce was good. I liked the spicy one better. Entree was of generous servings! The drinks i loved! Not too much alcohol added ... it was just a perfect amount so I have enjoyed both my food and my drink!

The food it's good. The staff friendly. Plenty seafood and Cuban in The menu. Only bad thing it's smokers around outside sitting dinner area.

The most terrible experience I’ve ever had at a restaurant. Our server Jose was the most disrespectful server I’ve ever encountered. First he took the order for appetizers and after that took forever to come back and get our order for the meal, by the time he came back he had to tells us that they were out of white rice and arroz Moro which is what we planned to order. We didn’t mind and made our order and actually had to go one by one saying what we wanted and substituting the sides for fries. When the food finally arrived it was completely wrong. Basically all the sides were supposed to be fries and 2 of the orders had yellow rice and black beans, which we never would have ordered together and we mentioned that to our server while he took the order. The worst part is that we ordered 3 churrascos and only got one. The server Jose realized the mistake and started blaming us very rudely, saying we should have been paying more attention while ordering which was extremely disrespectful and rude. He started fighting back and forth on how it was not his fault the order was wrong when it was him who should have realized that we were six at the table and he only had 4 orders. After that he never came back to our table until we went up to him to get the bill because all we wanted was to leave. Everybody saw the way he spoke to us because he was very loud, rude and condescending and no manager or anyone intervened. I included pictures of the state of our table when we left. The plates from the appetizers were never picked up and we ordered multiple mojitos and the empty glasses were all there. Also the food was not good at all the black beans we never ordered were grey and and watery. We thought it was a sauce at first. Overall terrible experience, would not recommend and will not be going ever again.

Sarabeth’s has a secret weapon! Is it their amazing Lobster Spinach Omelette, possibly. Is it their delicious Lemon Ricotta Pancakes or the Crab Avocado Bacon Benedict platter? Perhaps it could be the to die for Strawberry shortcake that will make your mouth water. The actual secret weapon is their spectacular customer service, BINGO! Our server for our breakfast today was “Brad.” Brad welcomed us like we were family as soon as we walked in the door. We were shown the menus for both food and beverages, and while we waited fresh, ice cold water was served. Brad inquired if anyone had dietary restrictions or needed to be aware of any allergies. Brad gave us a run down on the specials, and particularly awesome menu items. We truly were in absolute heaven by his professionalism, friendliness and hospitality. The entire staff was impressive. In addition their restrooms were clean, and fully stocked. The restaurant is nestled into a gorgeous corner lot, with ample street parking as well as scooter/bike availability. If you need a lovely, quiet and relaxing breakfast, lunch or dinner please visit Sarabeth’s Key West. (P.S. ask to be seated in Brad section, you’re welcome). Enjoy!

we had a fantastic experience at sarabeth's on simonton street. the atmosphere is very casual, the staff is very friendly, welcoming and professional and the food was perfect, from apps to entrees to dessert. arriving after dark, the iphone pix don't do this stuff justice. just try it yourself, you'll love it.

Amazing food and service once again! I won't come to The Keys without eating brunch here! The mimosas are soooo good! The eggs Benedict are killer! Just pick one, cuz they're all amazing. The atmosphere is so great! Don't miss the opportunity to have brunch here! We had three people recommend other places but we bypassed them to come here!

What amazing food! Came here for the Keylime pie, but really enjoyed the lobster BLT on whole grain bread. Large portion extremely tasty and amazing. The potions are big so you can two can easily share this . And the fries are very good! Better than most fries I’ve had

There’s nothing special. It’s very overpriced and the prices aren’t listened or mentioned to you for a reason which is really annoying considering their bottles of water are priced at $13 What easily would have cost us $25-$30 at any other restaurant in town, costed us $135 lol Also as someone who’s from Louisiana…your shrimp and grits are more like a breakfast bowl. I had a spoonful of grits, two shrimps, on top a mixture of sausage and idk what else they added in that bowl but it wasn’t no Shrimp and Grits plz don’t insult us like that again.

One word, AMAZING!! Not only is the food amazing but the customer service is out of this world!! My husband and I loved the shrimp and grits which I think was a special. My daughters loved the pancakes and French toast. The mimosas were amazing as well. I would start name dropping but the staff are ALL awesome with energetic positive attitudes. The service was so great we came back a second time and we were yet again met with those energetic positive attitudes. Do yourself a favor and stop by this awesome establishment!

Go for the best tomato soup I’ve ever had and the best burger in Key West.. I also had a beautiful salad with fresh greens and a subtle, delicious dressing. This is a charming restaurant in a restored older house. We sat outside on the generous porch, and it was lovely. We arrived close to end of the lunch shift, so they were out of some items, and service was still excellent. We’ll definitely go back for brunch and/or dinner next time we’re there.

Having breakfast at La Grignote is a great idea. It’s usually busy, and you may need to wait 10–15 minutes for a table, but you can grab a coffee while waiting. We ordered the Salmon Eggs Benedict with extra avocado and it was delicious. The latte was also great—creamy and smooth. The food came out quickly. Definitely recommend!

La Grignote – A Breakfast Gem in Key West If you're searching for the best breakfast in Key West, look no further than La Grignote. This charming bakery and café delivers an unforgettable morning experience that blends authenticity, quality, and warmth. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of freshly baked goods sets the tone. The sourdough bread is truly exceptional—crusty on the outside, perfectly soft on the inside. It’s clear that craftsmanship and care go into every loaf. The menu offers a delightful range of options, from classic pastries to hearty breakfast plates, all made with fresh ingredients and a touch of elegance. The coffee is strong and smooth, complementing the food beautifully. Service is friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere La Grignote is highly recommended—a must-visit for anyone who appreciates great food and genuine coffee.

Walking in you immediately understand that everything done there is done properly, and with care. That sounds funny talking about food, but baked goods are topped perfectly, bread is baked to perfection and while the restaurant was definitely busy, the staff is working tirelessly to turn tables over, to get new customers seated. Not just the “staff”, the OWNER! I told him that if the owner is willing to bus his own tables, that is a formula for success, especially in a place like Key West. Now for the food! Just as I saw in when I walked in, everything that arrived on our plates was fresh and delicious. My kids raved about the bacon, and it is served as half sized. Mini bacon strips! Who knew a tiny little change would be such a hit? The eggs Benedict is light and tangy and the waffle comes with a giant dollop of whipped cream. The tables are situated so that even with the small space, you don’t feel cramped. Prices were not ridiculous, but the food and service would have been worth the price, even if they were. Upper area of Duval is a nice change of pace from the downtown vibes.

Very tasty café! We got a Belgian waffle with fresh fruit, the French toast, an almond croissant, and an iced mocha. The only thing I wasn't thrilled with was the iced mocha, but, even then, it was fine. No complaints! HIGHLY recommend the waffle - it was our favorite

La Grignote is a simple and cozy café in Key West, with a laid-back, beach-style vibe, wooden tables, colorful dishes, and a relaxed atmosphere. The highlight was definitely the service: all the staff were super friendly and attentive from start to finish. I chose to sit outside, which was very pleasant. Inside, there's a big display case with lots of tempting sweets, croissants, and other baked goods. I ordered a Croque Madame with 2 poached eggs on top. The portion was huge, and it ended up being too heavy for breakfast. It had a lot of béchamel sauce, which made the flavor kind of repetitive and overwhelming. Wasn't that good to be honest and I couldn't finish it. It came with a small bowl of fruit on the side. My boyfriend ordered a croissant with egg and bacon, and that was excellent! The pastry was light, flaky, and crispy on the outside. The only downside was the sausage that came on the side: fried and very greasy. Overall, it was a good experience. The food had its ups and downs, so it's worth choosing your dish carefully, but the great service and welcoming, no-frills environment made up for it. I give it 4 stars.

We got breakfast on a Sunday morning, there. We park ou bicycles literally next to us, and enjoyed our food. It is a small place, with inside, balcony, and covered patio, seating options. Absolutely great service, creative food suggestions. Very influencing and friendly decoration of the space. I got the orange juice and my girl got the strawberry lemonade, both were surprisingly awesome!

This place was so amazing for breakfast! The Belgian waffle and Tartine were so beautiful plated and tasted great. The porch/bar road side seating was great for a breeze and people watching. Definitely a must try when visiting.

We had ordered Thai Basil Chicken Fried Rice, Chicken dumplings, Spring roll and Thai Basil Tofu fried rice. Food was good, dumplings were a bit dry, could have been better. But fried rice was flavorful and I would recommend to eat along with one spicy side they give.

The food was soo good, the views, the service and overall i can’t wait to be back! The food had a lot of flavor, the desserts were just right in sweetness and they have many options, i do recommend!!

Great service! It was hot and muggy so we ate inside. Outside they only had one fan not worth the view of the marina. I got the shrimp pad Thai no spice. It was very sweet and the cabbage wasn’t cooked into the food. It was raw and on the side. The spring rolls were delicious & I ordered the peanut sauce to go with it. Husband ordered chicken fried rice; he said it was fine. We won’t be returning not with the $61 ticket price. They charged us $4 for a bottled water as well.

We love this place! Jocelyn, the downstairs bartender, took very good care of us and even drew adorable customized Pomeranian/mermaids on our to-go boxes. Big bonus they are dog friendly!

The food was fantastic, and the atmosphere was great! Plus, the customer service was truly commendable.

Amazing food and service. Brought our fresh caught Mahi here after a charter. Highly recommend.

I can say this restaurants is (was) one of my favorites in Key West because of the really good food, this Saturday we came for lunch and the server not even said hello. The table was dirty, sticky and when I asked to clean it she didn’t like it. The food was really good as always, but she never came back to ask us if we would like a dessert or something else she just came with the bill. We paid and said good bye forever to one of our favorites restaurants because we are not coming back.

Stopped by for some key lime pie and a cookie. Lots of sweets to choose from! The staff was friendly and there was line inside to wait a few minutes before I could get my sweet fix. Well worth the wait!

We went to 3 ice cream shops in Key West and we can say this is the best!!! Cookie selection was great too and the size of each cookie was huge! ❤️ wish we knew this place sooner ❤️amazing staff too! Drop by and support them!

Mattheessen’s has their own spin on Key West key lime pie, with a fairly thick hand made graham cracker crust, and whipped cream by request. I like a thicker crust, so I enjoyed the flavor fusion of crunch with the creamy smooth tart lime flavor. This place is made for tourists, much like Kermit’s, though has more general dessert options including giant cookies, fudge, and ice cream. Sure to find something sweet for everyone’s taste in the family!

We were walking along Duvall and my daughters noticed these cookies in the window. Wound up getting the chocolate chip macadamia nut. Soooo good!! They gave me a small piece and I wound up eating half of it. LOL! Highly recommended stop!

Key lime pie was good, but ice cream is even better, according to my son, and he loves ice cream. He said it was the best ice cream he had ever eaten. I dont do ice cream, so I dont know. Whether you try pie or ice cream, you won't be disappointed.

This place is amazing. Got a cookie myself and two other people in my group got a key lime pie on a stick and key lime ice cream. Overall really positive. The cookie was great and really flavorful (Peanut butter and chocolate fudge). I was told that the both key lime pie items were pretty good. Overall a really cool place. Definitely worth it. Only reasons it isn’t 5 stars is because it was pretty pricy and there was a lot of sugar in the cookie. Kinda like a crumble cookie but fresher, better flavors, and felt like a little less sugary and buttery.

Peanut butter fudge was a 10/10! Huge cookies & great coffee!

It was a great experience. Desserts were delicious. My only recommendation is the following : we wanted to try a few things, but we didn't realize how rich and large the desserts were. I wished the waitress would have been upfront with us about the size desserts and the give us a little heads up about the amount we ordered. Otherwise no complaints at all. Very fun. The missionary dessert was amazing!!!

A tasteful, exciting and sensuous experience. I was so glad my friend recommended this. The drinks are unique and delicious. I just wish I had more room in my stomach for the desserts or if there was a variety of sampler plates one could have I wanted to try so many more things, but The ample portions of what I did choose tapped me out

So amazing!! The staff was so friendly and helpful with choices. The drink where amazing. The dessert were so good. Cheesecake was creamy. Carrot cake with so good. And the chocolate cake to die for. My husband is not a dessert guy but the caramel on rim he couldn't stop talking about. I highly recommend.

Several people told us how great this place was and that we should go here so we did. The vibe was fun! It’s dark and cozy and intimate and the menu reads like a smutty novel. Unfortunately, the desserts were not it for me. They were fine, but not mind blowing or anything. We got the four-gasm sampler and everything was just very mid, nothing really stood out. If that’s better than sex, you might be doing it wrong. That being said, if you’re looking for a fun and sexy vibe it might be worth a stop, just don’t expect mind blowing dessert

Love this place! I make it a point to come every trip! The desserts and the drinks are amazing! Make sure to have a reservation. Sometimes it can be very busy.

I have been dying to come on our last couple visits to the Keys. I’m so glad we made a reservation and went. It gives you the atmosphere you expect…dark, moody and full of desire…for dessert. We tried the Virgin Kiss, Choco Milk, the Fourgasm and the Cookie Nookie. We will be coming back to try some other options. The Red Velvet Cheesecake threw me for a loop and may be my favorite, unexpectedly.

This is definitely a must try experience while in the Keys. We made a reservation but ended up coming an hour early and they quickly accommodated us. The inside is very dark and romantic, decorated with candles and chandeliers. Their music selection is perfect too. Our server was great in explaining the menu and making recommendations for us. We ordered an espresso martini and an Irish cream cocktail for our drinks which were delicious. We got the sampler with 4 different desserts on it. They included a candle with “happy honeymoon” on the plate which was a nice touch. The desserts were good, not great, which is why I only gave 4 stars. Overall I do recommend checking this spot out just for the experience!

AB Lobster in Key West is a must-visit for both the food and the setting. The view while dining is absolutely incredible—breathtaking scenery that makes the whole experience unforgettable. The food was excellent—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. The dessert was delicious and a sweet finish to the meal. The drinks, however, were a bit of a letdown compared to everything else, especially given how high-quality the food was. Still, the overall experience was wonderful. Between the fantastic seafood and one of the best views in Key West, I’d happily return to AB Lobster for the food and scenery alone.

Delightful experience dining at A&B Lobster House in Key West this week. Don’t be fooled by the low rating, dragged down by odd reviews! Beautiful location overlooking the marina in the Key West bight. Pavel was our waiter, did a fantastic job, helped us navigate the menu. Attentive but not intrusive! Dinner was excellent, cocktails followed by Pinot Grigio, grilled scallop with caviar, crab cakes, and triple-tail catch of the day, rare menu item … all delicious! Great location, fine dining! Ambiance awesome. Highly recommend!

Absolutely phenomenal! We had the absolute BEST time eating here during our family vacation. We started with the Oysters, which were so delicious. We each got a mixture of food and tried little bits of each, between the Tuna Steak, Alaskan King Crab Legs, Surf & Turf, and more.... Every single dish was perfectly cooked and plated. The staff was also just as pleasant as the food and are very attentive as well. Im also obsessed with the old-school type bar/bathroom in this place as well. Its a Key West GEM! We can not wait to come back!

Three of us ate outside on a Sunday night in early November. It was an amazing dining experience. The menu is extensive and the food is delicious. The shrimp cocktail was one of the best we’ve had and the pear salad was wonderful. The entrees were incredible. Caribbean lobster tail, seared tuna and red shrimp and scallops with fettuccine. The Key lime sorbet for dessert was very nice. Our server Casey was terrific. Super accommodating of all our requests. This is fine dining at its best. Amazing food, superb service and a great atmosphere. We eat here whenever we vacation in the area and definitely recommend this restaurant.

I had an amazing dining experience here. I ordered the filet mignon and a truffle risotto, and both were absolutely delicious — perfectly cooked and beautifully presented. The meal started with warm bread and butter shaped with the restaurant’s initials, such a thoughtful detail. We sat in the outdoor seating area, which was lovely and made the evening even more enjoyable. I also tried the Espresso Martini, which was excellent and tasted like a coffee dessert. Highly recommend!

So make a reservation like a week before. That’s key to get in here and get sat. We had an great server who looked exactly like Julia Roberts. She was amazing!! We sat on the balcony over looking the marina, where they were feeding the huge tarpons. For the appetizer we had a king crab, crab cake. Holy moly was that packed with crab. We had some cocktails with the appetizer. Tito’s n soda and my girl had a mojito. Both were bangin. The main courses were the surf n turf awesome! My girl had a fat spiny lobster tail! Both were great. Dinner was pricey, $280 with a tip but it was really worth it.

We had dinner for 4 on the covered patio over looking the harbor. It was nice to see all the boats in the harbor and a nice view while enjoying your drinks and dinner. The Food was amazing as well. Limited seating only on the patio.....so make reservation or be there earlier.

Salute! On The Beach offers a truly relaxed Key West dining experience, blending good food with unbeatable views. Nestled right on the beach, the location alone makes it worth a visit — you can feel the ocean breeze, hear the waves, and watch the sun dip low while enjoying your meal. It’s casual yet scenic, perfect for a laid-back evening out. I ordered the pesto pasta with Salute’s vegetables, which was vibrant, fresh, and satisfying without feeling too heavy. I paired it with a stout and a Bradley beer, both of which complemented the dish nicely and added to the mellow, beachside vibe. For my daughter, we ordered noodles with red sauce and cheese, a simple and comforting plate that she really enjoyed. Service was quick and efficient — we didn’t have to wait long for anything, and the staff was friendly and attentive throughout. The overall experience was easygoing and enjoyable, ideal for families or anyone looking to enjoy a relaxed meal just steps from the water. Definitely a great spot to unwind with good food, drinks, and that classic Florida Keys backdrop.

This place was awesome! The folks greet you at the door and they exude positivity! The bar is just what you'd expect for being on the beach, but is perfect! The food is delish and portion sizes are healthy. Got the lasagna and the yellow tail snapper. Both were awesome! Parking is plentiful on days when the beach isn't crowded. Highly recommend!

First time trying Salute on the beach and it was great! Nice beach view outdoor seating and atmosphere all around. Mark the Host was so friendly and fun, he’s the best! Jesus was our server and he also took great care of us! Literally everything we tried was soooooo delicious! The fresh bread they bring to the table started off our meal the right way…so fresh and tasty! You can tell the chef put a lot of thought into these menu items. You gotta try the calamari! Might be the best I ever had; it’s sautéed instead of breaded and has a spicy red sauce, we loved it! Make sure you get the key lime pie for dessert! Thanks for an awesome time!

The food was amazing. We ordered the muscles in the white sauce it was to die for! The fresh fish was so yummy and tender the sauces on both of our fish dishes were amazing! The food made me dance. It was so delicious and filling, I had the yellow snapper and my husband had the grouper. The staff was very friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was very relaxing and romantic we sat pretty much on the beach. This is our favorite restaurant in Key West hands down!

I rode the rental bike to Salute restaurant. I arrived around 11:00 AM to have more seating options. I had the popular dessert named Key lime pie. The meringue is sky high, complimenting the outdoor beach scenery. Vhuntermassage LLC

Random stop, and was so happy to stumble upon those place. Ordered the sautéed calimari with marinara - which was fantastic! Order it! It was super fresh, plentiful for the cost, and was perfectly satisfying. The marinara had a nice little spice that elevated the dish to the next level. I will definitely Salute this location, and when back in Key West, I will make this a hit!

We've gone here a couple times before and always loved it! This time I had a migraine so we got it to go. The calamari portions are half of what they normally are, we got fettuccine Alfredo one with just chicken and one with shrimp and chicken and the one with shrimp and chicken has hardly any chicken in it compared to the one with only chicken, as well as the portions for the pasta, being a lot smaller than when you eat at the restaurant. Stood for ten minutes waiting for the lady at the bar to ask us what we needed continuously walking passed us without so much as a “one moment please”. Paying $100 for this throw together food is very disheartening.

Best breakfast in Key West. Came back both mornings that we were there. We had the veggie Omelette and the quiche and tried some crepes as well, which were SO good. The cappuccino was on point as well. The vibes are so cute. Friendly staff. I love this place so much and would highly recommend it.

We always stop by this cute spot in Key West. I love the plain crepes, but I tried a savory one this time and wasn't a fan. The plain crepe with maple syrup is still my favorite! My family loves the sweet crepes and they get crazy and ice cream 🔥😂 Service the last two times have been better. So I appreciate that as well.

Traditional French breakfast fare in a classic styled cafe with a jovial atmosphere. Service was quick but with no pressure to keep moving even though they had a constant stream of patrons. Being able to watch the crepes being made in front of you while sitting at the bar was especially helpful in deciding what to have on future visits!

Délicieux! Delicious! We had the savory buckwheat crepe, it had smoked salmon and shrimp with key lime sauce and shared a honey almond croissant it was such a cute place and the service was great! I recommend!

La Crêperie is tucked away in a charming neighborhood just south of Duval Street, giving it a relaxed, local vibe that’s a nice break from the busier parts of Key West. The café has a small, cozy indoor space and some inviting outdoor seating, great for people-watching or enjoying a breezy morning. I tried the Key lime crepe, which was tasty and had a nice balance of flavors, but overall felt overpriced for the portion size. Adding to that, there’s a $2 surcharge on all menu items, which makes the cost feel even steeper. Service was friendly at first, but inconsistent. Our server was pleasant, but disappeared for a long stretch with no drink refills, and we eventually had to flag down another server just to get our check. All in all, La Crêperie has a fun atmosphere and decent food, but the service and value didn’t quite live up to expectations. It’s worth a visit if you’re nearby, but don’t expect a standout experience for the price.

Fantastic breakfast, lunch or brunch spot! We went for brunch one afternoon around 1pm in August and it was busy but we got seats at the bar. Stopped by the next morning around 11am and it was PACKED and lots of people waiting. Amazing food. I had a great crepe with strawberries, banana and chocolate ganache. My boyfriend had a croque and was obsessed! Great and super friendly service. Would definitely return here!

If I could give zero stars, I would. The food is overpriced and not tasty — everything was burnt. The Eggs Benedict was just a plain boiled egg, and the omelet was overcooked and burnt as well. The kids' portion of the omelet was ridiculously small for $11 plus an extra $2. Service was slow and unpleasant; the waiter ignored all our requests. The tables are tiny — there were four of us, but the table was meant for two. Overall, I absolutely do not recommend this place.

I’m a key lime pie fan. We went by a few places to try their key lime pies. We got a small pie, it frozen, we ate it about a day later and it wasn’t good. It felt as the crust melted (got runny like the caramel of a flan). The texture wasn’t good, I’m not sure if it was because we got it frozen but it’s definitely not worth it. My daughter ate the whip cream. Publix key lime pie is a whole lot better.

Grabbed a key lime pie to go. Will say I had a decent amount of key lime pie this trip. I will say this one’s ok. Maybe it’s because for me I’d like to have a bit more crust for a texture difference or contrast, also the pie was more tart than sweet. Basically, if those flavor profiles matches your fancy, absolutely come in and grab a slice.

This was the MOST delicious key lime pie I had ever tasted. Such kind and friendly staff and amazing key lime pie merch for a reasonable price. The store was also beautifully decorated which made the experience even better. It was walking distance from our cruise ship and if you are ever in key west you need to stop by. I also got the most heavenly scented key lime pie candle, an authentic beignet and the most refreshing key limeanade. My only complaint is that I don’t think I will be able to eat another key lime pie again unless it is made from this place, it’s that good

This was the absolute best key lime pie I have ever eaten. My niece and her husband actually saw this company on The Profit and said the gentleman stated the same thing. I guess you’ll have to visit Key West to get a taste of true key lime pie or order it online and have shipped. I wish I had bought more!! I highly recommend visiting if in the area.

Absolutely delicious 😋!! My Hubby and I came in December 2023 all the way from Atlanta during a cruise and now I returned in May 2024 on another cruise with my Mom. The key lime pie is light and refreshing. I also enjoyed the key lime punch so authentic. What I appreciate the most is that it's not tart!! The most delicious choice in Key West...give them a try.

Very well clean place with nice designs and space. The service was friendly. The slices of key lime pies weren’t that tasty. It’s nice to see the process of making pies in front of you but personally I didn’t like the taste.

Definitely the BEST Key Lime Pie in the Key West!!! We have tried Key Lime Pie from other locations during the same visit, but their Key Lime Pie and taffy definitely have that Key Lime punch, great consistency and taste as well. We the the mini version, soft serve. Great service, great ambiance. I would definitely love recommend and I know I will definitely crave it when I’m back home.

We went to Key West for our honeymoon and this was one of our stops to visit. The ice cream is delicious!!! A lot more pricey than I would have liked, $20 for 2 people, but it was yummy.

Whoever was working tonight was so sweet,attentive and helpful. And I'm sure we were annoying with all our questions but she seemed to really enjoy helping. The strawberry ice cream was super fruity n creamy. Loved the chocolate chip. It was just like we used to get when I was a kid. Light flaky chocolate chips. Lots of chocolate. Was not a huge fan if the chocolate amaretto. Promising but it had a slightly fake alcohol flavor to it. Maybe a minor adjustment in the recipe would fix it. The best by far BANANA CINNAMON! Light, fluffy, and velvety and a little sweeter. It's my new favorite. Anyhow definitely the best ice cream in Key West. We've had them all. This one is the most flavorful and absolute best service.

We come from Lancaster County Pennsylvania, where there’s Cow to come ice cream on Every corner, yours is amazing what’s more, we were Here almost twenty years ago (maybe 18 or 19) I said to Katie last night “were ya’ll Here 20 years ago She said Yes!!!! We’ve been proudly serving for like forty years!!!!” She was WONDERFUL The best ever really you meet some people occasionally who serve others with a Kind Heart interested in Helping others she’s one of them, and the ice cream was spectacular too, a can’t miss on your list of Key West Experiences

Very delicious ice cream and a wide selection! The staff is very polite and friendly!

This place needs more credit on the island as it definitely seems underrated. They have so many fun and fresh flavors to offer and some local ones like Cuban coffee and key lime. They also have variety as they serve sorbets, frozen yoghurt and gelato-style ice cream. I had the coconut and guava and both of them are excellent. The coconut has actually shreds of coconut that gives it a nice texture and the guava is the prettiest color. It did get a little crowded and chaotic while I was there as there was only one person running it but she was super nice about offering samples and being patient. Highly recommend just dropping by as you walk around!

I live in Florida but was my first time in key west. West to this place yesterday. OMG. Ice cream was so good. I got guava and key lime, my wife and daughter chocolate and my son vanilla. Chocolate was really good and I am not a big fan of chocolate ice cream. Guava was delicious with a natural flavor. But I will tell you, the key lime flavor was amazing. I this was the best ice cream I ever tried in the US honestly. Definitely worth coming back for that.

Delicious! I had French chocolate, coconut and chocolate Kahlua my fiance had mango, lavender and banana. Go big or go home get the three scoops for $7.75. they don't take credit cards so make sure you have cash on hand. Highly recommend trying them. There's also picnic tables outside to sit on.

Thank you so much to Key West Cakes for the most delicious and beautiful wedding cake!! We ordered a heart cake for an intimate wedding, the inside was vanilla and chocolate marble with Bavarian cream. 10 out of 10!!! The cake was moist and rich, absolutely perfect for our needs. Steve handled my order all the way from Maryland and had it delivered to the wedding reception. It absolutely exceeded my expectations. Thanks again so much!! Highly recommend.

We were married on 3/1/25 at The Hemingway Home & we decided on Key West Cakes. Staff were so great & our wedding planner set up a delicious tasting with them before the wedding so that we could make our selections. Our cake was beautiful & elegant. Just what we wanted. Thank you, Key West Cakes

We were absolutely blown away with our wedding cake! We got a vegan cake because I am dairy free and it was the best cake I have ever had. We choose a chocolate cake with raspberry filling and vanilla frosting. Our guests haven’t stopped talking about it! Key West Cakes has been a pleasure to work with- you will not go wrong with a cake from here!

Key West Cakes did our wedding cake, and I couldn't have been happier! We chose a coconut cake with coconut icing, and it was such a crowd pleaser. I normally find wedding cake to be boring and dry, but this cake was so moist, fluffy, and flavorful. Our guests loved it! We tried saving the top tier but ended up devouring it with family the next day because we were all talking about how good it was. I will dream of this cake until I'm able to be back in Key West for a slice again soon!

Heavenly cupcakes! I picked up 6 of them today and tried the Funfetti as soon as I got home. A perfect 10 for me. The buttercream frosting is wonderful, it is not too heavy. There was a good amount of frosting on too, which is my favorite part of any cake so it was a hit for me. I can't wait to try the other flavors I got: mint chocolate chip (which has green mint cake vs chocolate cake), guava, lemon lovers, coconut bliss and key lime pie. They look incredible and based on the first one I tried I'm sure they will be just as delightful. A must-try for any cake lover. I can't wait to go back and try different flavors and also try their cookies. I do have one recommendation though, either drive to get these (they have some parking) or put them in a cooler to get them home if walking or biking. I had the cupcakes in a sealed bike bag during the hottest part of the day and got them home in under 10 min and some of the frosting had started to slide off and kind of "melt". Totally my fault and lesson learned. Next time I will have an ice pack in my bag.

I 100% recommend this bakery! The entire process from ordering online until pickup was smooth! I ordered a key lime birthday cake,and it was OFF THE CHARTS AMAZING! The cake was BEAUTIFUL, with a perfect balance of taste and texture! The bday girl was extremely happy! I will definitely custom order from this bakery every time I need a special cake, and will recommend to others! Thanks for a great product!

Dave and team at Key West Cakes was an absolute pleasure working with for our wedding this past June. We worked with the team to develop a dessert menu of key lime tartlets and gluten free cupcakes (celiac guest). Not only were the tartlets delicious but the team at a Key West Cakes promptly delivered and setup our dessert table. Highly recommend Key West Cakes for any event in the keys. We will be going back for the tartlets everytime we visit!

We read their menu late one night in their front window while passing by. My friend was obsessed with trying the green shakshuka. We went back in the morning for brunch. Although my travel friends are healthy eaters, they don’t usually eat at places like this, but were happy with the experience. Their shakshuka was FABULOUS and full of herbs and flavor. Two of us ordered the mushroom croissant…nobody could shut up about how good it was! I had their basil limeade. BEST LIMEADE I’ve ever had (fresh and sour and unique in flavor). I ordered a bowl with greens, salmon, avocado and pickled onions. It was EXACTLY what I was wanting-hearty, oh-so-fresh food to nourish me! 2 friends ordered the spinach and feta frittata and loved it! The coffee and golden milk were also spot-on. Everything was incredibly fresh and tasty. They’ve put a lot of thought into presentation and flavors, not to mention all of the earth-friendliness! I appreciated everything about this spot. Is it cheap? No, but actual good food never is. Also, their prices are totally comparable to anywhere else in town. The vibe is fun, welcoming and calm, and it’s a unique setting tucked back inside an upscale boutique. This is exactly the kind of healthy comfort food I look for when traveling. We were all so delighted to have eaten here.

Decent selection of Vegan options. The seasoning on the side of potatoes was AMAZING. The cafe seating is set apart from the rest of the shop to allow some privacy, while you eat. The coffee bar also accommodates vegan diets with plant based milk options. All around a very nice space with flavorful and healthy vegan food.

One of my very favorite places to eat in Key West. Healthy, organic food, comfortable seating and music, counter space to people-watch on Duval if you’re in the mood. Lots of gluten free, dairy free, or vegan options, including awesome bakery case. They make everything here, and they care about health. Super-kind staff in the cafe also. A gem!

The coziest spot in key west! If you’re looking for a nice place to get away from all the drinking atmosphere and grime of key west this will be your safe haven. The food is so fresh and truly tastes healthy and home made. Their coffee and matcha are delicious. They have great vegetarian and vegan options. Not to mention, the cutest clothes in their boutique. I love this little spot.

Liza was so friendly and helpful. We love the Variety of the Cafe Menu and had a great experience ! We will be back soon. Thank you!

First time visiting Key West and I found this adorable boutique and café called the Green Pineapple. I was so excited because I’m GF, VG and the options are AMAZING! The smoothies, and that Mediterranean panini I had was hands down the best I’ve ever had. So what I’m saying is if you’re in Key West, do your self a favor, get some delicious healthy eats! You won’t regret it!

Amazing! Plenty of vegan and gluten free options for people with allergies and other dietary preferences. The Staff were very kind! I had the vegan croissant and the cold brew coffee both were absolutely delicious!

Paola made our wedding cake two years ago and this year she made the most beautiful tastiest 3 layered cake for my daughters first birthday. She was so sweet and kind to work with, the most professional baker I've ever come into contact with. The cake was so delicious. We had over 40 people at my daughters birthday and we got so many compliments about how amazing the cake was. Rick delivered the cake and it came perfect. Thank you again Paola, Rick and the team at Amazing Cakes and Creations❤️

Paola did my surprise KC Chiefs grooms cake for my August wedding and it was amazing. She was easy to book, super responsive (via email) and the cake turned out better than I ever could have imagined. I sent her a photo and she delivered. Plus it was super yummy!

The best cake we have ever had. Please don’t be blinded by the more popular/prominent bakeries in Key West. We tried them all (and not just their wedding cakes) and Paola’s tasting alone blew them out of the water. The white cake with strawberries and mousseline is to die for. Key lime with key lime filling is soooo good but the white cake stole the show for us. Guests were raving about both flavors. We ordered enough so we would have plenty of leftovers and people were stopping by the next morning to take some home and began eating a slice right in our condo. We did a small cutting cake with 2 sheet cakes served to guests, price was reasonable, decor was beautiful, flavor was fantastic. We will be ordering one to celebrate our anniversary when we are back next year.

We came to the Keys to visit our dearest friends and to celebrate our daughter’s 21st birthday. Amazing Cakes did a great job on capturing college/Keys/and the important “21”. The confetti cake flavor was so delicious. Delivery was perfect! Thank you so much!

Amazing Cakes truly lives up to its name. My cake was absolutely perfect. I had sent a few photos of what I wanted and they went above and beyond my expectations. Rick and team were so easy to email back and forth with and accommodate all of my requests. They even delivered to my hotel so it was there when I arrived. I very highly recommend! (Also is super reasonably priced!)

The most amazing cake and awesome service!!! Knowing my birthday was on April 11th and that we would be in Key West with friends, my fiancee wanted to do something extra special, as it was my 60th. She had found a pic of a similar cake and contacted the folks at Amazing Cake with her idea.... We are craft beer fans and especially fans of one certain craft brewery here In Virginia Beach. They had her ship the empty can to them and they came up with what was in the accompanying picture. The day of my birthday dinner, we were all over the map about where to go for dinner and Rick was SO helpful, even delivered the cake to the restaurant at 5 p.m. when we finally decided where we were eating... The cake was a HUGE success, an AWESOME SURPRISE and TASTY!!! Thank you Rick and company for all your hard work and assistance.

All I can say is wow!! My baby shower cake was so unbelievably beautiful I didn’t want to take a bite of it, the cake was the center of attention at our party :) From the phenomenal artistic design, to the rich delicious flavor, and the white chocolate ornaments... our cake was hands down the best!! I wish I could give more stars! Cannot wait to have another cake done for our next special occasion!

Absolutely loved this place! We hosted a surprise 30th birthday for my brother and rented out the entire property for the weekend. The service was truly exceptional - the staff made it feel like our own home. They went above and beyond, helping us place gift bags in each room and decorating the house for the celebration. We spent the day by the pool and had the main party in the afternoon/evening. We set up a tent and stage for a few bands, and the whole setup was gorgeous - plenty of space for our 60+ guests, right on the water. The staff were incredibly accommodating, letting us bring in coolers for drinks and catering from local restaurants. Everyone had an amazing time in such a beautiful setting. I can’t recommend Southernmost House enough for private parties, weddings, or any special event. Huge thanks to the entire team for an unforgettable weekend!

This place has everything you need for a perfect trip to Key West. We just returned from our honeymoon and we would go back in a heartbeat. The location is perfectly located near Old Town, right at the end of Duval. The staff went above and beyond to make sure our trip was special. Elio had our room decked out with champange and roses when we arrived and gave us countless recommendations for food and things to do. We also loved the bar and cafe located at the resort. The lobster pizza was delicious. The complimentary breakfast was also delicious with fresh local baked goods. The pool is by far the best pool on the island. Clean, beautiful view of the ocean, and the occasional chicken and iguana crossing. We cannot wait to book our next trip back to this resort!

Had a beautiful sunset dinner here, service was fast and the staff were so friendly and had great conbersation with them. The lobster biscuits are amazing! Its right on the water so you can get amazing pictures of the sea and the sunset.

Why 3 Star, because it’s rates a 3 star property, just a really expensive 3 star. You’re paying for location, pool and damn good pastries. We’re staying here right now (Night 1 of 3), We got moved from a King size partial Ocean View to a Bungalow. We were not told our upgrade was a Queen (pretty lame lack of communication tbh). Our first impression of the Bungalow was not great. The door barely shuts, the lights out avice the door and it barely locks. It has a dated kitchen and lack of detailed cleaning; think dirty old vents and build up on the vents. Not sure about this place tho. Hoping to be charmed by breakfast. Update Day 3 of 3. We decided to stay and not move, due to the fact we’re lazy, and we like the pool and quiet end of Duval. That said we did worry that we had a mold or mildew on our ceiling, the wash cloth holder comes off the wall. Get the picture? A lot of stuff like that. All in all a cool place just seems dumpy compared to nearby properties and other places we’ve stayed.

This review is for the fantasy Fest Friday bunny party in 2025. We had VIP seats on the upper deck. The place was so packed otherwise I don’t know how you could enjoy yourselves. The music was good. Loved the topless ladies!

This restored mansion is at the southernost tip of Key West, right on the water. The large grounds include beautiful guest rooms, large outdoor pool and sun deck, and a nice cafe. Shopping, dining, and entertainment are mere steps from your door. And the infamous "Southernmost Point" marker photo-op is right next to it.

Went to enjoy some drinks and the view, but was absolutely appalled to see the host pouring boiling hot water on the chickens and roosters that were walking around. They were not getting into food or bothering anyone. Everywhere else on the island will use cold water spray bottles or just shoo them away. When I confronted the host about this disgusting behavior, he told me it was no problem and it was company policy. I have tried to call several times to speak with a manager, but I am told every single time that there is no manager on duty. Pouring boiling hot water on birds IS animal abuse and it is uncalled for. I wouldn’t suggest anyone step foot on this property.

The cookies here are so good! Crunchy when you bite into it, but soft and chewy on the inside. They stay good for a couple of days, too. I'm on day 3 of my macadamia nut cookie and it's still kickin'.

This is such an amazing place to grab an ice cream after walking around key west. Definitely one of the most delicious I’ve tried. Their cake batter ice cream was amazing. I would definitely return

I hesitate to leave this three star review because the pie was actually GOOD! Very homemade, very good. The first time we went, the lady was nice and she gave us that good pie, and I don’t want to take away from that. HOWEVER, the second time we went, there was a guy working the counter and he obviously wasn’t very versed in what to do. My husband ordered the key lime milkshake and after some hesitation, the gentleman scooped some hard vanilla ice cream into a cup, filled the top with ice and limeade and gave it to us, all for about $9 IF you don’t leave a small tip, which we did. If you are wondering if you read that right, yes you did. The guy didn’t blend the shake AT ALL. It was a hard ice cream lump with liquid floating around it. We were flabbergasted. How does one drink this? Or do we eat it? Yeah, it ended up in the trash with a lot of disappointment. Needless to say, we won’t be coming back.

When we first went to store, it was should have been open but the doors were locked. The lady inside waved gave hand signal as if to say just a minute. Well, we waited outside for at least 5 minutes and she never opened the door. We did go back hours later and she had opened for business. My great nephews enjoyed the ice cream. I love the way the store is decorated and it’s next to the best breakfast place ever; The Breakfast Club, Too.

BEST KEY LIKE PIE! We have been trying every key lime pie we find on this vacation up and down the keys, this has been the best by far!!! I also love the fact it is family owned 💚

The BEST key lime pie I have EVER tasted. I try pieces all over the place...the crust is amazing..the best part!!! The pie is rich with a good lime taste, not overpowering ...Just right. I highly recommend it!!!

Now that’s a cookie! Most oversized cookies suffer from the same issue - they are baked on the outside but by the time you get to the center it’s typically gooey undercooked cookie dough. Thankfully the chocolate chip cookie here was perfect. Baked throughout while still maintaining crunchiness on the outside but still cakey in the inside without being undercooked. This was one of my favorite cookies I’ve had in a long time.

We wanted to try the famous Key Lime Pie. They kindly explained what it was and offered us the best Key Lime Pie on the island.!! We also brought all the ingredients to make our own at home. Thank you so much Limes and Pies!

What a sweet spot in key west! You know after I got so many lemons, I have to come to keywest and visiting Hemingway’s house and the 61 cats on property. And this cute store just adorable. Key lemon pie with rich favor and a nice slice of lemon candy, perfectly matches the Cuban coffee and expresso. And the music and people watching on the cozy sofa… our server mil is very professional and attentive. The accessories and snacks and sweets they are selling will definitely bring the vibe back to wherever you are…can’t agree more below: Mil was a really great help with our questions. Didn’t experience such a great sales assistant in Florida yet.

The lady serving was nice BUT seriously for $6.99 the smallest and worst serving of ice cream that I've ever had. My husband had single and it was like a teaspoon of ice ream. The ice cream is incredibly average and the serving size atrocious. Wouldn't go back.

Best Key Lime pie Has a nice balance between sweet and tart creamy. The crust was really good held together. Well not hard but not too soft and the whipped cream was really smooth. You could tell it’s homemade it not out of a can overall I would totally recommend visiting limes and pies in Key West on Duvall St.

This is a great stop to try some authentic key lime pie in Key West! We opted to try this at the recommendation of a local nearby! Their pie was excellent and worthy of a visit!

Best Key lime Pie in Key West… like heaven in your mouth with every taste. And served perfectly by a charming host Milton.

Amazing key lime pie!! We also bought a strawberry- banana smoothie. It was delicious as well. Such a cute shop! We will be back again.

Good place if you want to try some nice French pastries. We just wanted to try out macarons since we have never had one. We tried, as far as I remember, the Lemon and the Raspberry macarons and they were great. They even make these assorted boxes which you can get packed and gift it to someone. Definitely, a must try if you are on Duval Street.

First if all the people running this adorable and sweet establishment we're so incredibly nice and generous. The macrons were beautiful and so delicious. Next time we come to Key West we will definitely visit again. They also had dairy free and gluten free macrons!!!

Macaroons are good. Located right on Duvall Street. My daughter always has to stop in and grab a few different flavors of macaroons. Couple small tables and chairs so that you can enjoy your treats in the air conditioning.

What a cute shop on Duval St.! So many flavors to choose from it was hard to decide! My favorite was Bubblegum and it was blue! These kinds of treats are not cheap but when you're in Key West you need to treat yourself! They also have free tasting samples which makes it easier to decide what flavor to get. Best to eat them right away or keep them chilled. Next time I'm in Key West I'm going back to get some more!

It's a chain shop, same as the one I visited in Savannah in August this year. The chocolates are as beautiful as they are tasty. The macarons are delicious, even though they're a bit pricey for the size. And they were out of my favorite pistachio macarons when I visited. Still, it was an oasis of coolness after an afternoon of walking. Service is cheerful. I can't vouch for the gelato, but it did look yummy. These sweets are for a slightly more sophisticated palate than the sugar store down the street.

Picked up some macarons on our adventures down Duval street in Key West. The store was cute and had different types of two-bite desserts to offer other than macarons. The variety of flavors were perfect for the Key West heat and lend itself well to the environment.

Very disappointed with the Macaroons. Not light with a slight chew. Not traditional at all. I can make these at home so much better. And I agree with comments expensive if not done correctly but it’s on Duval St got to make money. However need to do Macaroons recipe over

Working with Cakes by Karol was an absolute delight from start to finish. She was incredibly responsive and patient, answering all of our questions and offering thoughtful recommendations on flavor combinations that would complement each other perfectly. We had a very specific cake inspiration we found online, and Karol took that exact vision and transformed it into a beautiful cake that not only matched our wedding aesthetic but also reflected our personalities. It was truly the perfect centerpiece for our celebration. One of the highlights was the cake tasting process—even though we weren’t local, Karol shipped the cake layers, fillings, and frostings to us so we could sample and mix flavors at home. It was so much fun (and so tasty!) to experiment with all the delicious combinations before making our final choice. On the big day, our guests couldn’t stop raving about how incredible the cake was—some even joked about trying to bribe others for extra slices! That kind of reaction says it all. If you want a cake that’s as delicious as it is beautiful, and a vendor who’s easy to communicate with and truly cares, Cakes by Karol is the one to call.

We highly recommend using cakes by Karol! Our wedding cake turned out absolutely incredible. Not only was it beautiful but tasted incredible. All out our guest loved it! It was the perfect size for our small wedding. The unique key lime flavor was perfect. Definitely recommend if you’re getting married in Key West.

Cakes By Karol is absolutely amazing!! We chose her for our destination wedding in Key West and she was nothing but Great from her professionalism to her amazing cake! Everyone said it was the best wedding cake they have ever tasted! It was the wedding cake of my Dreams! I would highly recommend Cakes By Karol for a delicious and beautiful cake!!

Cakes by Karol hosted the desserts and cake for our wedding day last week. I have Celiac Disease and other food allergies so I stick mostly to a gluten free/vegan diet. Given that, we did a one tier gluten free, vegan cake with chocolate cake, peanut butter filling and vanilla buttercream icing with a blush flower on the side. Not only did our cake look beautiful, but you would have never known it was a gluten free, vegan cake - it was DELICIOUS! I totally recommend them whether you have food allergies or not. Our guests loved the dessert display we put underneath (key lime shooters, chocolate trifle shooters, peanut butter chocolate shooters, chocolate covered strawberries). Our guests ate them until they couldn't eat anymore, even after our reception had ended. Cakes by Karol worked amazing with all of this and the fact that we live almost 2,000 miles away. They kept in contact with us through emails, calls, etc. and always responded in a timely fashion. That was such a breeze to feel important so far away. Thank you Cakes by Karol! If we could give you more than 5 stars I would!

For our wedding, we ordered a dessert tower for our guests. Cakes by Karol whipped up some fantastic key lime, strawberry cheesecake and chocolate mousse shooters that everyone raved about! We were working long-distance and the entire process was easy, we we very pleased with the results. Very budget friendly as well. Highly recommend!

Karol was extremely pleasant to work with and brought our vision to life!! We did a 6 inch round with key lime & strawberry shortcake shooter tower below. Everyone was obsessed including us! It was gorgeous and delicious! Highly recommend.

Very accommodating business. You tell them what you want and they’ll get it done (for a price of course). It’s always a gamble when it comes to taste. I had a cake done professionally last year for my daughters birthday in cape cod and it was trash, so I was praying this was edible. Luckily we could actually eat a birthday cake this year! Definitely pricey, but I know nothing about cake making. Overall they came through on my daughters birthday and that’s all I could ask for. Even delivered to Latitudes on a separate island. Thank you, again. (For those that need to know the cake we got was dense and rich and sweet, but that’s all I’ll say about that)

Great French bakery and coffee shop. Had a nice morning breakfast and would come back again. Like that it is locally owned and the owners are nice

Great little place we just stumbled into. Good coffee, great key lime pie and free Wi-Fi

Great food and coffee. Very friendly

Delicious milkshakes and super friendly owners/ service! + Free WiFi

Mediocre place. Had a regular coffee, tasted watery and not very flavorful.

The Best Café in town and the guys are very friendly😊

Cute spot!! Stopped in for a sandwich and gelato. Very good. :)

Of course the trolley we rode on through Key West passed in front of Kermit's Key West Lime Shoppe. Of course a human dressed in a key lime-colored baker's outfit was right curbside showing off a whole key lime pie to us all. And of course my spouse had to have one. After throwing down a few and enjoying some conch around town, we popped in before getting back on the cruise ship. MENU: Pies (by the slice, whole, even shipped to the lower 48), ice cream, smoothies, beverages. DESSERT: Key Lime Pie On A Stick An actual slice of frozen pie was covered in a dark chocolate shell. I personally would've liked it more if it was milk chocolate as the combined tartness of the pie and dark chocolate made it extremely tart for me. Key Lime Pie I'm not a key lime pie expert or fan, but it was good to me. A bit tart, light, not overly sweet, with a thin and moist crust. SERVICE: The male staff member who assisted us was welcoming and friendly. TIP: They sell other snacks and items as well. Mosey around the store! OVERALL: If you're a key lime fan, I'm sure you'll love this place.

The BEST coconut key lime pie bar (omg)!!! I could eat every day! 🤣 the store is amazing. They offer free cookies, for you to try and decide if you want to buy it. It’s always busy but have a lot of space to enjoy your sweet in peace. Staff is so friendly and kind. They have a lot of options for gifts. I also bought a key lime pie lip balm and I LOVED IT! Smells like key lime pie and tastes great. 😅 Loved loved loved!!! 💚

Delicious!! Love all the varieties of met line. We ordered the regular key lime pie, strawberry key lime pie, and gluten free l Ed Mon cookies - all excellent. They d en offer free samples of some items (not the pie). We liked the key lime jelly beans. Friendly service too. Highly recommend

If you're looking for key lime pie you've come to the right place! This shop is located right on Duval street and most likely you'll walk by it. Once you enter the place is really cute. They offer a variety of cookies, crackers, and the best part is they have free samples of it all! My favorite cookies were the key lime coolers. Give em a try. They also sell key lime pie by the slice or the whole pie. And if you want the pie to go, they do have thermal bags available which will keep your pie chilled. There's a fridge with key lime pies dipped in chocolate which are quite tasty. Another cool thing here is Key Lime Pie beer! Now that was an interesting find. I had never seen this before so I had to taste it. Yes, it's sour, but pretty refreshing especially on a hot day. I tried a slice of the original key lime pie and it was delish. Perfect amount of tartness and creaminess. The whip cream was delicious and the graham crust tasted fresh. They have some seating indoors and also have a cute key lime colored patio area where you can enjoy your goodies.

Great place to grab a slice of key lime pie! Super fun environment. They have lots of options as well. (Ice cream, cookies, etc.) We got the original as well as the strawberry flavored one. Great photo spots too. 10/10 recommend!

Had to try what I was told was the best key lime pie in KW. It was delicious indeed but I’ve got to believe there is better. Also the size of the slice is tiny. A slice of pie should be at least close to as long as the fork you’re eating it with! The shop had a lot of personality however, and i liked the free samples of some of their other goodies.

Shari and I popped into Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shoppe while in Key West on way to Rum Distillery Tour. It smelled like a slice of Heaven in there. We sampled a few cookies and a few pieces of Key lime candies But we bought nothing we were In a rush to the tour

I had a savory crepes and cappuccino for my breakfast, and purchased assorted pastries to enjoy on my ride to Miami. Oh boy, they're all fresh and delicious!

J'aime beaucoup! Lol loved this charming coffee, pastry, and sandwich shop! A good assortment of tasty treats in a tastefully designed and decorated space. Friendly, helpful staff. Nice small town feel. Get here early as they close at 2:30.

Lovely French bakery tucked away off the side of the major road running throughout KW. Without looking it up honestly this place would be very easily missed but missing this place would be a mistake. Very delicious and artfully crafted baked items. Can strongly recommend the chocolate and almond (bear claw?, not quite sure but I loved it) all items were delicate and sweet but not overwhelming. I could definitely go through several of these without an issue so I had to restrict myself to half a baked item a day. Flew a few back home they were so good. In the $4-5 range for most items. Absolutely make a stop here

What a wonderful surprise to find this charming French bakery hide in the Key West/Stark Island. We originally stopped in just for a cappuccino, but ended up staying until closing time, enjoying different tartines and the most delicious key lime beignet. The dough was absolutely perfect. We even picked up some croissants to take with us on our six-hour drive — and they were worth every bite. The staff were welcoming and friendly, which made the experience even better. I highly recommend this place — a true treasure in Key West!

We spent every morning of our trip to the Keys here for coffee and breakfast, and it never disappointed. From cappuccinos and lattes to frappes and food, everything was absolutely delicious. The portions were generous, and even when it was busy, the wait was never long. We especially loved the quaint atmosphere of the back patio- it became our favorite spot to start the day. Highly recommend!

We had an almond and chocolate croissant and an omelette with spinach, Brie and Swiss cheese. Delicious all of it! Our double espressos were caffeinated perfection! I highly recommend this bakery cafe!

Nice little breakfast spot. Not super French though - crepes were chewy, but tasty and espresso was served in styrofoam cups. Ugh. Outside of that, pretty fabulous. Very nice staff, clean, prices not too bad. Breakfast sandwiches on croissants were on point.

Such a cute place for desserts, wished we tried the ice cream. The cookies are absolutely huge and we got the snickerdoodle and chocolate chip. It was delicious but it didn’t WOW us. Overall the atmosphere and customer service were great!

This was a good ice cream spot; the ice cream is especially creamy which suggests to me that it has a higher cream content. The key lime pie was quite tasty; sweet yet tart and had a thick yummy buttery graham cracker crust. The gentleman added some whipped cream as this is not the “meringue topped” type of key lime pie. We also had some Cuban cappuccino which was essentially an Italian cappuccino but it was very good. The gentleman serving us surprised us with a taste of an affogado (espresso and some vanilla ice cream) which was really tasty! There are also giant cookies, fudge, gluten free chocolate macaroons but we did not try those. The ice cream is made down the street but it is essentially made on site as is the key lime pie. Good place!

Mattheessen’s Homemade is absolutely delicious! The ice cream sundae was incredible, topped with warm, fresh cookies that smelled amazing the moment you walked in. The whole place is filled with the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked cookies and sweets. Everything tasted rich, homemade, and full of flavor. If you’re in Key West, this place is a must-visit!”

By far the best key lime pie in all of Key West! The crust was incredible , and the key lime flavor is spot-on — tangy, smooth, and just right. We actually stumbled upon this spot while looking for ice cream but decided to try the pie instead… and I’m so glad I did! Highly recommend — even better than Kermit’s!

Wonderful overall experience! Nice people, delicious ice-cream and the ½ lb. cookies looked scrumptious!!!😆

Excellent customer service and delicious Ice cream, maxi cookies and Key Lime Pie.

This luminous place will define my memories of Key West. A candy-like scent permeates the place, and I bought a bag full of massive cookies. The chocolate chip cookies with pecans, and peanut butter with chocolate fudge are absolute winners! The dense cookies are buttery, and perfectly chewy. You can definitely change the world with these cookies!

Delicious creamy ice cream and smooth flavor filled fudge. I had the Key West Mud Slide in a waffle cup and my wife got a pierce of each peanut butter and chocolate caramel fudge. The peanut butter fudge was still warm!!! We were so focused on eating we forgot to take pictures.

We love this location in Key West! Every time we are in town we make a stop. Ralph and the team are so nice and personable! Literally everything we’ve had is amazing including the ice cream! If you’re on Duval street, make sure you stop by and get some treats. So many options and many handmade on site! Thanks!

Billie was such a joy and I loved the chocolate. The fresh made warm peanut butter was my favorite. Love the team work and family like business of friends. Suly thanks for making the peanut butter Great treat in key west!

Ice cream & artisan chocolate shop with a huge range of options of ice cream flavours. Queue might be quite long during peak tourist seasons. There is very few seatings available and are all outdoor next to the dirty streets - which isn't the best when you are eating.

Loved the atmosphere and smell of sweet treats! Ice cream was amazing! Ask for Billy (from WV)!! He was extremely friendly and provided samples of ice cream and chocolate! We will go back to visit again!

My sister and I were walking by when we did a complete 180 because this shop smelled so good from the doorway. After, we went here every single day of the trip. Mint chocolate chip in a cake cone! Ice cream in every bite and it was amazing.

Can’t say enough good about this place! Everything was delicious and the employees are so nice and helpful. My favorite ice cream was the toasted coconut! The all American two berry pie was also delicious- both unique to this shop.

Do not tip until you get your order. New owners are terrible! We have so many wonderful ice cream shops in Key West. This is not one of them.I always get the same thing. The grasshopper. It always had the graham cracker sprinkles in it. This time I was told it would be extra. When I got home, I did my research. Lots of photos and specific details regarding what is in the grasshopper. Including the graham cracker sprinkles. Seriously, if I wanted two scoops of mint chocolate chip ice cream, I could’ve just gone to the grocery store for half the price. Instead of arguing with a customer, just give them what they want. I took two bites of my ice cream and told the server to put it in the trash. I have no desire to go back here ever again. Hope you all are reading this and enjoyed my tip.

This is my absolute favorite ice cream shop in Key West. We go and get our blizzards from Timea. She is the best. Ice cream shops all over town but you can’t get DQ for service, good ice cream and great prices.

Beautiful location! This is the southernmost Dairy Queen, and they have fun things for kids to play with. All seating is outdoors and it is an ICE CREAM ONLY location. 🍦

I wrote special instructions for what the cake should say (& it had nothing to do w birthdays. It’s for a farewell). Yet, I received a birthday cake. Why offer the option for special instructions if they’re going to be ignored? Now I’m giving my friend a birthday cake vs a farewell cake

I wish they spend 30 seconds more to blend everything together for the smoothie as I still have chunks of ice in it … my husband god an ice cream with added brownie and chocolate and it was extremely sweet with cheap taste as synthetic! I won’t buy anything again from this store.

A stepback into time, family friendly, a must stop for everyone.

Ice cream is normal but the attention is the worst thing you will find in the keys of Florida. The lady who attends has a bad attitude and makes disliked facial gestures, if she doesn't want to work, she's better stay at home

We had ice cream from here four nights in a row! We don’t have much to compare it to because after our first visit, we were hooked and didn’t feel the need to try anywhere else. Our go-to combo was Mexican vanilla with Oreos and strawberries—absolutely delicious. The two ladies who helped us each night were incredibly kind and even shared some of the shop’s history with us, which made the experience even more special. We’d 100% recommend this spot, though to be fair, our recommendation is based on our overall love of ice cream rather than comparing it to other places in the Keys.

$20.99 for ONE small scoop of strawberry ice cream in a cup and a small vanilla milkshake is INSANE! This is taking advantage of people! They have no prices posted on their menu in store so you don’t know that when you get to the register, you will be paying a crazy price. Generally, there is an expectation of price that would seem fair and reasonable for things, but this is ridiculous. Never again. RESPONSE: of course we ate it as we did not plan to waste it after purchasing. And, nowhere did I say it tasted bad. I strictly said your prices are horrible and they are.

Delicious small batch ice cream in the heart of Key West. Tried the coconut agave and Kermit’s key lime. Both were really good, though the coconut agave was super trick and creamy. I appreciate that the key lime ice cream wasn’t too sweet.

We loved Wicked Lick so much, we went three days in a row while visiting Key West! The ice cream is fantastic—my girls couldn’t get enough of the one scoop with the waffle cone nacho chips (such a fun and tasty twist). The service made it even better—the ladies behind the counter were personal, friendly, and so warm every time we came in. It’s rare to find a spot that hits both the flavor and the experience this well. We’ll definitely be back next year!

I left the owner a message about the service but the actual ice cream, the dairy free VEGAN REEF DIVER with the Oreo cookies and the fresh strawberries and the berry sauce. Oh my God!!!! it was it was not enough 🤪😂 we wanted more!!! So much that me and my four year-old we were fighting for the last spoonful. I KID you not! It is absolutely delicious and worth every PENNY! I hope to see more of these around the US!!!! Kudos to you for making such a great vegan nut free, SOY FREE ice cream!

Incredibly disappointed in the quality & pricing of this “ice cream.” The texture was very icy, the flavor was lacking and it was $8 for a small! They have very basic flavors and you have to pay extra to add toppings, as nothing is mixed in. We tossed our $10 worth of ice cream (chocolate with crushed Oreos on top) and went to Dairy Queen. I’ll pay for quality ice cream, but this did not check any of the boxes unfortunately :(

Delicious ice cream worth it They have original homemade flavors, me and my boys had late night coffee ice cream with Oreos Heavenly delicious

This is one of the many food shops around town! They have rolled ice cream, ice cream, and normal ice cream. It's a little pricey and there are stores selling what they have for cheaper, so many just walk around before you go buy a $7 cookie haha not bad for taste though!

Delicious icecream with a wide variety of flavors to choose from. Most importantly, the people who run this place are very nice and gentle. Definitely five stars. ❤❤❤🌺

We had 1/2 lb chocolate chip cookie. It was good. Not too sweet but also had cake type feeling, I for sure like it that way but not sure of everyone looking for cookie would enjoy. For sure worth giving a try. According to the attendant their white chocolate with macadamia nut is one of the most popular one.

Ice cream was delicious and creamy! It was so much fun to watch her roll the ice cream and I believe it was reasonably priced.

A delicious place to stop! Their brownies are delicious and they were a nice snack on the cruise ride home.

We eat ice cream everywhere, all the time and travel a lot and this is the best ice cream we’ve ever had! A few of the flavors were more like a shaved Italian ice/sorbet-like texture but still creamy and delicious. So light and airy and refreshing, we LOVE IT!

The key lime, The Peanut Butter Cup, the cookie dough, and even the Papa Smurf flavor were all excellent and tasted delicious! Excellent ice cream and they all also have a creative blended flavors for braver eaters than me. 🤗🤔😁😀

Great deal for the price. I thought that the small was a large. It is well air conditioned and feels like a great environment. I tried blue raspberry and cherry. After a taste test I decided that the blue raspberry was a better flavor and I would recommend that. All in all this is a great place to get a quick shaved ice for a good price.

The orange and pina colada shave ice was so so delicious that I wish I could buy it locally elsewhere! If you have a sweet tooth, you will love it. Caution-its extra sweet. We liked the pecan ice cream and the Cuban coffee too, but the shave ice flavor made our day!

Every time I go the Key West this is a place I always visit. I bring everyone I know to this great ice cream shop. The rolled ice cream is always fresh and so delicious. Can’t wait to return.

The customer service was amazing!!! The guy who rolled my ice cream kept asking if I wanted different toppings thrown in to make it extra delicious! Some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had and such a cool experience! Highly recommend this place :)

This place is super chill! The owner and workers are all super friendly and go the extra mile to make sure you get exactly what you want! Great experience will definitely be back

When looking for a cute “mom and pop” ice cream place to take my family too, I didn’t realize it was going to be a whole dang experience! Their unique rolled ice cream was incredibly good, and you can watch them make it right in front of you…and you get a lot for what you pay for! My daughter didn’t waste her Hawaiian ice! Don’t sleep on Tropical Vibes! They’re the best around!!

This is one of the many food shops around town! They have rolled ice cream, which can be kind of fun. It's a little pricey and there are stores selling what they have for cheaper, so many just walk around before you go buy? Plus, it's an active place for the famous Key West Chickens!

Crew workers are nice and.. accommodating. We’ve visited this place 3 times. 2 out of those times they didn’t have any ice cream for one reason or another... they need better management across the board for equipment and stockage levels and restock orders.

I love this place. I don't usually eat ice cream, but I drink a lot of fruit smoothies. I usually make them myself in my Vita-Mix, but in Key West for a treat this is where I like to go. Smoothie Shuttle is good too, but they're a little confusing with all the additives and such; this is easy and quick and the people are very nice. And the smoothies are uber-delicious to my tastes! Occasionally when I exercise by riding my human-powered vehicles around the island I like to make this the end of the hard ride, and cool down with a creamy, satisfying fruit smoothie. As some have mentioned, the products are very sweet; if you don't care for that just ask them to use more tart fruit and less ice cream, they've always been very accommodating for me. Recommended.

My ice cream wasn't creamy and awesome, but broke my spoon when I tried to dig in and also had ice crystals in it. The chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream was practically vanilla with no cookie dough or chocolate chips. I was very disappointed but I am glad they have a military discount.

Just walked down there from our hotel and they only had 2 flavors. Was told they would make more the next day. It was 7pm and they don't close until 10pm, so it's not like we went in at the last minute. Went away buying nothing.

It's a good local ice cream parlor but not the best. The price is good but the quality is not exceptional but anyway it's Key West so everything is bit costly.

Brings new meaning to “ice” cream. Flavor was off as well as the texture. I would try one of the many other places down here.

Amazing caramel vanilla cupcake!! We went to several of the bakeries in key west, but this one was my favorite by far.

Something is always broken, which she didn't tell me until after I ordered and she started to make it and all of a sudden remembered. I used to live in Key West and the place was better as a Kohr Bros. The frozen custard is good but for the ridiculous prices, you should be able to get exactly what you want.

Please don’t call it custard if it isn’t. At best it’s just soft serve. Very nice lady working there.

This is not custard, more like soft serve. Big disappointment.

Amazing fresh fruit taste, full cups of deliciousness!!!

Tried the Key Line Pie sundae. Really good!

Every time I go they are closed! I want a frosty!

Gross. And not custard AT ALL!

Refreshing Key lime pie the crust was crispy. Very good I also had the toasted coconut ice cream. Very good not to sweet just right. Lots of things to buy.

Besides a slice or whole pie and other desserts, you can step in and find all sorts of key lime mechandise. Not only dessert but marinades, sauces, and rubs. They also have a section of clothing key west style of course.

Nice little shop had souvenirs,clothes snakes and ice cream. The key lime pie was great !!! Staff was very friendly. Key lime pie in key west is the best 👌

I’ve been recommended to try this place by a colleague from work in Phoenix. WOW!!! You can sample here almost everything, they do have them - so nice! I liked so much the ambiance of this store and the girls at the counter were so welcoming and cute. They have a huge diversity of key lime delicatessens- Key lime cookies, candies, cakes, coolers, chocolates, ice creams and more. The Kermit’s pie and pie on the stick is a must to try - so delicious, LOVE it! Will go again for sure when be back to Paradise. Would definitely recommend this place to everyone who’s visiting Florida keys. Cheers!

This wasn’t on our plan but noticed it while walking on the street. I wanted to try key lime pie in key west and accidentally stumbled on this place which had best key lime pie. I have never had key lime pie before so I cannot compare but it was delicious. Small cozy place which has few chairs outside. We sat outside eating our pie and drinking tea. Our son had ice cream. We saw few chickens running around which reminded me of my childhood back in India where chickens were just part of life in villages.

This is where I ate key lime pie. The real key limes are small but full of sweet juice. The locates all said to try here 1st so we did. Keep up the good work. I tried my first my pie on a stick, so neat.

THE most delicious key lime pie ive ever had in my life. Im not a fan of key lime pies, i dont usually order them as desert. But since i was here in key west, i decided to give it a shot and it was the best decision of the day. It was amazing. Every taste bud was happy. Very easy going atmosphere, really nice to eat the key lime pie on the porch looking at the interesting people.

This was the perfect addition to our surf themed baby shower. Not only was the cupcake sushi delicious, we loved the boat display with the custom sail we will hang proudly in the nursery. The consistency in quality, detail, and taste never ceases to amaze me, and we look forward to making cupcake sushi the star of all of our future events.

As always Lori is amazing! What a unique dessert to have at a wedding and we enjoyed it immensely. Thank you for being a part of our magical day! We also then continued to enjoy the Cupcake sushi for days after with family and friends since they kept requesting more. We will definitely plan to come back for more on our one year anniversary!

The sushi cakes were absolutely perfect and delicious! If you are ordering online, highly recommended. If you are in Key West and going to the shop for a visit, be prepared to be let down. The store looked like a cheap storage unit that a tornado went through. Papers and boxes and random junk thrown everywhere. No seating. Only one small glass case with a few trays for pickup. The atmosphere gets a zero, but with a fun idea like this it has potential to be awesome.

We ordered 100 sushi cupcakes for our wedding welcome party and they were delicious! They came in a super cute "sushi boat" with a sail that was personalized for our event. All of our guests loved the presentation of the cupcakes and the taste! We got a lot of compliments on them and would definitely recommend ordering your own as an addition to your Key West event!

Super yummy tiny cupcakes made like sushi. These are even patented. Many flavors to choose from.

As a former Key Wester I’ve enjoyed these exquisite morsels for years. Recently I hosted a party and was extremely pleased with the shipping they provided. And my friends in Sarasota went nuts over them!!

My neighbor’s daughter had this at her wedding reception and I was amazed and shocked on the cupcakes because they looked like sushi. I didn’t know at the time what flavors they had and tried a few. My favorites were yellow vanilla, red velvet, and double chocolate. The detail and work put into it was fabulous especially having a gluten free plate for people with gluten allergies which is very considerate.

My family went in there apparently right before closing to order ice cream. As we’re waiting we are told before ordering the only thing they will serve us is either on a cone or in a cup b/c they are closing. So we’re like ok I get it your closing no big deal we only want ice cream. We order and pay $40 for 4 cups of ice cream and the ice cream is delicious, but minutes after we order, as we are trying to finish it at table and we are told they have closed and we need to leave and eat our ice cream outside the restaurant. Completely rude staff and we weren’t being disruptive, just wanting to eat or ice cream we had just ordered. I understand they wanted to close up, but they could have started to close up and clean up while we finished up. I will never be back to this location and encourage everyone reading this to go elsewhere.

Ice cream and sorbet were good. Service was fine. Prices were RIDICULOUS. A mini - not small but mini - cup of ice cream and a mini - not small but mini - cup of sorbet, each barely reaching the top of the cup they were in, certainly not generous at all. And total came to over $19. I can’t imagine what it would cost if a family of five went there for good or normal sized ice cream cones!

Ordered one chocolate and one strawberry pint of ice cream. They sent me two strawberry. I ordered this through doordash. Try calling your phone and nobody answers it went to voicemail. Couldn't leave a voicemail please have voicemail is full. Try telling the doordash delivery driver and he kept on smiling at me saying yes and then realized he doesn't speak English at all. How does doordash hire somebody who can't speak English working in an English-speaking country why does a company even have a phone if they refuse to answer it

I'm sure the ice cream here is as good as the other stores, but the service was horrible. Some of our group still ordered but out of principle I had to leave without ordering. Plenty of other ice cream sellers!

Sales lady was unwilling to give us a little empty extra cup to let us give a spoon of our ice cream to our 10month old so she could nibble on a bit of ice cream on her own. Forced us to buy one cup of ice cream for 8.09$. Which is obviously way too much for a baby. Ice cream was standard Hagen dasz obviously so two stars

Prices were too high. One scoop was $8!! Crazy! Certainly not consistent with all the other desserts and food we ate in KW.

I got the mango sorbet and mint chip sundae - both delicious! Everyone complains about the price but seems to forget the pints of ice cream in the grocery stores are always pricey. It’s worth it for a vacation treat.

Hands down a staple of Key West! This ice cream was indeed homemade and the taste was absolutely amazing! Very humble people and friendly. Don’t visit without stopping by.. prices are reasonable too! Snickers, Cookie and cream and the coconut was my all star snack!

The owner recommended the peanut butter ice cream and WOW, I am so glad I listened! It’s rich, creamy, and absolutely loaded with that perfect peanut butter flavor without being too sweet. Every bite is smooth and indulgent, like peanut butter heaven in a cone. You can really tell it’s made with care and quality ingredients. Hands down, one of the best ice creams I’ve ever had and I never would have tried it if the owner hadn’t suggested it. 10/10 recommend!

While in the keys we wanted to stop for some ice cream . We found this spot and they had great reviews so we gave it a chance. I personally did not enjoy my ice cream and unfortunately neither anyone else. The ice cream is home made which means that it doesn’t have all the extra preservatives, however I melts ima second. Not even joking it water down immediately! The people were very nice. They do have great reviews. I would recommend to try for yourself, but it wasn’t for us. This spot is on a corner with a few sidewalk tables.

Absolutely the best thing we had in Key West! The fresh fruit sorbets are perfection! You must try a stop here on your next visit to the Keys!

Authentic as it gets - the peanut butter ice cream was some of the best ice cream I've ever had. Period. Texture was perfect, the taste was the perfect blend of peanut butter and cream. And then pair it with the banana ice cream with real banana pieces all throughout and it was INCREDIBLE. I will be back next time I'm in Key West!

Best ice cream on the island! Handmade fresh daily by the owner! It’s a must do every time I visit Key West and centrally located off Duval on front st.

The best cold treat in key west! Homemade Italian ice and ice cream - my fave is the watermelon ice! No fake flavor, just pure watermelon, perfectly sweet but not too much.

What a fun place! Who doesn't love ice cream and mini donuts with fun toppings. Cute sandy spot to eat at. Super friendly staff and we could hear the live music from next door. Great spot for a treat!!

A Sweet End to Our Key West Getaway! My husband and I stumbled upon Rooster Treats on our last day in Key West, and what a delightful find it was! I truly wish we had discovered it sooner so we could have gone back for more. I opted for the Cookie Monster ice cream, which was absolutely delicious – creamy and packed with flavor. However, the real showstopper was my husband's order: the Cookie Monster mini donuts. Oh my goodness, those were hands-down amazing! Fresh, warm, and utterly addictive, they were a perfect bite of heaven. Beyond the incredible treats, the atmosphere at Rooster Treats was fantastic. We loved the lively vibe, with music drifting over from next door creating a really fun backdrop to our sweet indulgence. The owner was incredibly friendly and genuinely grateful for our business, which always makes an experience even better. We also felt the prices were very reasonable, especially considering the quality and generous portions – we definitely got our money's worth. If you're in Key West and looking for a fantastic dessert spot with delicious treats and a welcoming atmosphere, Rooster Treats is an absolute must-visit. Don't make our mistake – go early and go often!

The donuts were a nice mid-day treat. We ordered birthday cake + fruity pebbles and the total came to about $9. 🍩✨ Ice cream flavors are limited and no cones are available, but you can customize your soft serve with a variety of wet and dry toppings.

We had the birthday cake mini donuts and the Cookie Monster Oreo mini donuts. Very cute and small treat. Will try the ice cream next time.

Delicious hot & fresh donuts! My husband got the cookie monster and my oldest got the chocolate paradise. My youngest got some vanilla ice cream with chocolate sauce and that was good too. The woman working the stand was pleasant and friendly.

Really cute spot with fresh donuts. The donuts mainly taste good because they are hot and fresh. The ice cream is okay, more icy than creamy in my opinion, not my favorite. Nice chairs and places to sit down and enjoy the treats. Very close to the southernmost point.

Super Slow to get the product (20 min on line) on Friday night. They make donuts fresh but they were good (cookie monster donuts) 1 person working. I had the key lime ice cream but it was more ice than creamy which was a little disappointing. It didn't taste really like a true creamy ice cream. My kids got the key lime pie ice cream, the Duval crawl, shark bite and chocolate paradise. They liked the ice cream all which were server with pralines. The ice cream was average price. They have a small area to sit and enjoy your order.

It's 86 degrees out but when the ice cream is melting inside the icebox your serving out of...time to fix your coolers. I had to put my three scoops in a cup instead....before walking 10 feet out of the store

This place is great and the ice cream is phenomenal. People are complaining about ice cream melting and leaving a bad review. Go back to 3rd grade and try again. Ice cream melts.

Ice cream was good Service was just okay but not surprising as the people at Key West just are not friendly at all.

Tourist are welcome. Welcome to get theyre money for two really, really small cups of ICE cream you'll Pay 16 Dollar and more. The quality ist Not more the Standart and that will be guaranted our last visit. Every one wants to ear money but not that way!

Probably because it is closer to the where the cruises dock, the prices are a bit high. But we liked the outdoor seating and enjoyed the ice cream on a warm day. I tried the orange sherbet and it was good. The kiddo tried a cookie dough Ice cream and he liked it as well. The lady who served it was kind and overall we had a good experience.

If Rude and nasty was a person! In an attempt to treat my family to ice cream and patronize this establishment, we witnessed the lady serve customers before us and then opened a package of cones with her bare hands. There was zero hand hygiene performed. I inquired about what I witnessed, and the lady became defensive. I didn’t want to disappoint our children, so I instructed them to order cups. My 10 year old was the first to order, but the lady was “bucking” at him and and rolling her eyes. I asked her to please not be rude to my children and was told “you either order and deal with the way I am speaking….. or”. I didn’t stick around to hear the rest. So rude! Stay away.

Good ice cream at a rip off price. We were waiting for our jet ski tour and decided to share a scoop of ice cream, we wish we would have read the reviews before going. I get this is a tourist town but wow, $9 for a one scoop in a waffle cone...it wasn’t that good. Also, we asked for sprinkles and got what you see pictured, less than a teaspoon for $1.00 extra! We told her we would not be paying for the extra “topping”. We will never return.

Walking into River Street Sweets in the heart of old Key West feels like stepping back in time—in the best possible way. As a kid, I remember visiting sweet shops just like this one, where the shelves were lined with endless rows of chocolates, candies, and handmade confections. Sadly, most of those magical places have disappeared… but not here. This shop captures that old-school candy store charm perfectly—and somehow improves on it. From the moment you walk in, the air is rich with the scent of caramel and chocolate, and you’re greeted with warm smiles and samples (yes, samples!). You can watch the candy-making process live, which adds a whole layer of excitement—especially for kids. The pralines are world-class, but honestly, you could spend an hour just deciding between all the fudge flavors, chocolate-dipped everything, brittles, gummies, saltwater taffy, and so much more. I wouldn’t be surprised if there are literally hundreds of options. Even though it’s in a high-traffic tourist area, I’ve never had to wait long, and the shop is well organized, clean, and fun to browse. The staff is friendly and patient, even when your kids are bouncing back and forth trying to decide what to get. I make it a point to stop in every time I visit Key West—it’s become a tradition—and my kids now look forward to it as much as I did when I was their age. It’s nostalgic, delicious, and a genuine highlight of every trip. Highly recommend if you’re in Key West. Even if you don’t have a sweet tooth, you’ll leave with a smile.

I had neglected to eat dinner because I was not hungry but I needed to fill my stomach fast. I chose two scoops of Butter Pecan Ice Cream ... Wow, It was delicious. Vhuntermassage LLC

Very expensive desserts but worth at least trying 1 thing if you’re a sweets fan, like me! They have so many different peanut butter cups,pretzels, candy and ice creams!

Very expensive to get a bag and choose candy, it was over $30 for us and we didn’t get that much. The taffy was gross, super soft and sticky even after putting them in a fridge overnight. Some of the wrappers were not closed up all of the way, and most of them were sticky on the outside. I don’t recommend getting candy there, maybe their ice cream is better.

River Street Sweets is great! The staff are kind and friendly. They have a ton of great chocolate, candy, and ice cream. Beautiful and colorful interior. Without doubt a great candy store worth going to! Have a great day!

Had the ice cream and the fudge, both were very good. 4 of 5 stars instead of 5, because 2 cones and 2 pieces of fudge was almost $40.00. I know it’s on Duval street, but my lord !!

It’s a lot of fun. Ice cream was good had a pretty neat selection. I would recommend it. Just don’t go out of your way for it. I would love to tell you all of you go to try the Carmel corn. They make it in house and watching them do it is pretty cool. I will say the atmosphere and aroma are both very inviting. Is it something that I would put on a travel blog no. But if you’re staying for a few weeks or even live here, it’s definitely worth a try. The other thing I especially loved about. It was the air conditioning. It gets really hot in the Florida Keys. So having AC in shade is a treat on its own.

Good ice cream here. Bad news was the gal working was not very friendly and seemed all irritated. Good service goes a long way. Ice cream is a hard one to mess up but bad service will. Not a huge assortment of ice cream but the store was clean.

Had a delicious s’mores flavor I got to enjoy the walk back to the room. The storefront is tiny but has a really cool vibe because of it. We got helped super quick and the ice creme was perfect. It’s also in a fantastic location for you to pop in when walking around.

I don’t do this often, but this was a brutal experience. We love Ben and Jerry’s ice cream, but the service at this location was very disappointing. My husband and I arrived 20 minutes prior to their listed closing time (11:00pm). There was one female employee behind the counter on her phone, who greeted us, and stated we would be helped momentarily. We then watched this employee walk back and forth behind the counter, while playing on her phone. My husband and I continued to wait patiently, while she continued for about ten minutes to ignore us. Twice, she poked her head around the corner towards the establishments bathrooms, calling for a second employee to come take our order. Finally the second employee showed up, and took our order. All to find the shake machine was “broken”. Honestly, the shake machines appeared to have just been cleaned for the evening. My biggest complaint isn’t about the machines, it’s about how the employee playing on her phone wouldn’t help us and continued to yell for another employee to help us instead.

By far my favorite ice cream in key west. Large selection of flavors and my favorite is the fresh waffle cone they make! Staff is super friendly and helpful, and Moses the manager is very kind and helpful The cleanest I’ve cream shop I’ve ever visit! Must try there ice cream cake as well

We stopped by with our 3 year old for a late night snack. Really good ice cream with lots of different flavors. The staff were friendly and quick with our orders. There are some places to sit and eat. Restroom is available. Merchandise was also available but expensive.

It was expensive but I guess it made sense given the location. We are big fans of Ben & Jerry’s and always visit if they are nearby. I think they had very limited flavors compared to other locations!

Always great cakes and ice cream. It would be nice if there were a larger selection of ready made ice cream cakes. There were only 2 choices when I went. But I was happy with the strawberry ice cream cake I got.

I took my family for treats tonight and everything was so good. I grew up in Central Texas and the flavors were a trip down memory lane. I highly recommend going and trying their homemade authentic Mexican treats! I’m definitely going to be back soon!!!

This is honestly the creamiest ice cream I’ve had in my life! Nice atmosphere and kind employees.

A do-not-miss experience. Easy parking in Searstown plaza away from Key West crowds -- located conveniently on the drive in or out of Key West, La Michoacana is not anything like your standard, American ice cream shop. Not much on looks, but wowwie! It's like walking into a tropical taste treat of fruity and creamy ice creams and rich sorbet-like flavors made with yummy, fresh fruits, cream, and more. Innovative combos. We loved the Hot Banana -- a sundae with vanilla ice cream, warm caramelized cooked-banana sauce with real banana pieces supplemented by fresh banana slices. Also the more exotic, huge cup of mango sorbet combined with strawberries-and-cream ice cream. Not Baskin Robbins typical strawberry but thick streaks of real, deep red strawberry puree in an unusual, delicious vanilla ice cream topped with small cubes of real mango and I'm not sure what else, but it was super yummy. We didn't get to try the spectacular "popcicles" (shaped more like ice cream bars on sticks). They belong in a modern art museum. Exotic flavors, some embedded with big fruit cross sections. There are ice cream, dairy-free flavors, and huge shave-ice type snow cones drenched in creamy or fruity sauces. If savory is on your menu, the shop also has a few mini-meal treats -- large cups of a saucy Mexican street corn concoction, a flat-bread/pizza-type slice piled with some wild toppings, and more. Think Haagan Dazs does Acapulco at the corner of Mexico City and Sears parking lot!

Don’t come here if you are on a diet! Too good! The service is great, the product is unique- I had the corn ice cream and it has become my new favorite ice cream. Will come back when I visit the keys again

Excellent! Great service and Ice cream. Wide variety of things to choose from. I want to especially congratulate Randal the owner for his great customer service!! This place has a great family environment. 5/5 and if I could give it a 10/5 I would!! Recommend!!

The best ice cream in Key West! Amazing all homemade ice cream. The owner gave us personalized service too. Don’t look any further! This is the place to go in Key West. I rate it 10 out of 10. Ruby says go there it’s the best.

Found La Michoacana by chance. I had the Mangoberry-pop. It was delicious. The young man beind the counter was so helpful and polite, our Icecream was amazing. They make their own icecream bars, which all look so yummy. I had the Strawberry Cream, so delectable.